Newest articles on The Sacramento Press tagged as "legal"

Ask the County Law Librarian -- Affirmative Defenses to Fraud

2012-02-09T23:01:33Z

Q. What are some affirmative defenses to fraud?

Ayana

For those readers who aren’t familiar with the phrase, an affirmative defense “sets forth facts from which it results that, notwithstanding the truth of the allegations of the complaint, no cause of action existed in the plaintiff at the time the action was brought.” Goddard v. Fulton, 21 Cal. 430, 436 (1863). In plain English, the defendant in a case can present information or evidence that reduces or eliminates his liability, even if the allegations in the complaint are true. Affirmative defenses are the legal reason why, even if everything happened just as described by the plaintiff, the defendant should not be held liable.

There are too many affirmative defenses available to list here. We have a very useful set at the law library that may help you determine appropriate affirmative defenses in your situation called California Affirmative Defenses.

There are some that can be used in almost all case types, and others that are specifically counter allegations of fraud. In order to assert the proper affirmative defenses, you will need to carefully review the complaint and the plaintiff’s allegations.

A common affirmative defense for many types of cases is a violation of the Statute of Limitations, or failure to file an action within a certain period of time after the “wrong” involved was committed. The Statute of Limitations for Fraud is three years. California Code of Civil Procedure § 338(d).

Statute of Limitations questions are always tricky, but particularly so with fraud, because the statute does not start to “accrue,” or start running, until the aggrieved party discovers the facts constituting the fraud. California Code of Civil Procedure § 338(d). You can read more about the statute of limitations for fraud at the Law Library in California Practice Guide: Civil Procedure Before Trial: Statutes of Limitations.

A common affirmative defense for fraud cases is failure to plead a cause of action with specificity. A little explanation of this defense may be helpful. A cause of action for fraud must be pled with “specificity,” meaning that allegations of fraud must be described in a complaint with much more detail than other causes of action. This is to “give defendants notice of the particular misconduct . . . so that they can defend against the charge and not just deny that they have done anything wrong.” Neubronner v. Milken, 6 F.3d 666, 672 (9th Cir. 1993). Each element in a cause of action for fraud must be factually and specifically explained--the “who, what, when, where, and how” of the misconduct must be listed. Vess v. Ciba-Geigy Corp. USA, 317 F.3d 1097, 1106 (9th Cir. 2003).

To determine if the complaint is pled with specificity, you will need to carefully review all allegations, and determine if all elements are adequately described. The elements of fraud are (1) a misrepresentation, concealment, or nondisclosure by the defendant; (2) the defendant’s knowledge of the falsity of the misrepresentation; (3) the defendant’s intent to deceive the plaintiff; (4) justifiable reliance upon the misrepresentation by the plaintiff; and (5) resulting damage to the plaintiff. California Civil Code § 1709. In order to describe the first element, for example, a “plaintiff must set forth what is false or misleading about a statement, and why it is false.” Decker v. GlenFed, Inc , 42 F.3d 1541, 1548 (9th Cir. 1994).

There are further affirmative defenses to fraud, of course, but without knowing more about the specific fraudulent act you are interested in, it is hard to say which would be most relevant to your situation. If you visit the Law Library in person we’d be happy to show you the references mentioned above and more, based upon the facts of your situation.

You should know, however, that we are in the process of moving to a new location and will be closed until on or about March 1. While we’re closed, you can still visit our website at www.saclaw.org for a wealth of information, including sample forms and instructions for navigating a variety of common legal procedures. Our website may be down for a couple of days while we move our computers, but you can “like” us on Facebook or “follow” us on Twitter for the latest details on when that might happen, and exactly when we will re-open. We sincerely hope you will visit us in our new location and that the many amenities of 609 9th Street (including abundant street parking!) will make you think it was worth the wait!

Do you have a question for the County Law Librarian? Just email sacpress@saclaw.org. If your question is selected your answer will appear in next Thursday's column. Even if your question isn't selected, though, I will still respond within two weeks.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian
www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian -- Law Library Closing for Move; Re-opening March 1

2012-02-04T18:04:01Z

Q. What’s going on at the Law Library? There is yellow caution tape across the stairs to the second floor, which is closed to the public, and there’s a whole lot of banging and clanging going on up there!

Ted D.

A. Sorry about the noise and disruption, Ted! We’re doing our best to keep it quiet, but the sound you hear coming from the second floor is the result of having workers dismantle our rather large shelving units--we’re preparing for our move to a new facility about two blocks on the other side of the courthouse.

The Law Library and Civil Self-Help Center will be closed starting at noon on Friday February 10. We expect to open in our new location at 609 9th Street (corner of 9th & “F”) on or about March 1, 2012. Until February 10, if you need any material on our second floor, please don’t hesitate to ask a reference librarian—we’d be happy to run upstairs and get it for you!

While we’re closed, you can still visit our website at www.saclaw.org for a wealth of information, including sample forms and instructions for navigating a variety of common legal procedures. Our website may be down for a couple of days while we move our computers, but you can “like” us on Facebook or “follow” us on Twitter for the latest details on when that might happen, and exactly when we will re-open.

You may also visit the Witkin State Law Library of California or the Yolo County Law Library, which are the two nearest law libraries open to the public in the Sacramento area. The Yolo County Law Library has graciously volunteered to remain open an extra hour, until 5:30 pm, Monday through Friday for the month of February to accommodate our patrons.

Again, we apologize for any disruption in service, but we sincerely hope you will visit us in our new location and that the many amenities of 609 9th Street (including abundant street parking!) will make you think it was worth the wait!

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian
www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Recovering Money for Property Damage by Tenant

2012-01-20T01:03:41Z

Q: In July 2011, I contracted a new driveway for my home. The cost was $3300. I paid extra for cement coloring. My tenant parked his car on the new driveway and caused permanent stains on both sides of the driveway due to leaks from his vehicle. In October 2011, he tried cleaning it but was not successful. He gave me a hand written note giving up on cleaning the stains. In November 2011, I hired a professional to clean the stains and not all of the stains were removed. He refuses to pay for the damage on the driveway or claim fault for his negligence. This incident has caused a disharmony between us. He knew his vehicle needed repair but was too lazy and stingy to repair his car. We have a written contact that requires his vehicle be maintained if he is to park on the driveway.

He gave his rent termination notice on January 1, 2012 to vacate the premise by January 31, 2012. We have a month to month rent agreement. The living arrangements have been hostile as he says that I have to sue to collect. He has also made the two rooms and bathroom he rented from me unclean, and refuses to clean it. I gave this tenant with his two kids a very clean living arrangements when he moved in on March 1, 2011.

There is also a possibility that he may not vacate my property on January 31, 2012 as I can see the bank notices for his bounced checks he gets in his mail.

How do I make this tenant from hell pay for the property damage? and evict?

Myrna

A: Thank you for your question! It seems you have a couple of issues, let’s tackle the driveway damage first. You didn’t mention if your tenant gave you a security deposit when he moved in. If he did, you may be able to withhold some of it to recover the property damage. California Civil Code §1950.5 primarily governs security deposits; be sure to read each section carefully to be aware of the various requirements for both the landlord and the tenant. Also the California Department of Consumer Affairs has a very good article discussing when a landlord can keep security deposits.

If there was no security deposit left, then Small Claims court is a common venue for disputes over property damages. It has the advantage of being very quick, with cases typically being heard in only a few months, and of being relatively inexpensive. You can sue in Small Claims for up to $10,000, and your damages fall well within this limit. Before filing, you should write a formal demand letter requesting payment for the damages to the driveway, possibly including an estimate for the cost of repairs. You can get help writing your demand later from the California Courts Self-Help Center.

At the law library, we suggest reading Everybody’s Guide to Small Claims Court in California, a very useful book on the small claims process. Every county in California has a Small Claims Advisor that can assist you with your case free of charge. You can find county-specific court information including Small Claims Advisors here: http://www.courts.ca.gov/selfhelp-advisors.htm .

For your second issue, if your tenant becomes a “holdover tenant”, meaning he won’t leave after his notice expires, you will need to formally evict him. A book at the law library that should help with this issue is the California Landlord's Law Book: Evictions , available for purchase at Nolo Press, or to view at our law library, which discusses the process and has sample forms and instructions. You may also want to visit the Unlawful Detainer Advisory Clinic, located in the Carol Miller Justice Center. The clinic assists both landlords and tenants in filling out answers and complaints, preparing cases for trial, and filing post judgment motions.

You can always do some research at the Sacramento County Public Law Library. The law library has print and electronic resources and friendly reference law librarians are available to assist you.

Do you have a question for the County Law Librarian? Just email sacpress@saclaw.org. If your question is selected your answer will appear in next Thursday's column. Even if your question isn't selected, though, I will still respond within two weeks.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Court-Appointed Attorneys in Civil Cases

2012-01-12T22:49:21Z

Q. I accidentally bumped into the back of a car at a stop sign--I barely even tapped the bumper, I took a picture and you can hardly even see the tiny dent--but now this jerk is suing me for "soft tissue neck trauma," aka whiplash. He is asking for $100,000 for pain and suffering!!! I was laid off about a year ago, before the accident, and still can’t afford car insurance, much less an attorney, even if I could find one who would take my case—I looked and looked! What are people in my situation supposed to do? I did nothing wrong, I could lose everything, and no one will help me! Why won’t the Court appoint a lawyer to defend me?
- Sandeep

A: We’re all very familiar with the phrase "If you are unable to afford a lawyer, one will be appointed for you.” We hear it every time someone is arrested on TV or a movie. Generally, the court will only appoint an attorney to ensure that a defendant’s Sixth Amendment “right to counsel” is met, in situations where the defendant cannot afford to hire an attorney. The Sixth Amendment provides that “in all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy … the assistance of counsel for his defense.” Originally, this amendment applied only to felony cases, but a series of US Supreme Court decisions have broadened this right to cover nearly all types of criminal cases. However, this amendment is speaking specifically about criminal proceedings, not civil cases.

In California, the court cannot appoint an attorney to represent either party in most civil cases. A recent law, AB 590, does provide for the appointment of counsel in “civil matters involving critical issues affecting basic human needs.” This has been interpreted to mean cases in which shelter, nourishment, safety, or child custody are at stake. The law provides funding for projects run by local legal aid organizations, and services are limited to those who fall at least 200% below federal poverty level. It’s unlikely that your case would meet these criteria. If you are unable to hire an attorney at your own expense, you’ll have to pursue your defense of this case on your own.

If you’re a Sacramento County resident, some assistance may be available to you for this type of case from the Civil Self-Help Center. The CSHC can provide general information and basic assistance to self-represented litigants with certain case types. Common types of cases they can help with include personal injury, property damage, and breach of contract. Keep in mind, though, that their services are “self-help.” This means YOU are in charge of your case. They won’t do everything for you, like an attorney would if you hired one. If you decide to pursue this case on your own with help from the CSHC, you need to be in control of your case, you need to understand and determine your own strategy, and you need to keep on top of deadlines, court dates, and other important milestones. The Law Library has a variety of books and other materials that will help you at each step of your case. The Law Librarians are happy to help you find the books and other resources to help you with your case.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

Ask the County Law Librarian – Providing For Pets In The Event of Death or Incapacity

2012-01-05T19:14:51Z

Q. I am trying to get my affairs in order and I am concerned about what will happen to my three dogs should I die or become incapacitated. Can I leave money in a will or trust for my dog's care?

Suzy

A. You cannot leave money or other kinds of property directly to your dogs because the law says that animals are property. I know most people that have pets consider them to be family members, but the law sees it differently, therefore your pets cannot be a beneficiary in a will. There are a number of things you can do to make sure your pets are provided for when you can no longer care for them.

You can choose a new owner for your dogs and make it a legally binding decision by including it in your will. A provision like: "I leave my three dogs Caldonia, Eli and Keeva to my friend Jennifer Lynn. " Obviously, you should talk to Jennifer before including such a clause in your will. Also consider leaving this new owner some money to go toward the costs of caring for your pets.

You can set up a Pet Trust which names someone, a trustee, in charge of managing and spending the property you leave for the benefit of your dogs. The trustee follows a written set of instructions that you provide. One advantage of a trust is that it takes effect before your death. The provisions in a will don't have any legal effect until you die.

For sample will clauses and other related information the New York City Bar Association has an informative website:
http://www.abcny.org/media-aamp-publications/brochuresbooks/556#Introduction

The law library has two books published by Nolo: Nolo's Simple Will Book, and Plan Your Estate both by Denis Clifford which can help on this topic. Also a great resource for all things related to dogs is Every Dog's Legal Guide, A Must-Have Book For Your Owner by Mary Randolph which is also published by Nolo. This website has a number of articles reprinted from Every Dog's Legal Guide: http://doglaw.hugpug.com/doglaw_073.html

When you are drafting your will or trust consider a contribution to rescue groups, humane societies and other non profits. A gift can help many animals. If you need help on the wording or have other questions the organization will be more than happy to provide assistance.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian
www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian – Recording Telephone Calls

2011-12-29T23:43:06Z

Q. My ex won’t pay her child support. Whenever we go to court, she claims she has no income, but she has boasted to me before that she is making money under the table and I’ll never get any of it. I bet I can get her to admit it again. Is it legal to record a phone call?

Chris

A. Don’t do it! It is illegal to record a phone call, or any private conversation, in California unless both parties know that the conversation is being recorded. You might also be sued for “intrusion.” Even if this doesn’t scare you, the tape would be worthless: it cannot be used as evidence in a court case, except your criminal trial.

Under California Penal Code 632(a), recording or eavesdropping on a confidential conversation without the consent of all parties is a crime. The penalty for a first offense is up to a year in jail or state prison, a $2,500 fine, or both.

Note that this applies to any “confidential communication,” whether it is in person, on the phone, or by some other device, as long as the eavesdropping or recording is done with an “electronic amplifying or recording device.” The term "confidential communication" includes any conversation in which is “carried on in circumstances as may reasonably indicate that any party to the communication desires it to be confined to the parties thereto.” California Penal Code 632(c).

Your ex might also be able to sue you for $5,000 or more. California Penal Code 637.2 provides that anyone injured by a violation of the eavesdropping and recording laws can sue for $5,000 or three times actual damages, whichever is greater.

If you do record your conversation, the recording will almost certainly be inadmissible in court. California Penal Code 631(c) states that “Except as proof in an action or prosecution for violation of this section, no evidence obtained in violation of this section shall be admissible in any judicial, administrative, legislative, or other proceeding.” In other words, you can’t use it to help you, but it can be used against you to prove you broke the law.

California actually has some of the strongest anti-eavesdropping laws in the US. In many states, it is legal to record a phone conversation as long as one person knows it’s being recorded. In these “one-party states,” people generally may record their own conversations without the consent of any other parties but cannot grant that right to a third party. Reporters have an obvious interest in the laws on this subject, and you can find an overview of all 50 states’ laws on the website of the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press.

There might be other ways to prove that your ex is hiding income or spending more than she claims to earn. If you come in to the library, we have books that can give you ideas of the types of records to subpoena and questions to ask to help you do just that.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian
www.saclaw.org

How Registered Sex Offenders can Challenge “Jessica’s Law” Residency Restrictions

2011-12-22T17:30:03Z

Q. My brother is going to get out of jail soon, and we were planning on him moving in with me, but his parole officer told him he couldn’t because he has to register as a sex offender and I live too close to an elementary school, which is against “Megan’s Law” or “Jessica’s Law” or something like that. Isn’t there anything we can do? I’m afraid if he doesn’t live with me he will be homeless.

Jerri

A. California’s Megan’s Law requires anyone convicted of a wide range of crimes, including forcible sex crimes involving non-consenting adults and most sex crimes involving children, prostitution, and child pornography, to register as a sex offender upon release on parole or probation or discharge from custody. California Penal Code § 290. Proposition 83, the Sexual Predator Punishment and Control Act, or “Jessica’s Law,” which amended Megan’s Law on November 8, 2006, forbids any registered sex offender from living within 2,000 feet of a school or park where children regularly gather. California Penal Code § 3003.5(b).

Your brother is not alone in facing a very bleak prospect. According to the Prison Law Office, a nonprofit public interest law firm which engages in class action and other impact litigation on behalf of prisoners, these residency restrictions have forced many parolees to become homeless because they are unable to find affordable, compliant housing.

Jessica's law has been challenged in courts as being too restrictive. Your brother may wish to ask a court to review his case. The Prison Law Office, which has been involved in many of these challenges, has produced a packet of forms and instructions that parolees can use to ask for an immediate stay of the restrictions while their individual cases are being heard by the courts. The packet is available for free on the web at http://www.prisonlaw.com/pdfs/ModelHabeasFull,Dec10.pdf. An additional fill-in-the-blank form, required by all California state courts in this type of case, can be downloaded from the California Courts’ website at http://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/mc275.pdf.

You should be aware that local cities, towns and counties are permitted to adopt ordinances which impose further restrictions on where you can live. If you are not in Sacramento and are unsure whether your residence is in compliance with local law, check with someone who is familiar with your community’s laws.

Good luck!

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian
www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian -- Small Claims Defendant Can Postpone Trial for "Good Cause"

2011-12-08T23:06:14Z

Q. I am involved in a Sac small claims action that continues to be postponed by the Defendant. I'm trying to get the matter over with. So now I'm wondering: what does "Form SC-105, SC Order and Answer do? Is it a way to expedite a case or ask a judge to review my evidence and rule in advance?

