STORYLINE Local Man Fired for Feeding Cats

This storyline has only one article

Viewing thru of

Close timeline

1 of 2
close

No high resolution image exists...

Progress bar

1 of 2
Loading images
Slideshow image Slideshow image

Larry Ottoviani officially lost his job after seven years with the 7Up Bottling Company for doing the one thing that helped him counteract the anxiety in his personal life.

That one thing was feeding hungry cats.

“I love cats and don’t like to see them go hungry,” Ottoviania said. “When I’m feeding cats I can forget everything else for awhile.”

Ottoviani had been warned several times by his supervisor not to feed the cats. The official termination notice dated Jan. 4, 2012, stated that Ottoviani violated his “last chance agreement not to feed the cats on company time and/or company property.”

While Ottoviani does not deny feeding cats, he denied doing so during company time and on company property.

What was it that Ottoviani felt a need to momentarily forget about, even if it meant risking his job?

He is the father of a dependent adult child with severe physical disabilities and has also been coping with the effects of a debilitating illness afflicting his wife.

During the past year, his wife’s condition required several hospital visits as well as some extended stays. And after a tumor had been found on Ottoviani’s right kidney it required the surgical removal of that kidney.

Fortunately, job-related medical insurance covered most of the costs. Since the loss of his job, Ottoviani says he doesn’t know what he’s going to do. Even with COBRA, a health benefit provision that provides temporary continuation of health coverage at group rates, Ottoviania admits “I don’t know how I’m going to afford to pay the $400 monthly premiums.”

The 7 Up Bottling Company, a subdivision of the Dr. Pepper/Snapple Group with headquarters in Plano, Texas is a beverage production facility governed by the U. S. Food and Drug Administration.

According to company spokesperson Jason Genthner, “The FDA states that we must ensure that the grounds around the food plant under the control of the operator shall be kept in a condition that will protect against the contamination of food. Over the years we have seen an increased presence of feral cats on our property.”

Ottoviani believes that if it weren’t for him, at least in part, there would be far more cats on and around company premises.

In 2008, two local animal advocates, Linda Silva and Nicole Hutchinson, discovered Ottoviani feeding cats. When they saw how many cats there were, they immediately began working with Ottoviani on what is commonly referred to as TNR --Trap/Neuter/Return.

Alley Cat Allies, a national advocacy organization dedicated to the protection and humane treatment of cats maintains a website that identifies TNR as the humane, effective approach for feral cats. Feral cats are humanely trapped, spayed or neutered, vaccinated, and ear tipped (the universal symbol of a neutered and vaccinated cat), and then returned to their outdoor home.

The organization states that another aspect of TNR is that kittens and other cats that can be socialized are not returned but instead adopted into homes. These procedures stabilize colonies of cats since altered cats no longer produce kittens.


Hutchinson enlisted volunteers from the Sacramento Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SSPCA) to sweep and clean up shards of broken glass in an unused area adjacent to the 7Up Bottling Company before launching an aggressive trapping program.

Hutchinson said that between August 2008 and December 2009, 71 cats were trapped and brought to the Sacramento SPCA which runs low-cost feral cat clinics on the first and third Sundays of every month.

The costs for altering the cats were paid by donations from the volunteers and from and grant funds. Ottoviani took home some of the tame cats and kittens, later finding homes for them. He kept the ones he couldn’t find homes for.

In 2006, there was a similar cat feeding incident involving a farmhand employed at the Cornell University Animal Science Teaching and Research Center in Hartford, CT Harford, N.Y..

John Beck was fired for feeding cats on the premises according to a story posted on the Best Friend Animal Sanctuary Network webpage. Beck filed a 20 million dollar lawsuit against Cornell University, which then filed a motion to have the lawsuit thrown out.

Beck admitted that his lawsuit was a long shot and that it was filed “for the principle of the thing.”

“How do you fire somebody for feeding cats?” Beck asked.

Ottoviani still believes he did the right thing. “I acted according to my conscience”, he said.

Linda Silva agrees. “Larry didn’t just feed the cats”, she said, “He went beyond the call of duty and took responsible action. It’s unfortunate that this would lead to the loss of his job.”

