Home » New films: The Witch, Race, Risen & The Lady in the Van
Film • Review

New films: The Witch, Race, Risen & The Lady in the Van

The Witch
Written & Directed by Robert Eggers

OK, I’m doing it again – focusing on the movie I liked least, as there are some interesting points to note about this production, as well as some notable flaws. “The Witch” is a feature length writing and directorial debut for Robert Eggers and although it was a miss for me, I would recommend it to those who enjoy low budget horror films or who aspire to make them.

Set in a 1630’s New England colony, this simple story revolves around a family that’s banished from the small village because the husband/father’s interpretation of scripture doesn’t match that of the village elders. We see the family leaving with what we assume are all of their worldly possessions on the back of a small cart and we rejoin them after what seems to have been approximately a year at their homestead on the edge of a creepy, dense wood which, we learn, they generally avoid going into as it has a bad reputation.

This of course raises the question of why they would build their new house in that location. There’s also a small stream which may have been more important than the fear associated with the wood, but either way they chose a spot that essentially restricts their movement to one side of their lot. They also appear to have built a significant amount in a relatively short time – including a two-story house with split planks and finished plasterwork. This is in addition to a barn and a small goat shack, both of which seem more like the level of craftsmanship one might expect.

Suddenly, it seems, things start to fall apart – their crop is failing and then the baby disappears while being cared for by the oldest daughter. It’s hard to determine how they’ve been managing up to this moment, as they also seem to have very limited experience at hunting, but whatever has happened previously this is clearly a turning point. It might have been better, resulting in fewer plot holes or questions, to have simply started the film with the family already established in this location and somewhat settled prior to a change in circumstance.

The loss of the baby is blamed on a wolf but there’s also concern about the possible involvement of a witch who might live in the woods and the family dynamic and relationships very quickly deteriorate as a result of this, with fingers being pointed in all directions. In some ways, rather than being a creepy story about witches, the film plays like an indictment of fundamentalist religion and the speed with which blame and sin are assigned to previously loved family members.

I’m not the best judge of films like this because I tend not to get creeped out or scared very easily, which also leaves me pondering many of the details that the target audience would probably skip over as they get wrapped up in the set pieces. From that perspective “The Witch” seemed slow and empty, as if it would have made a better short film than a feature film. However, what I found most interesting about the film, and unusually endearing these days, is just how simple the production is. It’s a film with little or no special effects and, but for the overly elaborate set design, it’s a film that many amateur filmmakers could emulate through lighting, camera angles, and careful editing.

I found the film ponderous to watch and the plot actually seemed to make the least sense when it wasn’t introducing supernatural elements. But I can imagine “The Witch” being inspirational to some young filmmakers working with limited resources and budgets. I just hope they aren’t similarly inspired by the soundtrack which constantly amped up the music regardless of whether anything bad was about to happen. That’s a trick that can work once or twice but it’s not something that can be sustained throughout a film.

Moviebriefs

Probably the best new wide release of the week (not an especially high bar) is “Race” which tells the story of Jesse Owens rise to fame and his successes in the 1936 Berlin Olympics. The Games were intended, by Hitler and his inner circle, to be a showpiece for the Nazi Party in all of its self-perceived glory. However, other countries were already aware of the early stages of the Nazi’s persecution of Jews and other minorities, and there were many who favored boycotting the Games altogether. The horrors that came later, at the hands of the Nazis, are well known but what “Race” does well is remind us that America during that period had its own bigotries to overcome. Stephan James is solid as Owens, but Jason Sudeikis as his coach always feels like he’s on the verge of an imminent comedy skit. It’s also odd watching a room full of American Olympic officials debate a potential boycott when two of the three main figures are English (including Tim McInnerny, who rather coincidentally plays a British Olympic official in next week’s “Eddie the Eagle”). Another interesting aspect of the film is the inclusion of Leni Riefenstahl (played well by Carice van Houten, who is perhaps best recognized as Melisandre in “Game of Thrones”), seen making her epic propagandist documentary “Olympia” about the Games. This is one of those stories that has so much appeal and interest that all it needs is to be told in a manner that doesn’t detract from the subject matter, or overly complicate the many elements, and on that level “Race” delivers effectively enough.

There’s a certain déjà vu quality to watching “Risen” so soon after watching “Hail, Caesar!” as it has elements that are reminiscent of the primary film within that film (in which George Clooney’s actor character stars as a Roman who is overwhelmed upon meeting Jesus of Nazareth). In “Risen,” Joseph Fiennes stars as a loyal Roman Tribune who, as Pontius Pilate’s enforcer, is tasked with the burial of Yeshua* and a later extensive search for his missing body. It’s an interesting take on the bible story, retelling the resurrection through the eyes of a non-believer whose entire sense of self and the world are shaken when he meets a living man whom he had previously seen as a corpse. A film like this can’t bring much in the way of storytelling suspense and the subject matter will divide audiences (I watched several people walk out) but, to its limited credit compared to some films of this nature, it does at least inject a certain amount of color and ethnic variety into its cast, with a few of the actors looking like they could have had origins (or maybe a vacation) in the Middle East. Yeshua, is played by Cliff Curtis who is actually of Maori descent and who seems to be asked to play almost every ethnicity in films (somewhat like Ben Kingsley). Meanwhile, the disciple Bartholomew* has the blond/blue-eyed appearance of so many modern depictions of Jesus. (*Note that while Yeshua is the Hebrew form of Jesus, the other Hebrew names are Anglicized in a manner that undermines any attempt at linguistic authenticity and makes the use of Yeshua rather pointless.)

Fans of Maggie Smith will likely enjoy “The Lady in the Van,” in which she plays the opposite end of the socio-economic scale from her frequent depictions of the likes of the Dowager Countess Grantham in “Downton Abbey.” Here she plays the part of a real life woman who lived in a van, including for many years in the driveway of English author Alan Bennett. Bennet, played by Alex Jennings in a manner that takes a little getting used to, is depicted in two parts – the man who interacts with the world around him, including the woman who inserts herself into his life, and the writer who observes these goings on and records the parts that seem interesting enough. It’s an effective approach as it inserts an extra character, providing an inner dialog for Bennett and an opportunity for us to hear what’s going on in his head during this extended invasion of his personal life and space. Over time he discovers that the woman has a convoluted past and his fascination with her, along with a level of timidity that precludes direct confrontation or action, overcomes his sense of revulsion regarding her circumstances. This is likely to be one of the oddest true stories of the year but it’s also a neat little film.

About the author

Tony Sheppard

Tony is a Professor at Sacramento State, Co-Director of the Sacramento Film & Music Festival and a long-time writer, primarily on topics related to film and the film industry. He is an active supporter of the local arts community, an amateur photographer, and has an interest in architecture and urban planning topics. He is currently designing a 595 sq.ft. house on a very small infill lot in Sacramento.

Topics

   
Share via
Copy link