The small claims advisors don't return calls and don't answer their phone. Any assistance would be appreciated.

Thank you
Carol

A. I understand your frustration in wanting to resolve your matter as quickly as possible! Form SC-105 is a generic motion form. It is used to ask the court to make a decision about a specific issue in your case, such as amending a judgment to include other names the defendant uses. This form cannot be used to get a judgment on the case.

According to California Code of Civil Procedure § 116.570, any party has the right to ask the court to postpone a hearing date for “good cause.” The code section does not limit the discretion of the court to grant additional postponements for “good cause” as necessary.

The request for postponement can be made either by writing a letter or by using Judicial Council Form SC 150, Request to Postpone Trial. The request shall be filed at least 10 days before the hearing date, unless the court determines that the requesting party has “good cause” to file the request at a later date. If the court finds that the interests of justice would be served by postponing the hearing, the court shall postpone the hearing, and shall notify all parties by mail of the new hearing date, time, and place.

According to Nolo.com’s legal dictionary, “good cause” is a legally sufficient reason for a ruling or other action by a judge. It is up to the other party to provide adequate proof that a postponement is required. Ultimately, it will be at the judges’ discretion if the postponement request is granted.

Try to be patient with the Small Claims Advisor; this is the time of year when self-help centers are busiest. It may easier to obtain services by going there in person rather than through the telephone.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Credit Card Surcharges

2011-12-01T19:55:22Z

Q: I stopped at a new convenience store near my house on my way home the other night, and when I went to pay for my purchases I noticed they had a note taped over the debit/credit card machine that said I would be charged an extra 75 cents if I paid with a debit or credit card, unless the total purchase was $10 or more. Well, I had no choice since it’s the end of the month, so I used my credit card and paid the extra 75 cents, but I was steamed! Is this legal?
-- Cody

A: Credit and debit cards are a convenient option for many consumers. However, they can be very expensive for merchants, who must pay the issuing bank a fee every time they swipe a card. These fees vary, based on the issuing bank and the type of card, but generally range from 1-3% of transaction amount, plus a per-transaction flat fee of 5-20 cents. For merchants with a small profit margin, these transaction fees can really be a drain on their bottom line. Some merchants try to pass these fees on to the customer by imposing a fee for using a credit or debit card.

California Civil Code 1748.1 prohibits merchants adding surcharges or any additional fees when a customer pays for goods or services using a credit card. However, the law does allow merchants to offer “cash discounts” to encourage customers to pay with cash or check, rather than a credit card. Although the outcome is similar – customers paying with a card are charged more than those using cash – there is a fundamental difference between a credit surcharge and a cash discount. With a credit surcharge, the consumer is paying more than the marked price simply because they’re using a card for payment. This can lead to an unpleasant surprise at the register, when the bill is more than the customer would expect based on marked prices. With a cash discount, customers paying with a card pay the marked price, while customers using cash pay less than the marked price. Customers paying with a card are charged the expected amount based on marked prices, while cash customers get a welcome discount.

Although credit card surcharges are illegal in California, there is no law limiting surcharges for debit card transactions. Last year, then-Governor Schwarzenegger vetoed SB 933, which would have prevented merchants from imposing surcharges when consumers use debit cards. However, the merchant agreements for both Visa (rule 6.3) and MasterCard (rule 5.11.2) prohibit the practice.

Keep in mind that “convenience fees” for using credit or debit card are allowed for some merchants, under both state law and merchant agreements. These are generally available to public-sector merchants, like schools, utilities or the IRS.

Until recently, merchants were legally prohibited from setting purchase minimums for credit card use. This was changed with a provision of 2010’s Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act. The new law allows merchants to set a minimum purchase as high as $10, as long as it is applied to all cards, regardless of issuer.

If you believe a merchant is in violation of State or Federal law or their merchant agreement, you can make a report to your credit card company, or to the California Attorney General’s office.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian: Collecting on a Small Claims Judgment

2011-11-18T17:47:17Z

Q. I am the Judgment Creditor in a small claims case. My judgment was by default. In lieu of a debtor’s examination I am planning to use interrogatories. Is my debtor entitled to a witness fee? Also, is a judgment debtor entitled to witness fees for coming to a debtor’s exam?

Thank you,
Grant

A. Good news! You will not need to pay the debtor any witness fees.

After plaintiffs win a judgment, they are on their own trying collect it from the defendants (now called the "debtors"). In order to find out what assets the debtor has, and where they are located, plaintiffs are entitled to do post-judgment discovery, including interrogatories and an in-person debtor's examination.

The law authorizing post-judgment interrogatories does not require witness fees. (California Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) section 708.020.) CCP § 708.020 also refers to the rules on pre-trial interrogatories. (CCP §§ 2030.010 and following.) Those sections do not require a witness fee, either.

A debtor’s examination also does not require a witness fee. Debtors’ examinations are covered by CCP § 708.110 through CCP § 708.205. While CCP § 708.120 provides that a third party who is examined is entitled to mileage, it makes no such provision for the debtor. (Generally, third-party witnesses are entitled to receive "ordinary witness fees" of $35.00 per day and $.20 per mile, round trip. Cal. Government Code § 68093.)

You mentioned that this was a small claims case. I’m curious whether the debtor sent you a Statement of Assets. In small claims cases, the debtor is automatically required to send you a “Judgment Debtor’s Statement of Assets” (Judicial Council Form SC-133) within 30 days of the Notice of Entry of Judgment. CCP § 116.830. You don’t mention whether the debtor did this, and I’m guessing not, since it covers the same questions you most likely would ask in your interrogatories – employment and pay information, bank accounts, real estate, and personal property. If you didn’t receive it, the debtor is technically already in contempt of court.

If you didn’t receive the Statement of Assets, there is a special form to use to set up a debtor’s examination after a small claims case: “Order to Produce Statement of Assets and to Appear for Examination” (Judicial Council Form SC-134). (If you did receive it, but need more information, you would use an “Application and Order for Appearance and Examination,” Judicial Council Form EJ-125.) To get copies of documents such as pay stubs, you can use the “Small Claims Subpoena and Declaration” (Judicial Council Form SC-107) or a standard “Civil Subpoena Duces Tecum” (Judicial Council Form SUBP-002).

If you want more information about the examination or your other options, you may want to contact the free Small Claims Advisor at the courthouse. You can find out more about their free services by visiting the Sacramento County court’s Small Claims Court website. If your case is in another county, check the California Courts website for a link to your county’s advisors . For information on this and many more subjects, visit the Sacramento County Public Law Library, “Providing Free Public Access to Legal Information for over 100 years.”

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - When does a minor have to get parental consent for medical care?

2011-11-10T17:40:21Z

Q. I’m currently working on a project for my ethics class. In this project I play the role of a risk manager who provides information to a 15 year old patient asking for medical emancipation. Do you know of any good resources where I can find more information on medical emancipation because I haven't been successful in my research? Thank you so much for your time, I appreciate it very much.

Best Regards,
Maria

In most cases, parental consent is required for a minor’s medical treatment. There are, however, exceptions, known as “medical emancipation” statutes. These statutes, which allow minors to consent to medical treatment without parental knowledge, approval, or consent, fall into two categories: “general” medical emancipation statutes, which are based on a minor’s status, and “limited” medical emancipation statutes, which apply to specific, designated medical conditions. Academy of Pediatrics v. Lungren, 16 Cal. 4th 307 (1997).

Examples of general medical emancipation statutes are California Family Code § 7002, which provides that a minor who has become emancipated by reason of a court order, marriage, or active duty in the United States armed forces is considered an adult for purposes of consenting to health care services; and California Family Code § 6922, which provides that minors who are 15 years of age or older, living away from home, and managing their own financial affairs, regardless of the source of their income, may consent to their own medical care.

Limited medical emancipation statutes cover certain circumstances where the state’s interest in protecting the health of minors is considered to outweigh a parent’s right to make medical decisions on behalf of their children. Minors may be reluctant, because of embarrassment or fear, to tell their parents about medical conditions resulting from specific conduct. Consequently, minors may postpone or avoid seeking needed medical care if they are required to obtain parental consent prior to receiving treatment for those conditions. California’s limited medical emancipation statutes include:

Family Code § 6924(b) A minor 12 years of age or older may consent to mental health treatment, counseling, or residential shelter services if (1) the minor is mature enough to participate intelligently, in the opinion of the health care provider, and (2) the minor is either a danger to himself or herself or others without the treatment, or is the alleged victim of incest or child abuse.

Family Code § 6925: A minor of any age may consent to care related to the prevention or treatment of pregnancy.

Family Code § 6926: A minor 12 years of age or older may consent to treatment of an infectious, contagious, communicable, or sexually-transmitted disease.

AB 499 (2011): Beginning in January 2012, minors 12 years of age and older may consent for medical care related to the prevention of sexually transmitted diseases.

Family Code § 6927: A minor 12 years of age or older may consent to treatment of care related to the diagnosis or treatment of rape.

Family Code § 6928: A minor of any age may consent to care related to the diagnosis or treatment of sexual assault.

Family Code § 6929 A minor 12 years of age or older may consent to care related to the diagnosis or treatment of drug- or alcohol-related problems.

Health & Safety Code § 121020: A minor 12 years of age or older may consent to HIV testing.

For more information on medical emancipation, see www.teenhealthlaw.org. For information on this and many more subjects, visit the Sacramento County Public Law Library, “Providing Free Public Access to Legal Information for over 100 years.”

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian- Divorce Nullifies Power of Attorney Between Spouses

2011-10-27T19:49:09Z

Q:
Hello I'm e-mailing with a question about the law of Power Of Attorney. My parents have been divorced now since "2006” in "2005" my Dad gave my Mom Power Of Attorney over his personal affairs. My parents have been separated since "1989" but have always maintained a good relationship. Lately my Dad has been showing sing of early Alzheimer’s and we have concerns because it seems that due to their divorce the Power Of Attorney is no longer valid! Is this a fact or is there something we can do to ensure that My Mom remains a vital part of My Dads affairs! I’m not sure and we need to know because there are properties involved and health care issues. So if u could help us out with some helpful info it would be nice. Thanks!!
-Iris

A:
I’m sorry to hear about your dad’s ailing health. It is true that in California, a divorce will nullify a power of attorney, if it was created between spouses before the divorce. The California Probate Code states that if after executing a power of attorney the principal's (your dad) marriage to the attorney-in-fact (your mom) is dissolved or annulled, the principal's designation of the former spouse as an attorney-in-fact is revoked. The California Probate Code also states that the power-of-attorney can be revived by the principal's remarriage to the attorney-in-fact.

If remarriage is not a possibility, and if your dad has the legal capacity to make the decision, he can execute another Power of Attorney listing your mom as the agent or attorney-in-fact. If your dad is able to understand and is willing to sign a Power of Attorney or Advanced Health Care Directive, these may be all that is needed to re-instate your mom’s authority. These forms are available at the law library’s website at http://www.saclaw.org/pages/forms-page.aspx .

However, since your dad is suffering from early Alzheimer’s, he may not be competent enough to do this. The law library has several books you can look at to help determine legal capacity, including: Capacity and Undue Influence: Assessing, Challenging, and Defending: Here's How and When To Do It published by CEB.

If your dad does not have the legal capacity to execute another Power of Attorney, then a Conservatorship may be an alternative for your family. A conservatorship is a legal arrangement in which a responsible adult oversees the personal care or financial matters of another adult considered to be incapable of managing alone. The person who cannot care for him or herself is called the conservatee. The person or organization the judge chooses to do this is known as the conservator. A conservator can be a family member, friend or professional person. California law on conservatorships can be found in the Probate Code beginning at section 1800.

A California conservatorship must be formally established through a court proceeding. The proposed conservator must first file a Petition for Conservatorship to initiate the court proceeding. Once the petition has been filed, the clerk will set the matter for hearing. The hearing will generally be set 45 days from the date of filing. Sacramento County may have some local forms requirements.

The law library has created Legal Resource Guides on Power of Attorney and Conservatorships that will help you get started in your research. These Legal Resource Guides are available from the law library’s website at http://www.saclaw.org/pages/legal-research-guides.aspx .The law library also has other materials available, including sample forms and general information that cover both of these topics.

Do you have a question for the County Law Librarian? Just email sacpress@saclaw.org. If your question is selected your answer will appear in next Thursday's column. Even if your question isn't selected, though, I will still respond within two weeks.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Past-Due Traffic Tickets

2011-10-20T21:22:32Z

Q: I got a traffic ticket a while back, and missed my court date. I’d totally forgotten about it until I got something in the mail last week, saying I owed money on my outstanding ticket. It’s a huge amount now, with interest and late fees, etc. Can I ask for a payment plan or community service? I don’t have the money to pay the ticket right now.

-Tanya

A: The payment of past-due traffic tickets is handled through the Sacramento County Department of Revenue Recovery. Periodically, the agency sends out letters regarding outstanding balances, in an attempt to collect money owed to the County. If you receive a letter from the Department of Revenue Recovery and wish to pay the amount in full, you can do so online, by mail, or in person. Unpaid tickets are eventually assigned to a third-party collection agency.

If your outstanding ticket is still being handled by the Department of Revenue Recovery, the court still has jurisdiction over your case. This means that the court can still change the amount you owe, order traffic school, allow community service, etc. To make this type of request, you will need to go to the traffic court at 301 Bicentennial Circle between 8am and 4pm, Monday-Friday. You will receive a same-day hearing.

Once an outstanding ticket is assigned to the collection agency, the court no longer has jurisdiction over your case. This means that the court can no longer modify the amount you owe, or allow options such as community service or traffic school. Your must negotiate directly with the collection agency about setting up a payment plan. Your driver’s license will remain suspended until you pay all fines and fees on your record.

If your ticket was due to be paid before January 1, 2009, you may be in luck. The state recently announced a limited-time “Amnesty Program” for outstanding court debts. With this program, California Superior Courts are offering a 50 percent off discount on some old, unpaid traffic tickets. The program will be available January 1, 2012-June 30, 2012. The eligibility requirements may vary from county to county. More information about the amnesty program is available at www.courts.ca.gov/partners/941.htm.

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Renters' Rights in Foreclosures

2011-10-06T22:04:52Z

Q. I have been renting a house for more than a year. I just got a notice that the house will be sold at auction at the end of this month. Do I have to move out then? That’s not nearly enough time to find a new place! And do I have to pay this month’s rent? I will need the money for a deposit on a new place. -Allan

A. Don’t worry – you will not have to move out at the end of the month. Exactly how long you have depends on who buys the property at auction, and whether your lease is month-to-month or until a certain date, but you will get at least 90 days notice. The trustee’s sale may even be delayed – this frequently happens. But you do have to keep paying rent!

With all the foreclosures going on, this situation is pretty common. When the mortgage crisis started, tenants were caught in a real bind – foreclosure wiped out any leases that were signed after the loan was taken out, and the new owner could evict them on 60 days notice.
This caused so much hardship that a new federal law was passed protecting tenants: the “Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act of 2009” (Pub. L. no. 111-22, 123 Stat 1660 (2009)). This law expires on December 31, 2012, unless Congress extends it before then.

Under this law, if the mortgage loan is “federally related” (almost all are), the lease survives the foreclosure. This means that the tenant can stay until the end of the lease. Month-to-month tenants must get 90 days' notice before eviction. The law doesn’t apply to tenants who are close relatives of the former owner who got a sweetheart deal for below-market rent.

There is an exception for buyers who plan to move in to the home themselves. In this case, the lease ends, but the tenants are still entitled to give 90 days’ notice.

So if your lease extends until a certain date, and the property becomes bank-owned, you are set until the end of the lease. If your lease is month-to-month, the bank must give you at least 90 days notice to move out. If the buyer plans to live in the home, you must receive 90 days notice to move out.

You do still have to pay rent though! You can still be evicted for cause, including non-payment of rent. Starting on the day of sale, rent should be paid to the new owner. If you have a security deposit, the new owner should also be responsible to return it when you leave.

For more information, read the Nolo article “Tenants in Foreclosure: What Are Their Rights?” or the Nolo Press book “California Tenant’s Rights.” The California non-profit group Tenants Together sponsors a “Foreclosure Rights Hotline” at 1-888-495-8020. Housing and Economic Rights Advocates has a more extensive list of tenants’ rights in foreclosure, including discussions of cash for keys, right to maintenance, and more.

Good luck!

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian
www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian – Service by Publication

2011-09-29T22:16:14Z

Q. I want to sue this guy who sold me a bill of goods, but he has disappeared off the face of the planet and I can’t find him anywhere. I thought I read somewhere that I could just put a notice in the newspaper and that would be ok. How do I do that?

A. When filing a lawsuit, you are required to serve the other party with your summons and complaint, to notify them of the lawsuit. If the other party cannot be located, you will have to ask the court for permission to publish the summons in the newspaper. Publication of Summons, as set forth in California's Code of Civil Procedure section 415.50, is considered a method of last resort. The court can only approve your request for an Order for Publication of Summons if you show that the other party cannot be served in any other manner. You will need to prove to the court that you have made exhaustive attempts to locate the other party. The California Courts Self-Help Website suggests numerous ways to track people down under “Finding Someone in Order to Serve Him or Her” at http://courts.ca.gov/selfhelp-serving.htm. The Law Library also has a guide to “Finding People & Businesses,” available on our website at http://www.saclaw.org/pages/finding-people.aspx.