 

Editor's note: Corrections have been made to this article after publishing. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Liked this article? Share it with your friends:

Conversation Express your views, debate, and be heard with those in your area closest to the issue.RSS Feed

edited on  February 1, 2012 | 12:27 AM
My article was recorded at two minutes past the submission deadline of the Journalism open. I stumbled upon a technical issue on the website during the submission process. I'm disappointed, of course, as I had worked very hard on this story. I hope that readers nonetheless will find this story interesting and of value.
5 1
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 8:43 AM
Heather, I found your story via a google news search for cat related articles and I shared it on my facebook cat page at /catnewsnow. A couple people said they will not be drinking 7up anymore. I hope Larry takes action to get his job back, or compensation.
2 1
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 11:18 AM
Heather,

We will accept your entry, but please know that we have support staff available to help with posting. In the future if you have posting issues (at a reasonable hour) we can walk you through the process. The email for technical or site problems is support@sacramentopress.com.
3 0
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 5:40 PM
Heather, I loved your article! However, I'm looking for a way to voice my opinion to the 7-up Bottling Co. in Sac. I know that 7-up has an obligation w/ FDA rules & regulations, but they could have most certainly come up with a better way to handle it, rather than firing a man who obviously cares for animals, and has a "conscience". I too am boycotting 7-up products. I hope Mr. Ottoviani sues them & wins.
3 1
REPLY
February 3, 2012 | 3:18 AM
I AM ALSO BOYCOTTING 7UP/SNAPPLE PRODUCTS!! I HAVE SHARED THIS STORY TWICE ON MY FACEBOOK PAGE. I AM A PATIENT ADVOCATE AND HOMECARE HOSPICE AIDE. I AGREE THAT CARING FOR ANIMALS IS A VERY RELAXING ACTIVITY--LARRY DID NOT NEED ANTI ANXIETY MEDS ...JUST TO IMPROVE THE WELL BEING OF GOD'S FURRY CREATURES. SHAME ON 7UP/SNAPPLE!!! NO PURCHASES OF YOUR PRODUCTS EVER AGAIN UNTIL THERE'S JUSTICE FOR LARRY AND THE CATS!!!!
1 1
REPLY
February 8, 2012 | 10:08 AM
Heather -- EXCELLENT ARTICLE! EXCELLENT REPORTING!! // I'm only sorry our paper (SN&R) didn't have this! // Very compelling subj. -- you went extra mile and showed how Larry's actions had larger reprocussions (sp)... Hopefully some atty will see this and take Larry's case?? -- Amy Yannello
0 0
REPLY
edited on  April 19, 2012 | 11:27 AM
Hi Heather, I believe you tried to contact me by phone “in regards to the article about the cats”

I have to say that it is very typical that I received not one response to my posts here. As well as I left my phone contact and e mail for this purpose.

I think Larry received help from those (so many)who are merely busy bodies and really lack the integrity to define the real issues that desperately need the resources rather than support a frivolous cause, such as a "man fired because he is feeding cat’s".
Many will be pleased to know that the Drug addict/schizophrenic “Cat Lady” and her boyfriend/pimp and their abused children have been evicted. Years after “trying to save the Cats” / hording cat feces, to the point of absolutely horrific.

The ( Keystone Cops) The term has since come to be used to criticize any group for its mistakes, particularly if the mistakes happened after a great deal of energy and activity, or if there was a lack of coordination among the members of the group. -Sheriff’s department ( Fair Oaks 95628 )allowed her to load up 20 of the cats in her automobile/kennel and drive away??? And return for many more over a week’s time thereafter.
The rest of the cats that did not run away (between 5-10) were trapped over a period of three weeks’ time by animal control: who refused to confront the hard issue head on while they could have.( Can you say Tax Payers? )
I asked to interview them regarding their epic failures over the past two years. (…..“But I was the one who filed all the reports and called you to come and get the Cats, after you dropped the ball, when the sheriff’s department called you yesterday. You told them that there was no reason to come out as long as the cats were not sick or dying etc.)
They responded “ We don’t have to talk to you Mr. Turner.
This is ironic because I did not receive one response to my post here as well.
So I believe it is just as well to also leave the hard issues up to (in contrast with the easy /mediocre) those who are chosen. For many are called, but few are chosen. Matthew 22 -14

If you ever want to cover a real story please feel free to call me 916 -961-6325
www.tridynamic.com.....................................................far beyond

Firstly, I do commend anyone for possibly trying to help another albeit somewhat of a one sided story here, However, as stated by "Linda Silva agrees" at the closing of your article, Larry "went above beyond the call of duty" i.e his paid position at his place of employment. I feel for the man because I too have a son with severe physical disability but anyone who want's to feed and help cat's can volunteer at a clinic or visit a rescue or simply work to save the cats on your day off without risking ones livelihood in the process.

