Noah
Directed by Darren Aronofsky
“Noah” is a difficult film to review, for assorted reasons. It’s a story that is integral to many religious groups and their collective teachings, although the story varies across those groups. Meanwhile, for those who aren’t religiously inclined, or who are religious but don’t read scriptures in a literal sense, it’s still a very familiar story but not an especially complex one. Taken in its basic form, as represented in the Book of Genesis, it wouldn’t make for much of a movie, at least not one that would appeal to vast numbers of modern movie-goers – there’s no villain and no dramatic love story, for example, and the entire plot is well known.
[Oddly, this is true of that other great boat story, “Titanic” – which also needed to have a villain and a love story added in order to garner mass appeal. And if your only goal is to watch a story about people fearing death by drowning who end up on a vast, allegedly unsinkable ship, you could always watch “Titanic” backwards. But let’s not go there.]Consider the source material, the basis for this adaptation. The Noah story is most closely associated, typically, with the Book of Genesis. But Genesis itself has multiple sources and those who don’t read it as the exclusive writing of Moses, generally look at it as having two primary authors (based on style and conflicting content). Much of the content was old in terms of existing written and oral traditions even when it was written by those hands and the flood story is a very close copy of stories that appeared in Mesopotamian culture, including in The Epic of Gilgamesh, as well as in Greek mythology and in at least one even earlier Sumerian text.
Flood stories aren’t especially unusual, but some of these bear remarkable similarities (enough to be assumed to be the same story handed down). However, other details appear to have shifted over time, with the earliest focusing more on local flooding, or river flooding, than on a global flood. Which may or may not matter, of course, given that in the periods in question, the idea of ‘the world’ was very different and more limited than ours today. Even a regional flood would have appeared to cover all known land for a people with a limited range of travel and would have similar practical outcomes.
In Genesis, there is mention of the ‘sons of God’ – who fathered children with the ‘daughters of men.’ Interpretations of this differ, but ‘sons of God’ are often said to have been fallen angels who fathered a race of giants with human women. These fallen angels are sometimes referred to as ‘Watchers’ and their offspring as ‘Titans’ or the ‘Nephilim’ (spellings or variations of many of these words and names vary from translation to translation).
But for every book, or compilation of writings, that made it into the official, canonical collection(s), there are others that did not. Some of these are heavily referenced in other writings, with both citations and manuscript fragments that exist, and some also discuss the flood legend. For example, the Book of Enoch which includes sections thought by some to have come from a separate Book of Noah. The first section of the Book of Enoch is the Book of Watchers – and is focused on those fallen angels and their offspring. This is interesting because much of the alleged sin amongst the men of the earth was attributed to the teachings of the Watchers, such as the forging of metals to make weapons. And the chaos and destruction is pinned on the Nephilim, as giants who destroyed the land. The implication being that, in flooding the earth but saving Noah and his family, God was ridding the earth of the Watchers and the Nephilim, rather than ridding the Earth of humanity. Noah, as a righteous man, was saved to repopulate the Earth, much as pairs of animals were saved for the same purpose.
But what most of the texts, and the assorted versions of the story, seem to agree on is that a very large boat, or ‘Ark,’ was built at God’s command and that Noah, his wife, his sons and their respective wives, (and a great many animals,) all survived the flood by boarding and remaining on the boat. In Islamic texts, additional righteous people also boarded the Ark while others, including at least one other son of Noah, were excluded. However, even where the various accounts agree on Noah, his three sons, and their wives, the identity and names of the women vary significantly.
All of which leads one to realize that in attempting an adaptation of the Noah story, one could head in multiple directions and write several different narratives that could each have supporting source material. And all of them would upset somebody whose particular set of beliefs weren’t the ones captured on film. So any attempt to satisfy all religious audiences is bound to fail before one even starts, and the only relatively safe approach is to attempt to capture the spirit of the story (or underlying stories) while also making a compelling film for non-religious audiences. But such a compromise also runs the risk of not actually appealing to anybody.
In Aronofsky’s “Noah,” Noah as a young boy witnesses the death of his father Lamech at the hands of Tubal-cain, a descendent of Cain (and a biblical character) and the film’s proxy for all things bad that humankind at large has undertaken. And suddenly we have a villain, whether or not the death of Lamech when Noah is a child fits any biblical account (and regardless of any other confusion as to lineage).