After all these attempts, if you are still unable to locate the other party, you may ask the court for permission for publish your summons in the newspaper. To do this you must complete an “Ex Parte Application for Order for Publication of Summons,” a “Memorandum of Points and Authorities,” a “Supporting Declaration,” and an “Order for Publication of Summons” for the judge’s signature. You must also obtain declarations from anyone else involved in the search for the other party. There are no fill-in-the-blank forms for these documents, which must be typed on 28-line pleading paper and otherwise conform to the California Rules of Court, starting with Rule 2.100, and any other local rules regarding the format of papers to be filed with the court. Luckily, the Law Library has prepared sample pleadings, and instructions for completing those pleadings, that you can download for free and adapt to your facts and circumstances at http://www.saclaw.org/pages/legal-research-guides.aspx. Scroll down and look for "Service by Publication: Step-by-Step."

Most often the reason a request for Publication of Summons is denied is because the court does not feel that adequate steps have been taken to attempt to find the person to be served. If the court grants the order to publish, however, your next step is to publish the Summons in a newspaper of general circulation in the location where the party was last known to reside. The newspaper will publish your Summons once a week for four weeks, then provide you with confirmation of publication. Pursuant to Government Code § 6064, service is deemed complete on the 29th day after the first date of publication. If the other party has not filed a response 30 days after the effective date for service, you may file for default against the other party. You will then be able to continue your case without the other party’s participation.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian
www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Suing the Government

2011-09-15T20:36:51Z

Q-
I want to sue the State of California, the County of Sacramento, the City of Sacramento, and any other state or local government entity that was involved in depriving me of my civil rights in an incident last March. I was talking about my plans with my cousin, and she told me the statue of limitations was six months. I thought the statues were longer than that--years, not months. Irregardless, I'd better get started--so how do I sue the State?

Trinity

A-
Thanks for your question. Bringing an action against a public agency or its employee presents special procedural requirements. Before a lawsuit or complaint can be filed with the court, the injured party must first file a claim with the government agency. The agency will typically conduct an investigation and either agrees with your allegations and settles the matter with you or disagrees, and rejects your claim. Once the claim is rejected, you will be notified in writing that you can pursue the matter in court. This is often called your “right to sue letter”. According to the California Government Code section 945.6, you will need to sue within 6 months of receiving the letter, but other “statute of limitation” sections may apply, particularly if you do not receive the written letter.

For your claim, the California Government Code section 910 sets forth the requirements for the required contents of the claim. However, in order to help people comply with this section, “fill in the blank” claim forms are provided by many government agencies and are often available on the internet. For example, claim forms for the State of California, the City of Sacramento, and the County of Sacramento are all available online. For other local government agencies, the law library has put together some information on finding other Government and Police claims.

If the agency you are hoping to sue does not have a claim form available, you can always draft your own using samples here at the law library. I would suggest looking at book called California Government Tort Liability, a practice guide published by CEB. It is a great place to start your research into this area of law, particularly since there are specific time limitations for filing a claim and many immunities within the act which you will want to take a look at. Finally, once you get your right to sue letter, you are ready for the next step: to file a lawsuit in court.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Patenting Recipes

2011-09-08T22:31:38Z

Q: I recently opened a bakery where I use recipes that have been in my family for generations. I’m worried about my competitors getting a hold of these recipes, and using them in their own bakeries. Can I patent my recipes, to keep them from being used elsewhere?
Thanks!
Arielle

A:
Recipes can be patented, as long as they meet the requirements that apply to any other type of invention. There are several basic requirements you will need to meet in order to patent your recipes.

First, your recipe must fall into one of the patentable subjects described by Federal law. To be patentable, your invention must be a "new and useful" process, machine, manufacture or composition of matter. The US Supreme Court has ruled several times that the only categories of things that cannot be patented are laws of nature, natural phenomena, and abstract ideas. Generally, recipes would fall into one of the patentable categories.

Federal patent law also requires that your invention be useful. As long as your invention is capable of achieving a useful result, it will meet this requirement. A delicious baked good is, in my opinion, a useful result.

The next two requirements are usually the biggest hurdle to obtaining a patent. Federal law requires that your invention be “novel” and “nonobvious.” “Novel” means that it has some significant physical or methodical differences from all prior inventions that are publicly available before the date of your invention or more than one year before your patent application. “Nonobvious” generally means that someone who is skilled in the particular field would consider the invention to be an unexpected or surprising development. It cannot be just the next logical step or change to an existing patent.

These two requirements may be a problem for you in patenting a recipe. To meet the “novel” requirement, you will need to prove that your recipe is significantly different than any other recipe that came before yours, and that was not publicly known more than one year before you apply for the patent. If your recipe has been in your family for generations, chances are it’s been publicly known for years. For your recipe to be “nonobvious” it will need to include something that would surprise skilled chefs. Simply adjusting ingredients and measurements will not likely be enough to make your recipe nonobvious.

Federal law also limits patents to the inventor or discoverer. This means you can only patent your own recipe. You probably cannot patent your grandmother’s recipe, since you did not write it yourself.

After reading all this, you may decide that a patent doesn’t suit your situation, and wonder how you can protect your recipes from other bakeries. Companies like Coca-Cola and KFC rely on trade secret law to keep their secret recipes out of the hands of competitors. A trade secret can be anything that gives you a competitive advantage, such as a special recipe or formula. To be considered a trade secret, you must take steps to prevent competitors and the public from accessing your recipe. Unlike a patent, there is no application process for a trade secret. Instead, you just take reasonable precautions to keep your information secret, like keeping your recipes locked away when not in use, or having your employees sign a nondisclosure agreement. The Uniform Trade Secrets Act prevents others from copying, using, or benefitting from your secret without your permission. If anyone steals or divulges your trade secret, you can ask the court to issue an injunction preventing further disclosure or use of your trade secret. This law does not protect against people “discovering” your secret, by reverse engineering your recipes, though. The Nolo Press website offers more information about trade secrets.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian
www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian -- Public Access to Mug Shots

2011-08-25T19:46:42Z

Q. Is it possible to obtain an individual's booking photo using the booking number at a County jail?

Thank you,

Rebecca

A. There are several reasons a person might want to see booking photos (also known as “mug shots”). They are a popular part of news stories on crime, especially when celebrities or particularly newsworthy crimes are involved. In some cases, a person may want a photo to help them identify a person who may wish them harm, but whose appearance may have changed. Academic or other studies may be another potential use for booking photos.

Although a few police or sheriff’s departments routinely release booking photos, and some even post them online, in many cases they are reluctant. You can start by simply contacting the sheriff department or jail records department and requesting the photo. You may find, however, that many—including the Sacramento county jail—will not release them in response to a simple request.

Your next step could be to file a request under the California Public Records Act (California’s equivalent to the Freedom of Information Act). The CPRA (California Government Code Sections 6250 through 6276.48) requires public agencies to permit inspection of their records.

According to the advocacy group First Amendment Coalition, it’s unclear under California law whether the police are required to release booking photos.

Booking photos are a “public record” (“any writing [including photographs] containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any state or local agency”). (Cal Government Code 6522(e).)

However, records of investigations and investigatory files compiled by law enforcement agencies are exempt from the CPRA requirements. (Cal. Government Code 6524(f).) In 2003, the California Attorney General issued an opinion that mug shots fall within this exception. 86 Ops. Cal. Atty. Gen. 132, 135 (2003). As a result, law enforcement agencies may, but are not required to, disclose them. Attorney General opinions do not have the force of law, but courts tend to give them great weight when deciding a legal question for the first time.

The 6524(f) exemption itself has an exception: the agency must release the arrested person’s “physical description including date of birth, color of eyes and hair, sex, height and weight,” in addition to the name of the person and information about the circumstances of the arrest. The First Amendment Coalition suggests that “[o]ne could argue that a booking photo falls into this category of records that must be released, since it does no more than visually show information that a law enforcement agency is required to release anyway.”

To use the CPRA to get a booking photo, your first step is to write a request letter. The First Amendment Coalition has a sample of what such a letter should include.

If the letter does not work, you can try re-filing the request with a higher-up official, or you can file a lawsuit to enforce your CPRA rights right away.

If you file a lawsuit, and the court agrees that the records should have been released, you are entitled to reimbursement of your fees and any attorney costs. The First Amendment Coalition has a useful page on filing such a lawsuit. They also offer a Find-A-Lawyer service to match potential litigants with First Amendment specialists, sometimes at reduced rates.

Do you have a question for the County Law Librarian? Just email sacpress@saclaw.org. If your question is selected your answer will appear in next Thursday's column. Even if your question isn't selected, though, I will still respond within two weeks.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian
www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian – How to Stop Wage Garnishment

2011-08-18T17:34:54Z

Q. I just got a default judgment against me by a credit card company. I didn’t bother answering the summons and complaint because I figured I didn’t have any defenses—I spent the money but couldn’t pay the bill. A friend told me they could go after my wages, now, though, and take 25% of them until my credit card bill is paid. I don’t make that much money; we live paycheck to paycheck and I can barely afford to feed my family and pay my rent and other bills, which is how I got into this problem in the first place. Can they really take a quarter of my paycheck? Is there anything I can do about this now?

Jin

A. You could attempt to obtain “relief” from the default judgment, but you must prove you had a specific reason under California law, for example, “excusable neglect” under the Code of Civil Procedure § 473(b), for a court to grant relief from a default judgment. Forgetting about the lawsuit, being too busy to properly respond, or being unable to afford an attorney are not grounds for excusable neglect. You also must show that you have a meritorious defense to the original case. Given what you said in your question, it doesn’t sound like you would be successful pursuing relief from default, but you should read the Legal Resource Guide about the process on our website at http://www.saclaw.org/pages/relief-from-default.aspx, so you know all the options.

A judgment creditor can go after your bank accounts and other personal property, your real property, and even put a lien on a lawsuit you have against someone else. You can read about those measures on the California Court’s Self-Help Website at http://www.courts.ca.gov/1179.htm. “Wage garnishment,” however, is probably the most popular method creditors use to collect judgments, because it is the quickest and easiest. A creditor can garnish, or take, up to 25% of the amount you earn over the federal minimum wage, unless part of your paycheck is exempt under other rules.

In order to garnish your wages a creditor must ask the court for a Writ of Execution, which is an order directing the Sheriff to enforce the judgment in your case in the county where your assets are located, and an Earnings Withholding Order (EWO). Once granted, the Sheriff serves your employer with the EWO, which requires the employer to pay part of your earnings to the Sheriff. Once your employer instructs you that they have received an EWO you have 10 days in which to file your Claim of Exemption and a Financial Statement with the Sheriff’s department listed on the EWO. There is nothing you can do until your employer receives the EWO.

A Claim of Exemption is the form you must file with the Sheriff to explain why some or all of the wages the creditor wants your employer to garnish should be exempt (excluded). Enforcement of Judgments, Form EJ-155, lists most of these exemptions.

Your employer will hold on to the money garnished until either: 1) 10 days go by and the creditor does not oppose your claim of exemption; or 2) the judge makes a decision on the claim of exemption. If the creditor does not oppose your claim of exemption, you employer will return the wages to you.

If the creditor opposes your claim of exemption, you will receive a Notice of Opposition to Claim of Exemption and Notice of Hearing on Claim of Exemption that will set a court date for a judge to make a decision, probably within the month. If the judge agrees with your claim of exemption, you will get your money back. If the judge agrees with the creditor, your employer will send the money to the creditor every month until your judgment is paid in full.

The court reviews all oppositions to claims of exemptions and makes a Tentative Ruling on whether to allow a claim the day before the scheduled hearing. These Tentative Rulings are posted and available for viewing after 2:00 p.m. on the day before the scheduled hearing. The tentative ruling will become the final ruling on the matter unless either party asks for the hearing to be held. If you would like the judge to hear oral arguments, you must notify the other party, the other party's attorney, and the department clerk of your intent to appear at the hearing no later than 4 p.m. the day before the scheduled hearing. If you do not give this notice, your hearing will be taken off the schedule and the tentative ruling will become the final ruling of the court. For more information on the Court’s Tentative Ruling System and how to view the tentative rulings, see the Legal Resource Guide on our website at http://www.saclaw.org/pages/tentative-rulings.aspx.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian
www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Serving Legal Documents to a P.O. Box

2011-08-04T20:29:15Z

Q-
I am involved in a court case and need to serve legal documents and the only address I have for the other person is a mailbox at a UPS store and someone told me that I can’t serve a P.O. Box, is that true?
Joseph

A-
The answer depends on what type of P.O. Box you are trying to serve. If it is an actual post office box that is offered by the federal government, through the United States Post Office, then it cannot be served. However, according to the California Business & Professions Code § 17538.5, you can serve a Commercial Mail Receiving Agency (CMRA) which is commonly referred to as a “post office box” even though legally it is not. CMRAs offer private mailboxes, and these are technically not P.O. boxes. If you know that the person you are suing has a mailbox with a commercial mail receiving agency, you do have the option of serving the agency location with copies of your legal papers.

You are able to serve a commercial mail receiving agency because when a customer rents a private mailbox at one of these agencies, California law requires that they sign an agreement which authorizes the CMRA owner or operator to act as agent for service of process for the mail receiving service customer.

Even if the person you are suing has terminated their private mailbox, California law requires that CMRAs accept service of process for and on behalf of any of their mail receiving service customers for two (2) years after termination of any mail receiving service customer agreement. So you may be able to serve the owner or operator of the CMRA within two (2) years after end of the private mailbox rental agreement.

Below are some general steps for serving a CMRA:

1. You must verify the location of the private mailbox. Contact the U.S. Postal Services office and ask for the location of the box. This has the added benefit of allowing you to verify that this box does indeed belong to a CMRA, and is not a federal post office box, which cannot act as agent for service of process.
2. Ask a friend, process server, sheriff, or anyone over 18 years of age and not a party to the case to serve the CMRA owner or operator with copies of your claim.
3. Though not required by law, it is always a good idea to mail a copy of the plaintiff’s claim to the private mailbox itself.
4. The CMRA will send all documents by first-class mail to the last known home or personal address of the mail receiving service customer. Make sure to serve the CMRA at least fifteen (15) days prior to your hearing date.
5. File a completed Proof of Service form with the court clerk five (5) days before your hearing date.

Check out the law library’s Legal Resource Guides for more information on serving your papers.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Calculating Child Support

2011-07-28T18:41:58Z

Q: My ex and I were divorced many years ago, when we were both working at different jobs than we have now. Teenage boys are very expensive, and more child support would really help! I don’t know if it’s worth the hassle of all the paperwork, though, if the support amount won’t change much. Is there any way for me to estimate how much the new order would be?
- Rachel

A: Typically, child support orders can be modified anytime circumstances change, such as unemployment or job promotion. If it’s been several years since your support was determined, and if you’re working at different jobs, it’s very possible that your support order can be modified.

California has a statewide guideline for calculating how much child support should be paid. These guidelines are outlined in California Family Code section 4055. The formula is fairly complex to calculate by hand, but luckily, the website of the California Department of Child Support Services has an online child support calculator to help you. This is the official calculator used by Family Court Commissioners.

The amount calculated using the formula or the calculator is only a guideline. The court takes into account many factors when determining child support. The main factors are discussed on the California Court's Self-Help website's Child Support page.

The family law Self-Help Center may be able to help you with your support questions. They can't represent you in court, but they may be able to help you with selecting and completing the proper forms to modify your child support order. The Self-Help Center is located in Room 113 of the William R. Ridgeway Family Relations Courthouse and is open Monday through Thursday from 8:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m., excluding court holidays.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - "Safe & Sane" Fireworks on New Year's Eve?

2011-07-07T21:16:13Z

Q. Hello,

I found your website and I have a question about fireworks. I happen to have been born on New Year's Eve and always thought it would be fun (weather permitting) to have some of the Red Devil fountains to light . . . I guess they are called safe and sane now . . . in my day, that meant Red Devils!

So, is it legal to set off California legal fireworks any time of year? If not, would I need a permit or something? Also, is it legal to purchase fireworks online, as long as they meet a safe and sane standard?

Also, I would most likely be celebrating with friends in Citrus Heights . . . does that make a difference?

FYI, we would either use the street, or the driveway. I'm totally willing to get oil drip pans and fill them with clay cat litter to catch the sparks. We always have a bucket of water, a hose and a fire extinguisher handy.

Thanks! Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Pamela

A. Hi Pamela!

Nice to see that someone else is concerned with safety when it comes to handling fireworks. Personally, I think “safe and sane fireworks” is an oxymoron, but I realize I am in the minority.

According to the California Code of Regulations, a license isn’t required for the use or discharge of “safe and sane” fireworks. 19 CCR § 981. The specifications for “safe and sane” fireworks is set forth in 19 CCR § 986.6. You can search the California Code of Regulations at http://ccr.oal.ca.gov/linkedslice/default.asp?SP=CCR-1000&Action=Welcome.

California “State Fireworks Law” limits the time period for legally selling “safe and sane” fireworks to between noon June 28 and 10 p.m. July 6th of the same year. California Health & Safety Code § 12599. The state law does not seem to limit the time of year you can set off fireworks; however, “nothing in the State Fireworks Law authorizes the sale, use, or discharge of fireworks in any city or county where that sale, use, or discharge is otherwise prohibited or regulated.” California Health & Safety Code § 12541.

Both the County of Sacramento and the City of Citrus Heights prohibit the possession, sale, use, display or explosion of any fireworks with two exceptions: certain public displays with the written permission of the fire chief that take place under the supervision and direction of a state-licensed operator; and the sale, use or discharge of “safe and sane” fireworks to noon June 28 and 10 p.m. July 5th of the same year. Sacramento County Code § 4.54.320; Citrus Heights Code of Ordinances § 38-68. You can search the Citrus Heights Code of Ordinances at http://library.municode.com/index.aspx?clientID=13326&stateID=5&statename=California.

So, no “safe and sane” fireworks display on New Year’s Eve in Citrus Heights. As for purchasing them online, the State Fireworks Law provides that “it is unlawful for any person to sell or transfer any safe and sane fireworks to a consumer or user thereof other than at a
fixed place of business of a retailer for which a license and permit has been issued.” California Health & Safety Code § 12681.

I’m sorry, Pamela. Don’t worry, though, I’m sure you will have a Happy Birthday anyway—it is the law of safety karma.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Group of shoppers takes co-op to court

2011-07-04T23:55:58Z

A group of Sacramento Natural Foods Co-op members who seek to ban Israeli-made products at the store began court proceedings Thursday, saying the co-op’s board is violating its bylaws by not opening the decision to a vote by members.

“Our ultimate goal is to have the co-op’s bylaws maintained, and those bylaws require and give members the right to put initiatives on the ballot,” said Maggie Coulter, who sponsored the “Human Rights Initiative.”

To read more about the issues behind the legal action, click here.

Coulter said Friday that the group filed a writ of mandate in Sacramento County’s court system Thursday in hopes that a judge will require the co-op board to allow the membership to vote on items brought to it with the required 100 member signatures.

“They’ve threatened to do this for a long time,” said Board President Steven Maviglio on Friday. “It’s sad and unfortunate that they’re forcing us to use money that should be going to sustainable agriculture to pay lawyer fees.”

He added that though the store carries insurance for legal representation, the deductible will be “tens of thousands of dollars.”

Coulter said the board sent out costly mailers to co-op members about the issue in the past, using some of the same money.

“Maybe the board will come to its senses and realize, ‘You know what? Let’s just follow the bylaws and let the members vote,’ ” she said.

In a previous article, Board Member Michelle Reynolds said the bylaws section referenced by the group looking to ban Israeli-made products is a “cherry-picked” section and not representative of the entire bylaws.

Maviglio said the board is following the bylaws, and a policy committee has been in place for a decade to review initiatives, and it determined that the two initiatives in question – the Human Rights Initiative and the Restore Co-op Democracy initiative – don’t qualify to go to a member vote.

Coulter disagreed, and added that there are no plans to stop the legal action.

“The next step is it has to be scheduled,” she said. “We are being represented by pro-bono attorneys from the National Lawyers Guild. They – like us – believe in the democratic process and feel this case has merit and is also an important case.”

She said that she thinks the members’ ability to put measures on a co-op ballot is critical, saying it ceases to be a co-op if that is not allowed.

Maviglio disagreed, saying that the issue will be “laughed out of court.”

He said the board members are confident that they acted within the bylaws.

“It’s just a publicity stunt,” he said. “There’s no merit in it.”

To view the co-op’s bylaws, click here.

Brandon Darnell is a staff reporter for The Sacramento Press. Follow him on Twitter @Brandon_Darnell.

Ask the County Law Librarian - Swimming Pool Safety Laws

2011-06-30T23:25:07Z

Q: I recently purchased a home in a nice, family-oriented neighborhood. My neighbors to the left of me have a large swimming pool, which their young children and the children’s friends frequently play in. I’ve noticed that the pool doesn’t have any sort of barrier around it. Isn’t there a law that states pools must have a surrounding fence to protect young children from an accidental drowning? If so, is it my duty to report them?
-Rick

A: With summer upon us (finally!), it’s certainly true that pool owners should be especially vigilant in regard to pool safety measures for children. Laws and regulations concerning pool safety will vary depending on the state and county in which you reside, so be sure to conduct legal research in the appropriate jurisdiction.

In California, Section 115922 of the California Health & Safety Code requires that private pools built or remodeled after 1998 feature at least one of seven safety devices, specifically: an isolating enclosure or barrier; approved mesh fencing; an approved pool cover; an alarm on each house door that accesses the pool; a “pool-use” alarm that notifies the home owner when someone has entered the water; and any other device that offers equal to or greater protection than the previously listed features. Be sure to read the official code section for further details.

Counties and cities may impose further requirements, as long as those requirements do not conflict with state law. Section 15.64.070 of the Sacramento City Code, for example, requires that new or remodeled pools be enclosed by fences with self-latching gates. Homeowners that fail to take this precaution may be cited for an infraction, per section 9.16.090. To be thorough, consult both the city and county codes in your area: according to Chapter 16.18 of the Sacramento County Code, a violation of the County’s Swimming Pool Code (Chapter 16.36) could lead to a citation for nuisance.

Keep in mind that many current “swimming pool laws” were enacted fairly recently and may apply only to new or remodeled pools. Your neighbor’s pool may not be subject to these requirements, so it’s best to gather all the facts before acting. If you live within the city limits of Sacramento, believe your neighbor’s swimming pool to be in violation of the city code, and would like to report it, you can file an online Code Violation Complaint or call 311.

For more information on pool safety requirements, precautions, and helpful resources, you can read the Sacramento County Public Law Library’s Everyday Law article on Swimming Pools, or visit the California Department of Public Health’s “Safety Guide for Home Swimming Pools and Spas.”

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Fireworks Stands

2011-06-23T20:14:22Z

Q:

I was surprised recently to come home to a fireworks stand in a parking lot adjacent to my house. I feel that it is too close for safety. What are the laws in the city of Sacramento for fireworks stands?

Thank you,

Lori

Thanks for reading and submitting your question! Late June, fireworks stands start appearing seemingly overnight and appear on almost every street corner. Before the individual or organization can set up a fireworks stand in the City of Sacramento, they must first apply for a Permit to Sell Safe and Sane Fireworks. All applicants must provide the city with a public liability policy in the amount of $50,000 and a $25,000 property damage policy and a products liability policy in the amount of $300,000 showing the City of Sacramento as additional insured thereunder.

California has a “State Fireworks Law” that can be found in the Health and Safety Code, Section 12500 – 12728, but it mostly discusses general provisions, definitions, and the classification of fireworks and other pyrotechnic devices. For the answer to your question, we need to look within the ordinances for the City of Sacramento, specifically chapter 8.48.130 which discusses temporary fireworks stands. According to this section, “No fireworks shall be located within twenty-five (25) feet of any other building or within one hundred (100) feet of any gasoline pump or distribution point”. So depending on how close the stand is to your house, there may be a potential violation.

There are other requirements necessary for a fireworks stand, including the number of required exits, two unless the stand is longer than 40 feet, or maintaining two fire extinguishers that are in good working order and easily accessible for use in case of fire. Of course, “No Smoking” signs are to be prominently displayed on the fireworks stand. If you think your fireworks stand is in violation of any of these laws, you can contact your local fire department; chapter 8.48.150 states the fire chief or the chief’s designee may revoke the permit immediately if it is determined there is a violation.

Even though a fireworks stand can be an eyesore, often it is the number one fundraising tool for most non-profit organizations. The stand should be disassembled and removed no later than July 20th.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Retiree benefits data released to the Bee

2011-06-17T02:23:39Z

The agency that manages retirement benefits for Sacramento County employees provided in-depth information about retirees’ finances to The Sacramento Bee earlier this week after a lengthy court battle.

The Sacramento County Employees’ Retirement System released information about retirees on June 13, Richard Stensrud, the chief executive officer of SCERS said Wednesday.

Joyce Terhaar, executive editor of the Bee, confirmed in an interview Thursday that the newspaper received retiree information from SCERS after suing for it in 2010.“In general, it should have been available from the beginning,” Terhaar said, referring to the data SCERS submitted.

The Bee, which joined with the First Amendment Coalition in a lawsuit against SCERS in 2010, is currently working on stories about the retirees’ information, Terhaar said. She added that she did not know the dates the stories will be published.

The Bee stories may report information that includes the names of retirees and beneficiaries who are collecting benefits, their retirement dates, the names of the departments or agencies for which they worked, their jobs at the time of retirement and how long they were in the retirement system, according to a June 9 letter Stensrud sent to SCERS members.

Retirement allowances, cost of living payments and current retirement payments could also be included in the stories, he wrote.

A June 10 Bee editorial said that the taxpayers should not be blocked from learning the information. “That money comes not just from county employees and retirees, but taxpayers, too. Taxpayers have a right to know what they are paying for,” according to the editorial.

James Diepenbrock, the president of SCERS’ board of directors, said the board did not want to release the information because doing so would make SCERS vulnerable to lawsuits by its members.

Diepenbrock said SCERS must adhere to County Employees Retirement Law of 1937. “That act specifically states that we are to maintain the confidentiality of members’ records,” he said. “As a fiduciary, the board and I felt we can’t release this data because of the way the law reads.”

Terhaar said the courts disagreed with the board’s interpretation of the law.

Stensrud also acknowledged the courts’ views in his letter to retirees.

“Unfortunately, however, both the trial court and the Court of Appeals concluded that the disclosure principles of the (California Public Records Act) outweigh the confidentiality provisions of the 1937 Act,” he wrote.

The Sacramento Bee and First Amendment Coalition won both of their legal fights with SCERS. The Third District Court of Appeals decided May 11 that names of SCERS’ retirees and beneficiaries and their payment information should be publicly released, according to a statement on the SCERS website.

The prior court battle played out in Sacramento County Superior Court, which determined in July 2010 that the data about retirees and beneficiaries should be released under the state’s Public Records Act.

“SCERS does not agree with the conclusion reached by the courts, and continues to believe that ‘naming names’ adds minimal value to the oversight of public employee benefits,” Stensrud wrote in his letter.

“SCERS also continues to be concerned that in this digital age the release of such detailed information could be used by people with questionable motives to prey upon vulnerable retirees and beneficiaries,” he wrote.

SCERS charged the Bee $560 for the records it delivered on Monday, Stensrud said. The charge was to cover the costs of SCERS’ staff time to create a new report out of various databases and for conducting manual research for an element of the data that was not in an existing database, he said.

The Public Records Act states that a public agency can charge fees for “direct costs of duplication” of data.

The information can now be obtained by anyone who wants to make a Public Records Act request. Stensrud said he was unsure of what the charge would be to give out the same information that was provided to the Bee.

Read Stensrud’s June 9 letter to SCERS members here.

Kathleen Haley is a staff reporter for The Sacramento Press.

Ask the County Law Librarian - Neglected Homes

2011-06-16T22:22:45Z

Q: My neighbors moved out a couple of months ago because they were facing foreclosure. They left the house a mess! The yard is totally overgrown, there’s a pile of junk in the driveway, and I’m afraid the pool is going to start growing mosquitoes now that the weather is warming up. Is there anything I can do?
- Karina

A: Unfortunately, you are not alone in this situation. The Sacramento Bee reports that there are thousands of vacant homes in Sacramento, many of which are severely neglected by their owners. According to City estimates, approximately 60 percent of these abandoned properties are bank-owned.

To help combat this growing problem, Sacramento enacted its Vacant Building Ordinance in 2007. Under this law, property owners are required to actively maintain and monitor their property. This maintenance requirement applies equally to individuals, banks, or corporate owners. The Ordinance defines “maintenance and monitoring” as maintaining the exterior of the building, including keeping paint and other finishes in good condition; maintaining landscaping and plants; regularly removing trash and graffiti; keeping the building in compliance with all codes and regulations; and preventing crime and gang activity on the premises. The law also requires posting of the owner’s name and contact information on the front of the building. Vacant buildings not meeting these standards may be considered a public nuisance.

Under Sacramento’s Vacant Building Ordinance, a property owner may be cited with administrative penalties if their property is vacant and not well-maintained for 30 days. The owner can be cited every 30 days until the property is brought into compliance. The initial penalty can be as much as $1000, and up to $5000 for each subsequent penalty. Additionally, the property owner will be charged a $150 monthly monitoring fee, as well as $150 each time a building inspector is called to the property.

If you believe your neighbor’s house does not meet the standards described in the Vacant Building Ordinance, you can file a Code Violation Complaint online or by calling 311. Your complaint will prompt a City inspector to visit the property, and begin the enforcement process. Hopefully this will encourage the owner to clean up the property.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian
www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Fixing Errors on Your Credit Report

2011-06-01T23:57:28Z

Q. A couple years ago, a collection agency got a judgment against me without my knowledge. After they started garnishing my wages, I filed a motion to vacate the judgment since I was never served. I won, but the judgment is still showing up on my credit report. How do I get it off? Thanks,

Anya

A. Congratulations on getting the judgment vacated. Since you no longer have a judgment against you, the credit bureaus should remove it from your record. Unfortunately, it’s rarely that easy. Credit bureaus (and the public record researchers who sell them the data) commonly miss changes such as an order vacating a judgment, satisfactions of judgment, and the like. (National Consumer Law Center, Fair Credit Reporting, Ch. 4.3.2.5.2.)

So, what do you do now?

Since your report is no longer accurate, your next step –as with any false or erroneous information on your credit report – is to file a dispute. This triggers a “reinvestigation” by the credit bureau which should result in the inaccurate information being removed. Unfortunately, the dispute process is not reliably effective. Consumers frequently have to file numerous disputes, and sometimes lawsuits, before the errors are corrected. (Fair Credit Reporting, 4.5.1.2.) Here’s how to dispute this or any other problems on your report:

Check all of your credit reports. Check all of the “big three” credit bureaus (Equifax, Transunion, and Experian) to find it if all of them show the judgment. You can order a credit report from each for a fee. Once a year, you can get a free credit report from each upon request by visiting annualcreditreport.com.

Mail a written dispute to each of the bureaus that show the judgment. Although each bureau has a toll-free number for disputes, it is best to use a written dispute to create a record of the request. The online dispute forms you will find at their websites give you limited space and don’t let you attach copies of the order vacating the judgment. (They may also never be seen by a human being.)

There is no required form for a written dispute request, but it should include all of the following:

Thorough identifying information, including full name, current and recent addresses, date of birth, telephone number, Social Security number, name of spouse (if any), and current employment information.
A clear description of the judgment on your credit report, along with a copy of the report with judgment circled;
An explanation of why you are disputing the information (e.g., “This judgment has been vacated by order of the court”), along with a certified copy of the order vacating the judgment. Include specific steps for the investigation (“contact the records department of the court at [phone number] to verify this order”);
And finally, a direct request that the CRA delete or correct the information.

Click here for a sample of such a letter on the FTC’s website.

Consider signing your dispute letter under oath, in front of a notary. This converts it to an affidavit, which boosts its credibility and may get it more in-depth review. Fair Credit Reporting, 4.5.2.4.2-9.

Make sure to send it to the correct address for each bureau. Certified mail, return receipt requested, is advised. Keep copies of all correspondence and the return receipts in a separate file folder for each agency. Fair Credit Reporting, 4.5.2.4.3.If you speak to someone on the phone, make a note of the date, person you spoke with, and outcome and put it in the file folder, too.

Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FRCA), the credit bureaus must then investigate the dispute, and forward all the relevant data to the information provider (“furnisher”) that sold them the information in the first place. The furnisher then must investigate and report back to the bureau.

When the investigation is complete, the credit bureau must give you the results in writing and a free copy of your report if the dispute results in a change. If you ask, the bureau must send notices of any corrections to anyone who received your credit report in the past six months (two years for reports used for employment purposes).

The bureau will also give you contact information on the furnisher. Some people find that even after they clear an item off their record, it pops up again months later, because the furnisher leaves the inaccurate information in its files, and sends it out again to the bureau. To prevent this, send your dispute directly to the furnisher as well.

What if the dispute is denied?

Disputes often receive very cursory review and are denied almost automatically if the basic information matches the furnisher’s files. If this happens, you can request that a statement of the dispute be included in your file and in future reports.

Unfortunately, you may need to repeat the dispute, perhaps with telephone follow-up, to get a more thorough review. Filing a complaint with the FTC (https://www.ftccomplaintassistant.gov/) or the Better Business Bureau (http://complaint.bbb.org/) is another way to get your dispute taken seriously. If you have tried several times without result, you might even try calling your congressional representative or senator to ask them to call the FTC and demand action.

You may even need to file a lawsuit. If you do, under the FCRA, you may be entitled to actual damages (court costs, attorney’s fees, lost wages, and defamation) and in outrageous cases, punitive damages. The library has several books that may assist you with this, including general books such as Nolo’s Represent Yourself in Court and more specific books such as the National Consumer Law Center’s Fair Credit Reporting, which has an in-depth description of how the credit report business works, detailed information on how to file a lawsuit, and sample court forms.

Visit the Federal Trade Commission’s website for more information on your credit report rights and how to dispute items on your credit report.

Best of luck with your quest to clear your credit report!

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian
www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian -- Is demanding a receipt a violation of rights?

2011-05-26T18:32:33Z

Q. I was wondering if it is legal in California for retailers like WalMart and Best Buy to ask customers for their receipts as they exit the store. As a paying customer, I resent being treated like a criminal. It is because of practices like this that I shop online whenever possible. I understand that membership stores like Costco and Sam's Club have user agreements that allow them to check receipts against items in your cart, but without such an agreement is WalMart violating my rights?

Thank you for your time.

Ally

A. Best Buy and WalMart have certainly started a trend--more and more stores across the country are asking to see receipts upon exiting these days. It may be inconvenient, but it saves you money in the long run—prohibiting theft helps keep your costs down. It doesn’t violate your rights for them to ask for a receipt; you can always refuse and keep going. Only if the security guard then stops you might any violation of rights occur.