“Noah” also has the Watchers, as fallen angels, who have become creatures of rock and earth who have witnessed and sometimes helped the fall of man while desperately waiting and hoping for a reprieve from ‘The Creator.’ There are no separate depictions of the Nephilim, although that’s probably to simplify things as much as any specific attempt at picking a narrative.
Noah and his family, specifically his wife and sons, live a simple existence away from the chaos of other people – or ‘Men’ as Noah refers to them, as though a different species or form of existence. Noah teaches his sons to take only what they need and can use, and they live a spartan, vegetarian life on the fringes of what is almost a post-apocalyptic wilderness caused by over-mining and over-population.
The depiction of these people and places feels more Tolkienesque (in a Peter Jackson sense) than biblical, much of the time, and watching Noah and his family seeing surprisingly industrialized cities and mining operations, is reminiscent of hobbits visiting Saruman’s Isengard, for example. Even the Watchers seem similar to Tolkien’s Ents, as large, slow moving, but long-lived witnesses to the destruction around them. And the clothing is more patchwork business casual than robe or toga.
With a clear villain we get violent conflict, with Tubal-cain attempting to take over the Ark as the flooding begins – and there are also moments when Noah is depicted as an action hero, killing those who threaten his family. But Aronofsky also gives us significant internal familial conflict by running counter to the source material (almost all of it as far as I can tell) in excluding the presence of wives for two of Noah’s sons. At least some of this relates to another interesting narrative choice – the compression of time.
In Genesis, Noah is 500 years old when he has his sons and the building of the Ark takes 100 years. In “Noah,” ages and time periods are largely avoided and his sons are still young as the flooding starts. In particular, this sets up his middle son, Ham, for conflict with Noah as he is desperate for a wife of his own. There’s much more family drama going on in the film than just that detail, and I’ll skip the rest to avoid spoilers – but suffice to say that these aspects of the film seems relatively original and also somewhat problematic. It’s likely to annoy the purists and muddles the character arcs for others. For example, the conflict between Noah and Ham takes on a completely different form.
It’s also an odd choice to include aspects of the story that seem fantastical on the one hand, such as fallen angel rock monsters, while on the other hand leaving out a detail like the lifespans that are described in Genesis. We’re shown divine intervention in the form of the instantaneous growth of flowers and trees, and yet we’re apparently sheltered from the idea of men living to 900+ years or of the boat taking so long to build.
And so we’re left with an odd compilation of parts and influences that seem likely to disappoint rather than to enthrall audiences. It’s a well made film, with high production standards and reasonably solid special effects. It’s also well acted – most notably Russell Crowe as an extremely conflicted Noah, Jennifer Connelly as his wife, Ray Winstone as Tubal-cain, Logan Lerman as an unhappy Ham, and Emma Watson as a girl adopted by the family and who becomes the oldest son Shem’s wife.
But the narrative is the problem here. By not following any particular religious source material religiously, most fundamental readers of scripture are likely to be offended. At the same time, the basic concept of an angry God, disappointed in his creation and eager to start over with a blank slate, and the inherent conflict that causes for the people involved, is present and may satisfy more liberal readers of scripture. But it doesn’t lend itself well enough as a compelling action adventure for others – it’s essentially a relatively simple story that telling upon telling has already largely spoiled, but with added and awkward drama that attempts to provide new twists but which also undermines existing themes.
Which leaves the other, loudest theme of the film previously unmentioned. This is a retelling of the flood story, transformed into a lesson about environmental stewardship and sustainability. Aside from ideas of divine creation or intervention, it’s a story that warns of the dangers of strip mining and over-development, for example, and of wanton disregard for nature and the resources we have – whether given to us or found. It sets apart man as both guardians of the planet and as destroyers of it, with that balance being of paramount (pun intended) importance.
And that’s an odd takeaway – to walk out of a film about Noah and feel more like it was sponsored by the Sierra Club than by a major religious group. The outcome is a well-intentioned but inherently muddled film that may struggle to find an audience, other than Aronofsky fans and the cinematically or religiously curious who simply want to check it out for themselves.


2 Comments