California Penal Code (CPC) §490.5(f)(1) provides that “a merchant may detain a person for a reasonable time for the purpose of conducting an investigation in a reasonable manner whenever the merchant has probable cause to believe the person to be detained is attempting to unlawfully take or has unlawfully taken merchandise from the merchant's premises.”

Furthermore, CPC §490.5(f)(2) provides that “[i]n making the detention a merchant . . . may use a reasonable amount of nondeadly force necessary to protect himself or herself and to prevent escape of the person detained or the loss of tangible or intangible property.”

CPC §490.5(f)(3) goes on to state: “[d]uring the period of detention any items which a merchant . . . has probable cause to believe are unlawfully taken from the premises of the merchant . . . which are in plain view may be examined by the merchant . . . for the purposes of ascertaining the ownership thereof.”

And, in CPC §490.5(f)(4), “[a] merchant . . . having probable cause to believe the person detained was attempting to unlawfully take or has taken any item from the premises . . . may request the person detained to voluntarily surrender the item . . . . Should the person detained refuse to surrender the item . . . a limited and reasonable search may be conducted . . . in order to recover the item. Only packages, shopping bags, handbags or other property in the immediate possession of the person detained, but not including any clothing worn by the person, may be searched pursuant to this subdivision.

Finally, CPC §490.5(f)(7), ‘[i]n any civil action brought by any person resulting from a detention or arrest by a merchant, it shall be a defense to such action that the merchant detaining or arresting such person had probable cause to believe that the person had stolen or attempted to steal merchandise and that the merchant acted reasonably under all the circumstances.

So . . . if you refuse to show a security guard your receipt and continue walking to your car with your bag of merchandise, does that constitute probable cause to detain and possibly search your bags? It depends upon the circumstances, but most likely, yes. What would you think if you were in the security guard’s position?

What if the security guard looked in your pocket for your wallet and pulled the receipt out of there? Would that be a violation of your Fourth Amendment right to be free of unreasonable searches and seizures? Nope, the Fourth Amendment only applies to police officers and other state actors, not to private store employees. You may be successful in a suit against the store for false imprisonment, however, because the California state statute specifically excludes clothing from the parameters of a limited and reasonable search.

Whatever you do, don’t overreact. You are not being targeted or insulted; everyone is being asked to present their receipt, so don't take it personally. You don’t want to end up like the Bethlehem, PA, man who was sentenced to six-twelve months in jail for yelling at and threatening the Wal-Mart greeter who asked to see his receipt, or the Utah Wal-Mart shopper who now faces criminal charges for disorderly conduct because he cursed at a greeter, threatened to injure a security guard, and screamed at police officers who were called to the scene.

If you really just cannot bring yourself to show them your receipt, don't lay yourself open to criminal charges by aggressive or belligerent behavior. Remain calm and continue walking. If you're detained and think the store security guard acted unreasonably, remain cool and call the police to handle the matter. Especially if you've got nothing to hide.

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Neighbors and Their Trampolines

2011-05-19T22:54:17Z

Q. I share part of a fence with the neighbor behind me and they put a trampoline up against the fence so when their kids and friends jump they clear the top of the fence by a couple feet and look into my yard and home. Their yard is higher on the hill than mine which makes the trampoline sit even higher at the fence, and my yard is an odd wedge shape, narrowing on the side they have the trampoline so that the distance from my bedroom and living room window directly to where the trampoline sits is only about 10 yards. I've explained and asked them nicely once if they could "scooch the trampoline over a bit." This made the mom defensive and unreasonable and she later squirted me with her hose over the fence. I am embarrassed having kids, usually several at one time, jumping and looking over right into my bedroom just yards away when I'm sometimes in bed. Moving the trampoline a few yards away would solve the problem. Is there any law or protocol regulating fence privacy? Thank you.

Cathy

A. When an issue between neighbors arises, there are many options available to those willing to invest a little time and effort into preliminary research. “Neighbor law” is usually governed locally, so your first step might be to survey the options closest to you.

For example, if you and your neighbor belong to a homeowners’ association (HOA), subdivision, or other development, you might check the by-laws (also called Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions or CC&Rs) for any limitations, restrictions, or prohibitions relating to trampolines or other play structures. If your neighbor isn’t technically violating any rules, you might have the option of initiating an informal complaint process with the association. You can find more information on homeowners’ associations online or at your local county law library.

You will also want to research your local city and county ordinances. Some city and county ordinances regulate the location of “accessory structures,” though what constitutes an accessory structure will vary depending on the jurisdiction. For example, Sacramento City Code 17.80.050 considers some children’s play structures as detached accessory structures (swing sets, for example) and accordingly provides minimum installation requirements. However, the ordinance does not consider mobile play structures as accessory structures and thus these structures are not regulated by county ordinance. Sacramento County Code §16.18 pertains to nuisances and available remedies, though generally the term ‘nuisance’ refers to an act or device that jeopardizes one’s safety or health. Nonetheless, a thorough look at your local county and city codes is highly recommended for all neighbor law issues. Most California city and county codes can be found online or in print at your local county law library.

At least one California city has dealt with this type of situation before. Earlier this year, Mill Valley’s City Council met to determine whether a trampoline could be considered an accessory structure and thus be subject to the city’s zoning laws. After considering a fact pattern very similar to yours, it concluded that trampolines were not accessory structures and therefore could not be governed by city ordinances.

Though many neighbor law questions can be answered by consulting local resources, some issues are governed by state law. California Civil Code § 3479, for instance, governs “private” nuisances that are “indecent or offensive to the senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, so as to interfere with the comfortable enjoyment of life or property…”

If you feel you have a cause of action based on a state law, the proper forum would be either small claims court (for monetary damages) or your county’s superior court (for an injunction and monetary damages). However, this route is likely to be both time-consuming and costly, and your claim first must meet certain legal standards and have evidentiary support. You can find California statutes online at www.leginfo.ca.gov/calaw.html

One helpful book that discusses all of these resources and many more is the 7th edition of Neighbor Law: Fences, Trees, Boundaries & Noise, published by Nolo. Nolo Press is a Berkeley-based publishing house that specializes in self-help law books written with the layperson in mind. Neighbor Law’s introductory chapter contains information on “tackling” a neighbor problem, including sources of preliminary research, techniques for approaching the neighbor, and methods for pursuing the issue (e.g. the local authorities, mediation, or court). For more information on mediation, see Ask the County Law Librarian: Fence Dispute and Alternatives to Court.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Damages for Security Breach of Sony Playstation Network

2011-05-13T00:17:38Z

Q:

I saw your column on Sac Press and thought maybe you can help. I am a customer of Sony’s PlayStation Network for online gaming, recently they had a security breach and Sony notified me that some of the information released to hackers includes my full name, address, phone number, email address, PlayStation user ID and password, and credit card information, just to name a few. I know this info has gotten into the wrong hands due to the huge amount of spam email I am now getting. My concern is primarily with identity theft as my credit card company has stated they are aware of the issue and I have zero fraud liability, but some of my friends may not be so lucky as they used debit cards and I was told that those do not have nearly the same protection. Is Sony liable if my identity is stolen? Can I make them pay for something like a credit freeze to keep the bad guys from buying a car in my name? And what about my friends who were not lucky enough to have a credit card and used a debit card for their online gaming? I don’t even know where to start, can you please help?

Jim

Thanks for reading and submitting your question! It appears that the lawsuits for damages against Sony are already beginning. A Massachusetts woman was among the first to file a lawsuit against Sony over a hack into the company's PlayStation Network video game service. According to the Boston Business Journal, the class-action lawsuit was filed in U.S. District Court in Boston on May 5, 2011. The plaintiff is alleging Sony stored and retained customer data without authorization, failed to maintain a proper firewall, and did not properly encrypt the data it held. The suit also calls the electronics giant out for delaying for almost a week after it knew of the breach, to notify affected customers. You can read a copy of her complaint for more details of the case.

The real question is not whether or not you can file a lawsuit to recover damages, but rather, once you file your lawsuit in court, will you be able to win your case? Well, in order to prevail in court, you will most likely have to prove that actual damages have occurred. So it would depend on if you actually suffer damages from this incident. According to an article written by Mark Foley, lawsuits seeking to recover significant damages based on the loss of, or unauthorized access to, sensitive personal information have not been especially successful for plaintiffs since inconvenience, and threat may be hard to prove in court. Most companies try to alleviate damages by offering to provide identity theft monitoring to affected customers and Sony is no exception.

ABC News is reporting that Sony is now offering 12 months of free identity theft protection to affected customers. Customers have until June 18th to sign up and should be receiving a detailed email soon with information on how to sign up. If you don’t receive your email, I would contact Sony as soon as possible in order to get further details. Ultimately, if your identity is stolen, you can read the law library’s Everyday Law article for tips on what you can do to protect yourself.

Do you have a question for the County Law Librarian? Just email sacpress@saclaw.org. If your question is selected your answer will appear in next Thursday's column. Even if your question isn't selected, though, I will still respond within two weeks.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Fence Dispute & Alternatives to Court

2011-04-28T21:18:04Z

Q. There is a boundary fence between me and my neighbor's side yard. It is leaning and I have propped it up for the last time. I have gotten two estimates from reputable fencing companies. My neighbor is refusing to pay half to replace it. I don't want to go to court. What else can I do?

A. More people are like you wanting to avoid going to court and solving matters using alternative dispute resolution. Using alternative dispute resolution can save you time because it is easier and quicker to write up an agreement than it is to go to court. It can save you money on attorney's fees, court costs and other expenses. It also gives you more control over the case and the outcome since you are actively creating a workable solution.

You may want to consider mediation. Mediation is a voluntary process in which two or more parties involved in a dispute work with an impartial party, the mediator, to generate their own solutions in settling their conflict.

The mediator's role is to facilitate communication between the parties, not to impose solutions. Mediators do not advise, take sides or render a judgment. Instead, the mediator will work with all the parties to help them reach a mutually acceptable resolution.

Private mediators are listed in the yellow pages. Also some lawyers advertise in their phone book listing as providing mediation services. In Sacramento there is the non-profit that provides mediation services: Sacramento Mediation Center a program of California Lawyers for the Arts. http://sacmediation.org/.

As a first step, Chapter 11 of the 7th edition of Neighbor Law: Fences, Trees, Boundaries & Noise by www.nolo.com has detailed information about state and local laws regarding fences. It also has a section on Responsibility for Maintenance.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

Ask the County Law Librarian – There Oughta Be a Law

2011-04-14T15:38:31Z

Q: I have a great idea for a new California law. Our kids get nothing but junk food at their school cafeteria for lunch. They should be learning about – and eating – fresh, healthy food. I want to get a law passed that requires every elementary, middle and high school with a school lunch program to also have a school garden to supply students with fresh fruit and vegetables. How do I get this law passed?

Paula

A: Dear Paula,

Laws are created in one of two ways in California: through the legislature, or through an initiative.

Bills in the State Legislature

Most new laws (or changes in laws) start when a state senator or Assembly member drafts and proposes a bill. People in a certain age range may remember the Schoolhouse Rock cartoon “I’m Just a Bill,” describing this process for federal laws. It’s similar in California, but in real life, the process is complicated by many sub-steps and opportunities for delay. Bills go through a lengthy process of debate, amendment and approval, first in one House then the other, before being signed (or vetoed) by the Governor.

Call, write, or email your representative to suggest a bill. You can also contact the representative’s office to schedule an appointment with him or her. Contact the local or Sacramento office to set up a time to meet. Be prepared with information about the problem your bill would address, how current law deals with this problem, and how your suggestion would improve things.

You can contact any representative, but you are more likely to get a personal response from the Assembly member or senator who represents your own district. To find out who your representatives are, visit “Your Legislature” and enter your zip code.

Once a bill is introduced, there are many things you can do to help get it passed, from organizing letter-writing campaigns, writing letters to the editor, and offering to testify at committee hearings. Tips on these and other methods of lobbying for your bill can be found in “A Citizen’s Guide to Lobbying” and “How to Lobby the California State Legislature,” both put out by the state government.

You can trace the progress of any particular bill through the lengthy process of debate, amendment, and approval by visiting the official California legislative information site’s “Bill Information” page. You can even sign up for an email whenever something happens with your bill.

Passing a Law by Popular Vote: The Initiative Process

California is one of 24 states that use the initiative process. The initiative is the power of the people of California to propose statutes and amendments to the California Constitution (Cal. Const., art. II, Section 8(a)). The laws governing the initiative process are mostly at California Election Code, starting at section 9000.

Initiatives are placed on the ballot if the sponsors can collect enough signatures to qualify – 5% of the number of voters in the last gubernatorial election (currently 504,760 ) for statutes, and 8% (currently 807,615) for Constitutional amendments. If approved by a majority vote, an initiative becomes law the next day.

Getting an initiative on the ballot takes a long time – if you start now, you might be able to get one on the June 5, 2012 ballot. There are also very specific requirements for format and signature gathering. You can read about the process in the California Secretary of State’s “Initiative Guide.”

The first step is to write the text of the law. Next, the sponsors are required to submit it to the California Attorney General, who writes the official title and summary, and if necessary, submits it for fiscal analysis. The AG's office has a good explanation of the process on its website. After that is complete, the sponsors have 150 days to circulate the petition and collect the necessary signatures. Both volunteers and paid signature-gatherers are allowed.

Once the signatures are gathered, the sponsors file the petition with the officials in each county, who count the signatures and report the results to the Secretary of State. If the initiative gathers enough signatures, it goes on the next statewide ballot.

For more information, visit the California Secretary of State’s website or contact the Secretary of State's Initiative Coordinator at (916) 657-2166.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian
www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian – Disqualification of Judges

2011-04-07T19:29:13Z

Q. My wife and I are getting a divorce, and the judge is making all her rulings in my soon-to-be-ex’s favor for no good reason that I can see, except that the judge doesn’t like me—she seems to be biased against men. What can I do to get rid of this judge? Can I report her to the State Bar?

A. The law and procedure for the disqualification of California superior court judges, court commissioners, and referees, is in the Code of Civil Procedure (CCP), sections 170 through 170.6. There are two basic methods a party can use to ask that a judge be disqualified from their case:

1) CCP §§ 170-175 provides the justification and procedure whereby a party may take action toward disqualification of a judge “for cause.”

2) CCP § 170.6 guarantees to parties the right to disqualify a judge without any showing of cause whatsoever. This is called a peremptory challenge.

A Section 170.6 challenge is permitted at any time before the commencement of a trial or hearing on a substantive matter in either civil or criminal court. Each side is allowed a peremptory challenge one time only. You have no control over the judge assigned to take over your case, so avoid hasty or ill-informed decisions to disqualify.

A peremptory challenge is usually made by a written motion to the court, done in proper format with specific language and supported by a declaration or affidavit made under penalty of perjury. An oral motion under oath is also allowed. There is no hearing or ruling on a timely and properly-formatted peremptory challenge. The replacement is automatic, and the case will continue as quickly as possible, perhaps hours or days, under a new judge.

There are specific deadlines and strict time frames in which a peremptory challenge must be made, depending on your court’s calendaring system. Improper timing is the number one reason that challenges are rejected.

Even if your deadline has passed for filing a timely peremptory challenge, however, you still have the right to challenge the judge for cause under CCP § 170.1. Grounds for a just cause challenge (relationship, financial interest, etc.) can arise at any time during the proceedings. Therefore, a challenge for cause is timely if raised “at the earliest practicable opportunity” after discovering the grounds for disqualification, even during trial.

Step by step procedures and sample formats for written motions, supporting declarations, and affidavits for both of these disqualification methods can be found in a set of books called California Forms of Pleading and Practice, Volume 27, Chapter 317, “Judges.” You can find this set of books at the Sacramento County Public Law Library.

The State of California Commission on Judicial Performance, rather than the State Bar, reviews complaints that charge judicial misconduct. Procedures and the form of complaint for judicial misconduct can be found on their website.

A judge’s incorrect ruling on its own does not constitute judicial misconduct. A judge who commits legal error is subject to investigation and possible discipline only if the legal error clearly and convincingly reflects bad faith, bias, abuse of authority, disregard for fundamental rights, intentional disregard of the law, or any purpose other than the faithful discharge of judicial duties. If the incorrect ruling or legal error does not meet these standards, then it is not subject to disciplinary review. However, it may be grounds for an appeal in your case.

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Obtaining Evidence for a Contested Traffic Citation

2011-03-30T19:35:06Z

Q. I’ve decided to contest a speeding ticket I received recently. How do I obtain all of the police records and evidence against me?

A. Before you contest your citation, you may want to consider submitting an “Informal Discovery Request” to the issuing agency. Under California Penal Code Sections 1054-1054.7, the prosecution in any criminal case (including infractions) is required to provide the defendant with copies of all written statements, reports, and logs regarding the case. This code section also applies to a copy of the engineering and traffic survey if your citation is a radar case [Cal. Penal Code § 1054.1(f)].

Fortunately, you can submit this request before you formally challenge the citation, in order to review evidence the issuing party may use against you in court. Your copy of the ticket, for example, will not include the notes about the stop that the issuing officer most likely made on the reverse of his or her copy of the citation. Once the issuing agency receives your request, it has 15 days to provide the relevant information. One caveat: the request requires you to submit all of your evidence as well: you will include the names, addresses, and statements of any witnesses you may have with your request.

There is no statewide “official” discovery request form for Section 1054 requests, but a book published by Nolo Press and written by Attorney David W. Brown called Fight Your Ticket in California contains both blank and sample completed forms, as well as instructions. This book also contains the information and strategies you would need to:

-determine if your ticket is beatable
-challenge speeding citations & other violations
-present your case in court
-appeal a conviction

Should you choose to formally challenge the citation, you can subpoena relevant records, equipment, and the issuing officer’s testimony during the trial prep phase of the case by using a Subpoena Duces Tecum (CR-125/JV-525). Samples of this form are available in the book, and the form is available for free online from the California Courts website at http://www.courtinfo.ca.gov/forms/fillable/cr125.pdf You will need to read the information carefully and conduct further research to be sure you’ve done everything properly.

Fight Your Ticket in California is available directly from the publisher at www.nolo.com, from most large bookstores and libraries, and from your local county law library. To find the law library nearest you, go to www.publiclawlibrary.org

For online resources about contesting a traffic citation, you can find more information on the Sacramento County Superior Court website at http://www.saccourt.ca.gov/traffic/traffic.aspx and on the California Courts Self Help website at http://www.courtinfo.ca.gov/selfhelp/traffic/info.htm.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Domestic Violence Restraining Orders

2011-03-25T01:32:44Z

Q-
I am afraid of my boyfriend. We just moved in together last month, and ever since then, he has been shouting and cursing at me. He also pushed me down and punched a wall. I want to break up with him, but I am afraid he will hurt me. Can the law help protect me?

Anonymous in Midtown

A-
I am sorry to hear about your situation! If you feel in are in immediate danger, call 911!

California’s Domestic Violence Protection Act defines domestic violence as abuse toward an intimate partner or family member. The abuse can range from verbal threats, annoying telephone calls, stalking, hitting, and destruction of personal property. If you ever have to call the police, ask for an emergency protective order. A police officer that answers a domestic violence call can ask a judge for an emergency protective order at any time of the day or night. Explain in detail to the police officer why you're afraid. The emergency protective order starts immediately and can last a week. The judge can order the abusive person to leave the home and stay away from you and your children for up to a week.

If you want protection for more than a week, you can ask to the family court to issue a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO). If the restraining order is granted, it typically requires the abuser to stay at least 100 yards away from you, and have no contact with you, including no email or telephone contact.

The Sacramento family court offers a free workshop on form preparation fro domestic violence restraining orders, Monday and Friday, excluding court holidays, at 8:45 a.m. This class is for both men and women and is held in the Self-Help Computer Room, Room 113A, on the first floor of the William R. Ridgeway Family Relations Courthouse, 3341 Power Inn Road. No appointment is necessary. For those who cannot attend the workshop, the court encourages you to complete your forms using TurboCourt. This program uses simple questions to gather all of the necessary information to apply for a domestic violence restraining order. If you will be filing in Sacramento, be sure to include the mandatory local forms.

You may want to contact WEAVE, INC. (Women Escaping a Violent Environment). WEAVE is a local nonprofit organization that was created to serve domestic violence survivors and their families in Sacramento County by offering counseling and other services including; dissolution & restraining order workshops, and a pro bono legal clinic or free attorney consultation for domestic violence.

Keep in mind that a restraining order can help protect you, but it is still just a piece of paper. A restraining order can lower, but not eliminate the risk of ongoing violence.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask The County Law Librarian - Collecting on a Small Claims Judgment

2011-03-11T20:22:07Z

Q. I just won my small claims case against my landlord for wrongfully withholding my security deposit. Does the court collect for me?
Jenny

A. The court will not collect the money for you. The court can issue the orders and other documents you may need to collect your judgment from the debtor. You can start the collection process when the time to appeal runs out (30 days after entry of the judgment); or if there was an appeal and you won, after the appeal decision (judgment) is sent back to the small claims court, usually about 10 days after the appeal decision.

Encourage the debtor to pay you voluntarily and don’t resort to harassment or illegal collection methods. Some of the most common collection techniques include: placing a lien on real property, placing a lien on business property, seizing wages and seizing bank accounts.

If the judgment debtor does not pay within 30 days after the court clerk mailed the Notice of Entry of Judgment the debtor must send you for SC-133 Judgment Debtor’s Statement of Assets. This form will tell you what property the debtor has that may be used to pay the judgment.

Sometimes the debtor won’t send the completed form and then you can file SC 134 Application and Order to Produce Statement of Assets and Appear for Examination. This summons the debtor back to court and you can ask the debtor questions about his or her assets or property. You can ask about things like where he or she works, how much he or she earns, bank accounts, stocks, other income sources, property and belongings, and anything else that can be used (or sold) to pay the judgment.

Once you know about the judgment debtor’s income and property you can ask the sheriff to take that property to pay you. To do this fill out and ask the court clerk to issue Form EJ-00 1 Writ of Execution. Take the form to the Sheriff’s civil division with a description of the debtor’s property that you want to levy on.

Click on the link for more information on collecting your judgment. The law library has information on this too. One good resource is Nolo’s How to Collect When You Win a Lawsuit in California.

Lastly, keep in mind that not all judgments are collectable because the debtor may not have any income or property of value.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian – “Quashing” Improper Service of Court Documents

2011-02-24T16:14:47Z

Q. I was handed a summons and complaint for breach of contract, but I didn't sign for it, so I don’t think it is legal. I want to challenge this in court. How do I do that?

Tom

A. Probably the most common misconception regarding service of the summons and complaint in civil cases is that the receiving party must sign something in order for the service to be valid. A summons may be served by personal delivery of a copy of the summons and complaint to the person to be served. Such service is deemed complete at the time of delivery (California Code of Civil Procedure §415.10). There is no requirement that the person being served sign for anything.

The most common mistake that people make when serving court documents is that they serve the documents themselves, rather than having a person who is at least 18 years of age and not a party to the action serve them (California Code of Civil Procedure §414.10).

Improper service of the summons, however, is not a defense to the underlying facts of the lawsuit, nor does it have any effect on the running of the applicable statute of limitations. You can challenge the validity of the service by filing a motion to quash service of summons on or before your last day to file an answer, or at any later time if the court finds good cause (California Code of Civil Procedure §418.10), but this typically has little effect on a case other than to cause a brief delay. If your motion to quash service of summons is granted, the court will simply require that you properly served.

For this reason, and because of the time and effort involved in preparing a motion to quash service of summons, many defendants choose instead to ignore the issue and simply respond to the lawsuit, assuming they learn about it in time to respond. There is no standardized form for a motion to quash service of summons; and, like most other motions in civil cases, the motion consists of several parts: 1) a notice of motion and motion, 2) a memorandum of points and authorities, and 3) a declaration, with any attachments (California Rule of Court 3.1112). In addition, the motion must be drafted on 28-line pleading paper (California Rules of Court 2.108, 2.111). Although instructions and samples of pleading paper can be downloaded from our website at www.saclaw.org/pages/creating-pleadings.aspx, there aren’t any reputable examples of motions to quash service available for free online. We have both print and online instructions and samples in the Library at 813 Sixth Street downtown, however, and would be happy to show you these resources and, if applicable, how to download samples from the appropriate database.

If the plaintiff in your breach of contract suit is a credit card company or collection agency suing you over a credit card debt, you can find out how to answer the lawsuit on our website at http://www.saclaw.org/pages/respond-to-credit-card-case.aspx. We also offer an "Answer to Breach of Contract Workshop" every Monday through Friday morning in which an experienced paralegal walks you through the entire process of completing the forms used to answer your breach of contract/collection case.

For more on personal service of process of court papers, including a step-by-step guide and an animated video on proper service, go to http://www.saclaw.org/pages/personal-service.aspx

Good luck with your case, Tom, and don’t hesitate to visit us, in person or online, if you need any more help!

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Property Left Behind in a Rental Unit

2011-02-17T23:18:08Z

Q: Up until two weeks ago, I was renting a room in a house. I had become friends with the owner and moved in last summer to help us both out with costs. It became very unpleasant to live with her, however, and in December I gave her our agreed-upon 30 days’ notice that I would be moving out. She didn’t take it well, but I managed to move most of my things out (on my own). Due to a family emergency that took me out of the state for a week, I had to leave a few things behind in the garage. When I got back to town and tried to get my stuff, the owner refused! Is she guilty of stealing my things since she won’t let me pick them up? How can I get my stuff back?
- Jessica

A: This scenario is fairly common, and can happen in any situation in which there is a landlord/tenant relationship; for example, whether someone is renting a unit as part of an apartment complex or, as in your case, renting a room in a house. According to California Civil Code section 1965(a)(1), the landlord is required to return, or allow you to collect, your belongings if your request meets two requirements: 1) the request is made within 18 days of vacating the premises, and 2) the request is made in writing and includes a description of the property that was left. The request must be mailed to the landlord’s current address.

If your request meets both requirements, the landlord is legally obligated to respond within five days of receiving the request. She can ask you (in the form of a bill) to pay reasonable costs for storage; if she does, you must pay the charges and pick up the property within 72 hours of receiving the landlord’s demand. What qualifies as “reasonable?” And how should her written request be delivered? Civil Code section 1965 contains the answers to these questions and provides further information on the landlord's storage of the belongings and any storage costs incurred.

If your request meets both of the above-listed requirements, you agree to pay any costs relating to storage, and your ex-landlord still doesn’t comply, you could sue for actual damages and possibly more, if you believe she acted in bad faith [Civil Code Section 1965(e), (1) and (2)].

If more than 18 days has passed since you moved out and your remaining property is worth less than $300, the landlord is free to dispose of it. If it is worth more than that, the landlord must sell it at a public sale, subtract costs of sale and storage, and turn the rest over to the county. You have a year to claim the net profit from the sale (see Civil Code Sections 1983 and 1988).

As in most legal situations, there are exceptions and qualifications. You should conduct further research to find out how the law applies to your unique circumstances. To read the above mentioned Civil Code sections, go to www.leginfo.ca.gov and select California Law. Put a check box next to the Civil Code, and hit SEARCH. A linkable table of contents should appear. Go to the section you are interested in reading.

Another helpful resource is the book “California Tenants Rights” published by Nolo Press. The book is available at large bookstores, large libraries, directly from the publisher at www.nolo.com and from your local public law library. To find the law library nearest you, go to www.publiclawlibrary.org

For online information, the California Department of Consumer Affairs has made available the publication “Options for a Landlord: When a Tenant's Personal Property Has Been Left in the Rental Unit: Legal Guide LT-5.” The guide was published in 1996, so you’ll want to make certain that the code sections you might rely on are still current. You can do this by visiting www.leginfo.ca.gov and reading the current laws. The department website also offers an online version of California Tenants: A Guide to Residential Tenants' and Landlords' Rights and Responsibilities, for a more comprehensive look at the landlord/tenant relationship.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian – Can I Fire My Attorney?

2011-02-10T20:46:59Z

Q: I hired an attorney for my divorce, but he hasn’t done anything! Everytime I call his office, he doesn’t answer the phone. I leave messages but he never calls me back, he just keeps asking for more money even though I have already paid him way too much already. How can I get rid of him?

Mel

A: I'm sorry to hear that! You have a right to discharge or fire your attorney at any time for any reason or no reason at all, even if you still owe him money for the time spent working on your case. It is a fairly easy process, all you have to do is file a Substitution of Attorney form with the court. When filling out this form, you substitute either your newly hired attorney or yourself, if you plan to represent yourself.

If at the time you let him go, there is outstanding money owed, you will still owe the balance. However, there may be options for disputing the amount owed, especially if you have not been given an accounting of the time and money spent on your case. If you believe that your attorney's bill is too high, you should first talk to your lawyer about the bill, and make your concerns clear. You may find that the case was more complicated and took more time than you realized or your lawyer may agree that a mistake was made on the bill and make corrections. If there is still a dispute, the Sacramento County Bar Association administers an arbitration program to assist clients in resolving fee disputes with their attorneys without going to court. You should contact the Sacramento County Bar Association directly for information on disputing the fee and fee arbitration.

All lawyers who practice in California must live up to ethical standards imposed by the California Supreme Court and the state legislature. You can file a complaint with the State Bar of California if you believe that your lawyer acted improperly, but not just because there is some disagreement between you, or you believe he or she did a poor job. Depending on the seriousness of the offense, a lawyer can be given a warning, put on probation, suspended from practicing law for a period of time, or disbarred - prohibited from practicing law in California. For more helpful information on how to handle a disagreement with your attorney, check out this pamphlet from the State Bar of California.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Consumer Pet Protection Act

2011-01-28T00:38:14Z

Q. I purchased a pug at a pet store in the Bay Area ten days ago and now the dog is sick. I took Sparky to the veterinarian and she has hospitalized him. I think he will pull through. What are my options with the pet store?

A. California’s Pet Protection Act (Health & Safety Code Section 122125 et. Seq.) gives consumers recourse when they discover that their pet is ill within 15 days after taking possession of the pet from the pet store.

First you must get a written statement from the treating veterinarian stating that the dog is sick and is requiring hospitalization (Health & Safety Code Section 122160). The statement must be delivered to the pet dealer no later than five days after the diagnosis is made.

You have three options:
• Return the dog for a refund of the purchase price and reimbursement for reasonable veterinary fees up to the cost of the dog.
• Exchange the dog for another of equal value and get reimbursement for reasonable veterinary fees up to the cost of the dog.
• Keep the dog and receive reimbursement for reasonable veterinary fees up to 150% of the purchase price of the pet.
(Health & Safety Code Section 122160)

Dealers who knowingly sell sick animals are subject to a penalty of up to $1000.

If the pet store doesn’t dispute the diagnosis, the refund and reimbursement must be paid within ten days after the dealer receives the veterinarian’s statement (Health & Safety Code Section 122180)

For future pet acquisitions, our local City Shelter and the Sacramento SPCA are great options for pet adoption.

Get well soon, Sparky.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian – Finding a Will

2011-01-20T17:57:29Z

Q: How can I get a copy of a will? I believe I was named in my mother’s will but I can’t find a copy. Mom passed away recently and my sister has been transferring Mom’s property into her own name.

Marge

A: We hear variations on this question surprisingly often. Usually, there is nothing mysterious going on. Check with the probate court in the county where your mother was living when she died. If a will was filed or a probate was opened, that is where it should be, and the clerk will be able to find it using your mother’s name and date of death.

In many cases, nothing will be on file with the court. This is probably not a sign of any kind of misconduct. Perhaps your mom never got around to writing a will. Maybe she put her property in a trust, so probate is not necessary. Even if there is a will, there may not be enough assets to justify a formal probate, or it might not have been located yet. And, occasionally, people do hide or destroy wills.

Finding the will: If your sister is handling your mother’s debts and assets, you can ask her if she has located the will or trust documents. If not, check with your mother’s attorney. Search her home or office file cabinets and desks. Contact any banks she used, to find out if she had a safe-deposit box there. Banks will usually let family members open a safe-deposit box in the presence of a bank officer to search for a will or burial instructions, although nothing else may be removed. Be sure to bring a copy of the death certificate.

If you believe that your sister has (or had) the will and is refusing to give you a copy or file with the court, you can petition the court to order her to produce it under California Probate Code Section 8201. There is no preprinted form for this, so you would need to either hire an attorney or come in to the law library and do some research. We have samples of this form that you can customize.

If you do find a will, you can start a probate case. In the case, you (or someone) will have to tally up all of your mother’s assets and debts, settle the debts, and then divide the remainder between the beneficiaries of the will, all under the court’s supervision.

What if there is a trust? If your mother set up a trust, there may never be a probate case. However, the trustee would be required to give you notice of the trust, even if you are not named in it, since you are one of the children. (California Probate Code Sections 16060.5-16061.8.) Therefore, if there is a trust, you should receive information about it, including your right to a copy of the documents. If you don’t get notice, you can sue the trustee for any damages you suffer as a result (including attorney's fees).

What if there is neither a will nor a trust? If there is no trust or will, your mother’s property goes to her surviving spouse or domestic partner. If none, her property should be divided equally between her children under California Probate Code Sections 6400-6414. If that doesn’t happen, you can start a case in probate court to enforce your right to your portion. Again, if you decide to go this route, you would need to either hire an attorney or come in to the law library and do some research.

Do keep in mind that any court action will take a lot of time, energy, and money. Unless your mother’s estate (after subtracting any debts) is fairly big, it may not be worth investing time and money, but that is up to you.

Try just talking to your sister first. She may be transferring money to make it easier to pay off debts and wind up your mother’s affairs, and may not realize that she needs to keep you better in the loop. If you still aren’t satisfied, you can decide whether to take that next step of filing in court.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian -- Children's wishes in custody disputes

2011-01-13T18:53:48Z

Q: I’m going through a horrible, messy divorce, and I’m afraid my worst fear may come true—my 13-year-old daughter wants to live with her father instead of me because the cheating bum is “cool” and I’m just an over-anxious nag. Really he is just lazy so he lets her do whatever she wants and I’m the only one who ever enforces any discipline. A friend told me that there is a new law that says a 14-year-old can choose which parent gets custody. Is this true?

A: Under California law, there is no specific age at which children can make custody or visitation decisions. The California Family Code, section 3042(a)), states that a court must “consider” and give “due weight” to the wishes of children who are of “sufficient age and capacity to reason so as to form an intelligent preference as to custody or visitation.”

The legislature amended this law in 2010, so maybe that is what your friend is thinking of. The amendment, effective January 1, 2012, requires a court to hear a child who wishes to address the court regarding custody or visitation if the child is14 years or older, unless the court determines that addressing the court is not in the child's best interests. In addition, a child who is younger than 14 years old and wishes to do so may be permitted to address the court regarding custody or visitation if the court determines that hearing from the child is in his or her best interests.

In other words, if the court determines that the child is mature enough to have informed opinions as to custody and visitation, then the court must use this opinion as one factor to consider when making the custody and visitation order.

Whether the minor is of “sufficient age and capacity,” the threshold prerequisite to consideration of the child's wishes, varies with each child. The requisite maturity is not measured by any particular chronological age.

Obviously the new law has not yet been tested in the courts. In previous case law, however, courts have become more receptive as the child approaches teenage years. In Marriage of Rosson, 178 Cal. App. 3d 1094 (1986), and Marriage of Burgess, 13 Cal. 4th 25 (1996), for example, 10-and 13-year-old children met the “sufficient age and capacity to reason so as to form an intelligent preference” standard. In Stuart v. Stuart, 209 Cal. App. 2d 478 (1962), the court said it would listen to children as young as seven or eight. In Marriage of Slayton, 86 Cal. App. 4th 653 (2001), the court found it doubtful that a 5-year-old could realistically meet the statutory standard. In Marriage of Mehlmauer, 60 Cal. App. 3d 104 (1976), however, the court determined that a 14-year-old boy did not meet the standard and refused to shift custody from the mother despite the child's wishes. The bottom line is that custody is awarded according to the best interests of the child.

The California cases referenced above can be located at http://www.lexisnexis.com/clients/CACourts/ by doing a citation search. After checking the box next to “I have read and agree to these Terms and Conditions,” and clicking on “BEGIN SEARCHING OPINIONS,” click on “By Citation” under the word “Search” on the top left of the screen. Use the “Search by Citation Criteria” template to input your search. For example, in the Stuart v. Stuart case, 209 Cal. App. 2d 478, the first number, 209, represents the volume number of the Reporter the case appears in, so type that number into the “Enter Volume” box. Then, using the pull-down menu, select the abbreviation for the Reporter the case appears in, “Cal. App. 2d.” In the “Enter Page #” box enter the second number in the citation, 478, which is the page upon which the case begins. Finally, click on the “GO” button to retrieve your case.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Pet Licenses

2010-12-23T19:51:37Z

Q: We’re adopting a dog for our children for Christmas. A friend told me we'd need to get a pet license. Is this true? If so, who do we contact for that?

Bridget

A: Congratulations on the new addition to your family!

Sacramento County, and all cities within the County, require dogs and cats over 4 months of age to be vaccinated and licensed. Sacramento City also requires licensing of mini-pigs.

Each city processes its own licenses, so you will need to contact the Animal Services department for the city where you live. Links to each of those departments is listed below.

Citrus Heights (contract with the County to process animal licenses) - (read the code section here)
Elk Grove - (read the code section here)
Folsom - (read the code section here)
Galt (contract with the County to process animal licenses) (read the code section here)
Rancho Cordova - (read the code section here)
Sacramento - (read the code section here)
Unincorporated Sacramento County - (read the code section here)

Licensing fees vary between cities, and are significantly higher for unaltered animals. One-year licenses for a spayed or neutered dog will be $10-$15. One-year licenses for unaltered dogs range from $30-$150. Most cities offer one, two, or three year licenses, with discounts for the longer licenses. In order to obtain an animal license, you will need proof of rabies vaccination. If you wish to pay the reduced licensing fee for an altered animal, you will also need proof of spay or neuter.

Licensing your pet offers many benefits, especially if your pet gets lost. If your pet is wearing her license tag, animal control officers will attempt to bring her home, rather than taking her to the shelter. Should your pet end up at the shelter, though, the license will extend the time she is held at the shelter.

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian: Amending a Birth Certificate

2010-12-16T21:45:10Z

Q: I gave birth to a beautiful baby boy in September. We named him James, but from day one we called him Kimo, which is James in Hawaiian. We regret not naming him Kimo and I would like to amend his birth certificate. Is that possible?

Lelani

A: Congratulations on the new addition to your family!
Amendments to birth certificates are used to correct errors and cannot be used to change information on the certificate. Changing information on the certificate requires a court order.

Since both parents are in agreement the process is straight forward. All of the forms you need are available here: http://www.courtinfo.ca.gov/selfhelp/other/namechangechild2.htm

First you would complete the Petition for Change of Name including the Attachment to the Petition for one child. Both parents sign the Attachment. Next complete the Order to Show Cause and the Civil Case Cover Sheet. File all the forms with at least 2 copies of each in the court in the county where you live.

You must publish the Order to Show Cause in a newspaper of general circulation once per week for 4 weeks in a row. Bring the proof of publication and the Decree Changing Name form to your court date and the judge will sign it. An appearance may not be required. Here is information about the process from the Sacramento Superior court http://www.saccourt.ca.gov/forms/docs/cv-142.pdf

Once you get a certified copy of the Decree Changing Name you can change your child’s birth certificate, social security card and other legal documents. Visit www.cdph.ca.gov or call (916)445-2684 for information regarding amending the birth certificate.

Another resource is this 60 minute video which explains the process in detail: http://www.saclaw.org/videoDetails.aspx?vid=25

The Sacramento County Public Law Library also has a free Name Change workshop every Monday from 1:30 – 3:30 http://www.saclaw.org/pages/cshc-workshops.aspx

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Red Light Citation

2010-11-04T15:15:13Z

Q: I received a citation in the mail for running a red light. My brother borrowed my truck and he was the driver pictured. What do I do?

Bill

A: Contact the agency that issued the citation. Do not send payment to the court because then the citation will be connected to your driving record. Once contacted the issuing agency will then contact the court with the corrected information. If you fail to contact the agency or do not appear on your assigned date, additional penalties will be added to your case and your driver’s license can be suspended.

Below is the contact information for local agencies:

California Highway Patrol, Red Light Camera Program
903 Enterprise Drive
Sacramento, CA 95825 916-876-6643

With the citation number, license plate number, and the city code SCMTCA, you can view the violation video online - external link.

City of Elk Grove, Red Light Camera Program
8400 Laguna Palms Way
Elk Grove, CA 95758-8045 916-478-8161
With the citation number, license plate number, and the city code ELKGCA, you can view the violation video online - external link.

City of Citrus Heights, Red Light Camera Program
6315 Fountain Square Drive
Citrus Heights, CA 95621 916-727-5884
With the citation number, license plate number, and the city code CSHTCA, you can view the violation video online - external link.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Divorce Costs

2010-09-30T22:25:48Z

Q: I've heard that getting a divorce is more expensive than getting married. Is that true? In total, how much does a divorce really cost?
- Dave

A: Well, I guess that depends on how extravagant your wedding was. It’s usually cheaper to stay married than to get a divorce, though. For most couples, divorce is an expensive process. It’s impossible to put an exact price on a divorce, because it is different in each situation. An extended contested divorce typically ends up costing more than one that is settled easily between the parties. In general, the more issues to be dealt with during the divorce, the more expensive it may be. Additionally, the more assets you have, the more you have to lose. Here’s a brief overview of some of the types of costs you may to incur during a divorce.

Hiring an attorney
If you decide to hire an attorney to handle your divorce, expect to pay an initial retainer of at least $750 - $5000. Think of the retainer as a down payment – as the attorney works on your case, he will deduct his hourly rates from that amount. For divorce cases, hourly rates are usually around $175-$350. In most cases, you will run through your retainer before the case is over, and will need to pay additional fees to your attorney. According to “How to Do Your Own Divorce in California in 2010,” the average spent on legal fees for a divorce is well over $18,000 per spouse. For couples with more assets, or more issues to sort out during the divorce, attorney’s fees can run into tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars per spouse! If your divorce will be complex or highly contested, you will need to factor in additional litigation-related expenses, such as custody evaluators, financial expert witnesses, and mediators.

Don’t base your decision about hiring an attorney solely on the cost, though. There are benefits and drawbacks to hiring an attorney. Nolo Press has a very good article to help you decide whether hiring an attorney is right for you.

If you decide not to hire an attorney, the Law Library has a lot of materials that may help you handle your own case. A guide listing our divorce-related resources, as well as referrals to other sources of assistance is available on the Law Library’s website. Keep in mind that even if you decide not to hire an attorney, you may still significant costs during a divorce.

Filing fees
To file the initial papers to start a divorce, you will pay a filing fee of $355. This is not a penalty for the party initiating the divorce - the other party will also pay $355 to file their response. Throughout the case, you may have to file additional paperwork. Some of these filings may be free, others may have filing fees of up to $40. If you have very low income, or are receiving public assistance, you may qualify for a fee waiver. More information about fee waivers is available from the Law Library’s website.

Division of property
During a divorce in California, spouses will have to divide the community estate, often called “community property.” Community property is any property or debt that is acquired during the marriage, unless it is a gift or inheritance, or was owned prior to marriage. Sometimes it is difficult to determine what is considered community property and what is the separate property of each spouse. This article from Nolo Press provides a good explanation of the differences.

In addition to assets you’d commonly think of as community property, such as income, real estate, vehicles, and household goods, community property can also include accumulated vacation pay, pension funds, employee stock options, tax refunds, and intellectual property created during the marriage. Each spouse is entitled to an equal share of community property during a divorce. This means that when you divorce, you may lose up to half of everything you own. Depending on the size of the community estate, this can be very expensive!

Support
If you have children together, child support may become an ongoing divorce-related cost. California has a mandatory statewide guideline for child support based on the actual income of each parent and the amount of time each parent has physical custody of the children. To help parents estimate the amount of child support the judge will order in their case, the State of California has developed an online child support calculator, which is available at https://www.cse.ca.gov/ChildSupport/cse/guidelineCalculator.

You also may be required to provide medical insurance for the children, and contribute toward childcare expenses, unreimbursed or uninsured health care expenses, educational or special needs of a child, or travel expenses for visitation purposes.

In addition to child support, the court may also order spousal support, commonly called “alimony.” Spousal support is not mandatory in California, so there is no statewide guideline for spousal support like there is for child support. Instead, the court is required to consider a list of factors in making a spousal support determination. A good explanation of these factors is available online at http://courtinfo.ca.gov/selfhelp/family/support/documents/spousalsup.pdf. After evaluating the parties’ circumstances, it is entirely up to the court whether to order spousal support, and to determine the amount and duration of a spousal support order.

The cost of your divorce is very difficult to estimate, because there are so many different factors involved. In addition to those I’ve already mentioned, you may incur other costs, such as moving expenses, the cost of maintaining two separate households, even tax consequences related to support and property division.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Proof of Auto Insurance

2010-09-23T17:44:38Z

Q: I got pulled over and thought I had a valid insurance card at the time. It turns out my policy had actually been canceled. What can happen and what are the laws regarding driving without insurance?

Betty

A: In California, you must have car insurance that covers you when you're driving any car. If a police officer stops you, you must show proof of insurance. Failing to show proof of financial responsibility, meaning insurance coverage, is a violation of California Vehicle Code Section 16029. http://www.dmv.ca.gov/pubs/vctop/d07/vc16029.htm. Violating this code could result in fines up to $500 plus penalties, impoundment of the vehicle and suspension of the driver's license. If the vehicle is impounded the owner will have to pay for all storage and tow charges as well.

If you have insurance but don't have proof to show the officer, you'll be charged with an infraction for driving without proof of insurance and must provide proof of your insurance to the court and pay a fee.

If you don't have insurance, you must buy it. Then, provide your proof of the insurance to the court and pay a fine. The consequences can be far more serious if you are involved in an accident and do not have insurance. You may have to comply with the financial responsibility laws (SR22, SR22s, SR16), including having to pay for any injuries or damages from the accident out of your own pocket.

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - Foreclosure Defense

2010-09-09T22:44:12Z

Q: I just got a Notice of Default from my mortgage company. My friend told me I could stop the foreclosure process by demanding that the bank “produce the note.” What does this mean and will it really work?

Thank you, Louise

A: The “produce the note” defense to foreclosure is touted by many on the Internet —people ask us for the forms needed to do that almost every day. The theory is that because loans are frequently transferred it may be difficult, if not impossible, for your mortgage company to trace the ultimate ownership of your specific loan. To foreclose, the lender must actually be current holder of the note, and a homeowner can delay foreclosure by filing a lawsuit demanding this proof. Under California law, however, “It is well-established that non-judicial foreclosures can be commenced without producing the original promissory note.” Chilton v. Federal Nat. Mortgage Ass'n, 2009 WL 5197869 (E.D.Cal.).

Unfortunately for many homeowners these days, foreclosures are almost impossible to stop. An action to set aside the trustee’s sale requires both an irregularity in the procedure outlined in California Civil Code §§ 2920-2924 and a grossly inadequate sale price. Moeller v. Lien, 25 Cal.App.4th 822 (1994). If faced with foreclosure, the best thing for you to do is talk to an attorney, your mortgage company, or a nonprofit foreclosure prevention organization. Avoid foreclosure rescue and loan modification scams. If it sounds too good to be true, it is!

Coral Henning, Director
@coralh & @saclawlibrarian

www.saclaw.org

Ask the County Law Librarian - How to Find a Lawyer

2010-09-01T16:30:15Z

Q: How can I find a good lawyer? I am willing to pay. Can you recommend someone?

Thank you, Katherine

A: Although I can't recommend a lawyer, I can provide a strategy to locating one.

Locating a lawyer who is willing to handle your case can be challenging. There are a number of avenues you can pursue to locate the right attorney.

Personal Referrals
Talk to your family or friends for a referral. Ask them who their lawyers were and what they think of them.

Online Directories
Nolo's Lawyer Directory http://lawyers.nolo.com/
The publishers of Nolo's Lawyer Directory verify that all listed attorneys are in good standing with the state bar, and that they have not recently been disciplined. All attorneys provide detailed information about their educational history, legal specialties, fees, and personal philosophy.

State Bar of California http://www.calbar.ca.gov/
Posts member record information, including information regarding attorney discipline. Users can search for a "certified specialist" in these specific practice areas: appellate, criminal law, estate planning, trust and probate, family law, immigration and nationality, personal and small business bankruptcy, taxation and worker's compensation. Click on "Public Services" then on "finding an attorney for legal advice" to read the State Bar's guide on how to find an attorney.

Martindale-Hubbell Directory http://www.martindalehubbell.com
Best known for the national directory of attorneys, this site contains a searchable database by attorney's name, location and/or area(s) of practice.

Lawyer Referral Service
Sacramento County Bar Association Attorney Referral Service http://www.sacbarlawyer.org
For $50 you can receive a 30 minute consultation. The Lawyer Referral Service is a nonprofit service sponsored by the Sacramento County Bar Association. You can request a referral either by telephone or email.

Advertisements
You also could check the Yellow Pages, newspaper advertisements or the Internet in your search for an attorney. Not all lawyers choose to advertise in the Yellow Pages. Lawyers may use ads to list their fields of law.

Print Resources
You can always do some research at the Sacramento County Public Law Library http://www.saclaw.org. There are numerous print directories and friendly reference law librarians available assist you.

Ask the County Law Librarian

2010-08-26T20:08:40Z

Welcome to the Sacramento County Public Law Library’s new column, “Ask the County Law Librarian.”

The Sacramento County Public Law Library has been providing FREE public access to legal information since 1891; however, many residents don’t even know about us. We hope this column will remedy that, educating and informing readers about the legal system and legal services and resources available for free or for a very low cost.

How it works: You come up with a legal question, and I respond, providing references to books, websites, or local agencies that can help you answer your legal question. I cannot provide legal advice – that is, I cannot tell you what you should do, but I can provide legal information, so that you will know what your options are.

Another thing I cannot do is interpret the law. I can, however, direct you to the text of the law itself, and to other sources – in the Law Library and on the Internet – that have analyzed and interpreted the law.

So send your questions to sacpress@saclaw.org! I will feature one question per week each Thursday here at The Sacramento Press. Questions not featured will be answered privately within two weeks. I look forward hearing from you!

Coral Henning, Director

Connect with us:

Twitter: @saclawlibrarian or @coralh

Facebook: www.facebook.com/saclawlib

www.saclaw.org

Council: All 39 medical pot dispensaries can stay in town

2010-07-28T05:15:45Z

The 39 medical marijuana shops in Sacramento are on their way to becoming legal.

The Sacramento City Council voted 8-0 to draft regulations for current pot dispensaries to legally operate with city permits.

Councilman Ray Tretheway was absent from the meeting. Notably, Councilman Robbie Waters, who formerly served as a Sacramento County sheriff and city police officer, voted in favor of a path toward legal and regulated medical marijuana shops. Waters noted that he had originally approached the issue from a “cop view.”

Michelle Heppner, a special projects manager for the city, explained after the meeting that the City Council intends to allow 39 medical marijuana dispensaries in Sacramento to apply for city permits.

However, the notion of cap on the number of dispensaries is still hazy.

Heppner said the council agreed that the number of dispensaries is not capped at 39. However, the council is not saying that there should be an unlimited number of dispensaries in Sacramento, she said.

Heppner told the City Council she plans to present draft language for a medical marijuana ordinance in late September.

Photo by Brandon Darnell.

Kathleen Haley is a staff reporter for The Sacramento Press.

Support for the legalization of cannabis grows

2009-11-01T06:04:02Z

Standing outside of a Sacramento medical cannabis dispensary, you might detect something in the air. No, it's not secondhand THC vapor — public medicating is prohibited in the county. What you sense is a shift in perspective. Public pressure is building for the legalization and regulation of one of the oldest cash crops in America: the plants of genus Cannabis.

The US federal government has held since 1970 that cannabis is a danger to public health and safety and listed the annual flowering herb under US code as having "high potential for abuse" and "no accepted medical potential."

"A lot of people are thinking that federal drug laws are arbitrary and now we're starting to see the translation of public sentiment into political will,” Assemblyman Tom Ammiano (D - San Francisco) told The Sacramento Press.

In 1996, California voters passed a ballot initiative, Proposition 215, which allowed the possession, cultivation and use of cannabis for patients with a doctor's recommendation. Since then, voter majorities in Alaska, Colorado, the District of Columbia, Maine, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, and Washington have passed ballot initiatives to allow seriously ill Americans to use cannabis.

In 2003, after numerous rewrites, the California Legislature recognized and further protected medical marijuana uses with SB 420. State legislatures of Hawaii, Vermont, Rhode Island, and New Mexico have passed bills that do mostly the same. SB 420 is unlike other bills in that it also allows for the formation of patient collectives — not-for-profit businesses that provide medical cannabis to qualified patients.

American Association for Medical Cannabis state director Ryan Landers had a hand in the shaping of 420. "Originally, 420 started out as 187, a bill that was more conservative and, I felt, would help less people. It was sent to the suspense file and I had this feeling it would be coming back, so I helped to rewrite it for greater patient coverage."

Before 420, several bills entered debate that would contravene Proposition 215. In 2000, two of these bills emerged. Former state Senator Maurice Johannessen authored SB 2089, a bill that would have limited the recommendation of cannabis and restricted patients to two indoor plants. It failed in the Senate Committee on Health and Human Services, its first committee.

SB 848, authored by former state Senator John Vasconcellos, would have placed harsher regulations on medicinal cannabis and was refused passage in the Assembly.

"I testified to kill those bills to ensure that there would be no misunderstanding," Landers said. "I want to provide freedom for the most patients possible."

According to a 2004 survey by the National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws (NORML), over 75,000 Californians have become cannabis patients under the provisions of the Compassionate Use Act (215) and the Medical Marijuana Program (420).

Physicians and medical professionals have been a vital source of support for the medical cannabis movement. Dr. Frank Lucido, a 30-year private practice doctor and respected medical cannabis spokesman, estimates that 1,500 doctors in California recommend cannabis to chronically ill patients. He said that significant stigma still surrounds the drug, however.

"There are two reasons doctors are hesitant to prescribe cannabis," he said. “First, a lot of doctors don't know the value of the drug because they simply weren't taught that in medical school. Second, many are afraid of the California Medical Board and federal law enforcement, even though they're protected by Supreme Court rulings."

Lucido believes that medical cannabis, despite its enduring taboo in the medical sector, has wide applicability.

"Every doctor knows they have about 20 slam-dunk patients that could benefit greatly from medical cannabis."

Full legalization is a completely different animal and Ammiano knows it. The state representative introduced AB 390 in March to a blaze of attention. Since then, the bill has failed to move through the legislature. However, Ammiano planned for AB 390 to be a two-year bill.

"The debate we're having is sustainable, it has legs," Ammiano said. "And it's way bigger than just me."

AB 390 is a bill of a rare breed: It is both a full decriminalization of cannabis for adults over the age of 21, and a plan to enforce systems of taxation to tap into the drug's booming commercial value.

This would work twofold by would generating tax receipts and reducing state expenses. The bill planned to institute a tax of $50 per ounce of dried marijuana sold by official retailers, who would pay no more than $2,500 for an annual sales license and $1,000 for a renewal. Further, the bill would free up state resources in law enforcement, no longer regarding cannabis users as a criminal priority.

"It's California's biggest cash crop and right now we're hemorrhaging money to prosecute and imprison minor drug offenders,” Ammiano said. “With the current budget crisis, this is looking like the perfect storm."

Cannabis activists largely support AB 390, though the seasoned Landers objects to some points.

"The bill started out ahead of itself," he said. "The profits and tax numbers it projects are based on the illegal price of cannabis. Once legalization gets through, supply will increase and prices will have to settle. A $50 tax on an ounce that costs $25, which is the final pre-tax price most people hope for, would be ridiculous."

The age limit in the bill -- that Ammiano modeled after alcohol regulations -- is also contentious.

"The age limit of 21 is entirely a concession," Landers said. "Putting cannabis into the same category of regulation as alcohol opens up a host of problems. Eighteen-year-olds could take the state to court and force them to explain why cannabis is more dangerous than alcohol, even though marijuana alone has never killed a soul."

Ammiano's bill has the support of San Francisco Sheriff Mike Hennessey, although law enforcement has historically been extremely critical of legalization. "I think marijuana should be decriminalized," Hennessey told SFWeekly in February. "I'd like to give more thought to heroin and methamphetamines and that kind of stuff."

The California Police Chiefs Association disagrees, having issued a 2009 White Paper that rebuked even the medicinal use of cannabis. The white paper characterizes medical cannabis dispensaries as "multi-million dollar enterprises" which are "often used as a front for organized crime" where "many violent crimes have been committed," fostering "generally unhealthy conditions."

But actual instances of crime in and around dispensaries is fairly rare, according to Sacramento Police Department spokesman Norm Leong. "Service calls are generally uncommon, he said. “And when we do get calls, it's the dispensary owners that call it in."

Ammiano sees a gradual change of mind regarding cannabis in law enforcement.

"There's certainly a mindset there, but there are cracks in that as well. It's not as monolithic as it used to be."

He also cited the late conservative economist Milton Friedman, who supported cannabis legalization and taxation toward the end of his life.

Outside of Ammiano’s efforts, activist groups are taking other routes. Two voter initiatives are circulating through California, both of which propose to legalize, regulate and tax cannabis.

The Regulate, Control and Tax Cannabis Act of 2010, introduced by Oaksterdam University, would enact largely the same legalization measures as Ammiano's bill. This would allow the pro-cannabis supporters to get legalization directly onto the ballot and circumvent any lack of political support.

"The cannabis regulating system we currently have in place has failed," said Salwa Ibrahim, spokesperson for the initiative. "We want to empower the state to benefit from something that's already existing."

Ibrahim cited other benefits that are frequently discussed in the cannabis debate. "We don't think consumption or crime would increase at all. Similar to prohibition in the '20s, the black markets [that] illegality has created would disappear."

Regardless of the outcome of any of these movements, it seems clear that the public dialogue on legal cannabis has taken a step forward.

"390 has done an amazing thing, and that's this: It ignited the conversation," Landers said.

With or without the blessing of the law, humans worldwide are planting the cannabis seed. The renewed question on everyone's mind is what to do with the harvest.

This story was written by former Sacramento Press intern Cheyenne Cary.

Medical marijuana activist Ryan Landers speaks

2009-11-01T06:01:56Z

Medical cannabis in California wouldn't be what it is today if it wasn't for Ryan Landers. The Sacramento activist helped to develop the laws, policies and realities of medical marijuana in a career of activism that spans more than a decade. He was there to help roll Proposition 215 into motion in 1996 and had a significant hand in crafting SB 420 in 2003.

"I live the cause," he said. "When I'm not out testifying or counseling or negotiating for the cause, I'm just home and sick."

He's a 15-year survivor of HIV/AIDS, a personal fact that he doesn't usually publicize partly due to prior experience.

Landers, now 37, became a member of Californians for Compassionate Use in 1995. CCU is the group behind the successful Prop. 215 ballot initiative that won state medical legalization.

"When we got started, the public perception was really different," Landers said. "As we were collecting signatures, people were shocked. 'What do you mean you want to change drug laws?'"

As a volunteer, Landers ran information tables and collected signatures at California colleges, the Capitol, bookstores and food co-ops. “The press was giving us coverage every night, and I started appearing on TV,” Landers said.

Prop. 215 landed on the 1996 ballot and swept through into law on a 55.6% margin.

Landers is no stranger to news cameras and microphones. His media skills made public figures of his friends Steve Connell and Jacqueline Mahone, who testified beside him for years. He has also worked extensively with activists like East Bay resident Dr. Frank Lucido and Sacramento attorney Joseph Farina, to whom Landers says he probably owes his life.

Getting a tattoo at 16 changed his life forever. He was diagnosed HIV positive in 1995.

He started medicating to help deal with the nausea and pain that the HIV virus and medication brought with it. Cannabis helps relieve his neuropathic pain and allows him to eat and keep food down once a day, even though he hasn't been hungry in 15 years.

Landers' activism reads like a history of medical pot. He testified in the California State Legislature against SB 535 (1997), SB 847 (1999), SB 848 (1999), and SB 187 (2001). He helped to author a revised version of SB 187, which went on to become the successful SB 420.

In appearance, Landers is not what you'd expect when you think of a cannabis activist. He keeps his hair cropped and short, reminiscent of his service with the Navy during the first Gulf War, and stays snappily dressed in three-piece suits on a normal day of business. He looks nothing like Tommy Chong.

The medical cannabis cause wound up making Landers a parent. As he was working with teens at risk of expulsion for cannabis use, he took two kids under his wing and eventually officially adopted them. David, 23, and Nate, 24, both graduated with their senior classes. More recently, they made him a grandfather at 37.

"In the end, that's why I could never walk away, when I thought about how many lives in the community could stand to benefit from this," Landers said. "If what I was doing was dangerous, or if it were wrong, I wouldn't be doing it."

(This story was written by former Sacramento Press intern Cheyenne Cary.)

In search of sleep

2009-07-02T05:40:38Z

Emergency overflow shelters shut down their accommodations to the homeless in Sacramento, including Cal Expo so the homeless took a stand Wednesday morning.

Hundreds gathered in front of Loaves & Fishes on the corner of North 12th and Ahern Street for a march to bring awareness to the recent closings of shelters and the criminalization of poverty and homelessness.

Event organizers expected around 200 attendees, but at one point during the march, there were counts of close to 1,000 people walking to 420 Richards Blvd., a vacant parcel next to the new police station.

Many of those participating in the rally who rely on shelters for a place to sleep at night said they are afraid of legal consequences for camping out on streets.

"There was a woman, six months pregnant on the street, and when the police found she was homeless, they put her in jail," said G.P. Bailey, an activist and songwriter. "That is a scary thing."

"It's a crime against people for existing," said Robert, an 18-year-old a recent graduate of Jesuit High School.

He endured the heat and 1.2-mile march in solidarity for the community of people he was immersed in as a part of a community service project. Robert spent one week living as a homeless person, scrounging for food and pedaling for money with the guidance of teachers.

"We come from a pretty privileged school and they want us to learn that there is more to life than that cloistered area in Carmichael," he said.

Another appearance from the ranks of the privileged was made by the lead singer of local band Papa Roach, Jacoby Shaddix, who lived in Del Paso Heights since the age of 18.

He mingled with the rally participants, held up signs of support with his family, and led a cheer for a safe, legalized camping ground for the homeless.

"My family was homeless for the first year of my life, and to be where I'm at now, I'm super blessed," he said.

Papa Roach has donated money to Loaves & Fishes, and when he is not touring on the road, he serves food there in his spare time.

Birte, a librarian at Loaves & Fishes, as well as a Danish immigrant, was attracted to the homeless environment because of her experiences in Denmark.

"Healthcare for everyone was a big difference back home," she said. "A lot of folks out here end up here because they didn't have healthcare or had big bills."

Tina Reynolds, the owner of Uptown Studios, expressed the need to reform public policy that criminalizes homelessness.

"We are working on repealing laws and making politicians aware of the situation," she said. She also expressed dissatisfaction with the various laws that prevent people from setting up camping gear, rolled up beds, and how these apply to everyone with homes as well. "You are not allowed to camp out in your backyard for more than one day," Reynolds said.

The issues at hand are not specific to the homeless population, they also affect the community in general.

"It's not one side, it's affecting everyone," G.P. Bailey.

Bailey feels the cuts in shelters are creating a ripple effect which affects more than those looking for a home on the street.

"It is affecting the police department," he said. "It's hard to hire anyone from the new graduating class" of the police academy.

Reynolds suggested a dome-like model structure on display from World Shelters that they hope to implement in the future.

"They have if for disaster relief, and there's no disaster like homelessness," she said.

The structure, which costs roughly $2,495, is made of panels of corrugated plastic, and is said to protect from UV rays and can be equipped with optional solar panel attachments. For $2 a day, people can live in these structures.

Reynolds said she wants to look for property within the city that is unclaimed and hopefully set up safe facilities. She described the ideal location as an inexpensive community off the grid that has access to services like Loaves & Fishes, water, toilets, showers and garbage collection.

"What I hope is that we'll be able to understand that there's a legitimate problem in Sacramento," Robert said.

To learn more, click the following links:
Sacramento Loaves & Fishes
World Shelters

Violations, revisions and contacting us

2008-10-14T06:07:28Z

VIOLATIONS OF THIS POLICY

Any improper collection or misuse of information provided to Sacramento Press is a violation of our Terms of Use and should be reported to privacy@sacramentopress.com.

If you choose to use the Web Site in any manner, your visit and any dispute over privacy is subject to this Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use, including limitations on damages and of the provisions related to jurisdiction and application of law of the state of California. We reserve the right to change our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use at any time. Non-material changes and clarifications will take effect immediately, and material changes will take effect within 30 days of their posting on this site. If we make changes, we will post them and will indicate at the top of this page the policy’s effective date. We therefore encourage you to refer to this policy on an ongoing basis so that you understand our current privacy policy. Unless stated otherwise, our current privacy policy applies to all information that we have about you and your account.

CONTACTING SACRAMENTO PRESS

If you have further questions about our Privacy Policy please email your questions to: privacy@sacramentopress.com.

(END OF PRIVACY POLICY)

Security

2008-10-14T06:04:42Z

SECURITY

We maintain physical, electronic and procedural safeguards to protect the information collected about you. Access to such information is restricted to individuals who need it in order to provide you a good experience with the Web Site. Employees who violate these confidentiality requirements are subject to our disciplinary process. Where third parties provide support services, we require them to conform to our privacy standards.

(Privacy Policy continues in next article, "Violations, revisions and contacting us")

Changing or removing information

2008-10-14T06:03:04Z

CHANGING OR REMOVING INFORMATION

It is important that the information we maintain about you is accurate and complete. If you have reason to believe that we have information about you that is incomplete or inaccurate, please write to us at: {431 I street, STE 107, Sacramento, CA, 95814} or email us at support@sacramentopress.com so that we can update this information.

(Privacy Policy continues in next article, "Security")

Intro, agreement and amendments

2008-10-11T09:38:19Z

TERMS OF USE FOR THE SACRAMENTO PRESS

1. Binding Effect. This is a binding agreement. By using the internet site located at http://www.sacramentopress.com (the "Site") or any services provided in connection with the Site (the "Service"), you agree to abide by these terms of use ("Terms of Use").
2. Changes to this Agreement. The Sacramento Press reserves the right, in its sole discretion, to change, modify, add or remove any portion of these Terms of Use, in whole or in part, at any time. Changes to these Terms of Use will be effective when posted. Your continued use of the Site and/or the Service after any changes to these Terms of Use are posted will be considered acceptance of those changes. It is your responsibility to review these Terms of Use periodically, and if at any time you find these Terms of Use unacceptable, you must immediately leave the Site and cease all use of the Service and the Site.
3. Privacy Policy. The Sacramento Press has a privacy policy that explains to users how their information is collected and used ("Privacy Policy"). A copy of the current version of the Privacy Policy can be reviewed by clicking visiting http://www.sacramentopress.com/site/privacy. The Privacy Policy is expressly incorporated into this Agreement by this reference. Your use of the Site and/or the Service signifies your acknowledgement of and your agreement with the Privacy Policy.

NOTE: You can find the next section of the terms of use, User accounts, software and content, by clicking on the link, or by clicking the green storyline tab on the upper right hand side of the page.

Intro, what we collect

2008-10-11T09:38:17Z

This document explains the information we may collect through the Sacramento Press web site at Sacramentopress.com (the "Web Site") and how that information is used and shared. When you use the Web Site, you are accepting the practices described in this Privacy Policy.

If you have questions or concerns regarding this policy, please contact us at privacy@sacramentopress.com.

INFORMATION WE COLLECT

When you use the Web Site and that includes accessing the Web Site to read it and/or contribute or edit content on the Web Site we may ask you to provide us with the following types of information:

Personal information you knowingly choose to disclose

If you a registered user me may ask you to provide us with certain personal identifiable information ("PII"), such as your name, email address, gender and any other personal or preference information that you provide to us (including for example your social security number and credit card number(s)). We will store this information in a commercially reasonably secure environment.

Web Site use information collected by us as you interact with the Web Site

When you use the Web Site we may collect your browser type and IP address. This information may be gathered for all users of the Web Site, whether just visiting the Web Site or actually contributing or editing content on the Web Site. In addition, we store certain information from your browser using "cookies." A cookie is a piece of data stored on the user's computer tied to information about the user. We use session ID cookies to confirm that users are logged in. These cookies terminate once the user closes the browser. By default, we use a persistent cookie that stores your login ID (but not your password) to make it easier for you to login when you come back to use the Web Site. You can remove or block this cookie using the settings in your browser if you want to disable this convenience feature. When you use the Web Site, we may track the kinds of things you did as you interact with the Web Site (for example, what articles you read and/or edited). We collect this information so that we can provide you a better experience visiting the Web Site including for example, to offer personalized features.

(Privacy Policy continues in next article, "How we use our information")