The other side of the coin: My neighbor has a fixation with cat's. A large number of cats, and hoards them and their feces to the point of absolutely foul. I live In Fair Oaks near Hazel ave.

This story is similar,(related) in the way that she and her children have finally lost their home.( My research on the property has determined: foreclosed with currently the gas shut off. I spoke with the PG&E man and he said the smell imitating from the home was unbearable,he felt bad and he wished me luck ) But with no relief in sight for the family living in there nor the dazed and confused neighbors as foreclosures are dragging out for up to five years, and "squatting" is more and more acceptable in today's somewhat diversified culture.( I would not be shocked if someone starts a "pitch in and help" for her regarding possibly loosing all of her cat's and piles of feces. Although I would like to (( start a pitch in and help, any idea's ? )) see her / family receive Intervention, but that's probably out of the question as reality tends to scare away the trolls...... here ?.

Oh, sorry People, please realize the serious (Human) health risks involved with free(indoor /outdoor)and roaming cats (feces brought in on the bottoms of cat's paws,indoors or around people mainly). Google Toxo plasma Cat schizophrenia virus; contracted(spread) by cats to humans starting with host's such as rats and or birds- which is now becoming better understood through research.

At any rate, If anyone ( other bleeding hearts like myself here ? ) can help the large number of cat's being locked inside for most of their lives next door to me for years now, however, only to be let out to mate in season Jan-Feb (like right now) by the irresponsible (infected with the virus ?) woman. Her un- spayed /Neutered juvenile Cat's mate with wild and free roaming cat's that are attracted (like herself) to the stench emitting from her dwelling ( her master plan of course to keep the numbers strong.) Using feral cat's that scratch and moan and stink / defend the right to the chance to help her do so.

I am sincerely asking you to please help the ( many inbreeding ) cat's that lay down in front of cars( some are being ran over neighbors report backing over them.

God forbid helping humans or the innocent man children trapped inside this feces hole and subject to the schizophrenia / virus'( Fact ) transmitted through the cat feces.

Please do not waist time speaking to me about 95628 Sacramento county animal control or health department because these, after several cases # will never go inside ( without any integrity whatsoever )..... several cases dropped. They always say In an almost (scary)lobotomized way " if they are not feeding them at the front door then they are not in violation"......??? Case closed = years and years of stench and anxiety, and neighbors scared to band together but rather succumb to the conditions with our (broken) system as well as inside this home with no shortage of lame excuses like, "with budget cuts resources are not available" and from the neighbors,..... "I went to school with them,....They are on drugs,..... She's crazy and,,,,, I don't want to be involved" .

The best one was from the Local Fair Oaks 95628 law enforcement ..." I told you to get a restraining order".........LOL

Hours of research concludes, the reasons for failing to act are that people are scared,afraid,or can't smell very well along with my best theory of they may not know what the vertical formation of bumps between their shoulder blades are.( a spine )

Along with those who actually hoard cats become(immune) attracted to the cat and feces smell and actually get a form of (euphoria) high that has to do with releasing large amounts of dopemine (feel good) in the brain. So as time goes on ,(years) like any drug addiction, one needs more( Cat's feces ) to maintain the level of high obtained previously.Which will explain the infamous Crazy cat lady and the cat's locked inside a home.Far from a natural free roaming environment = animal cruelty.

Because of myself and family taking a stand over the years, most of the neighbors do not speak to us in fear they will be looked down on by the cat lady and her less than undesirable group of friends(on the street as well) that come and go at all hours of the night. Instead some neighbors tell us in secret they do not like it, but nevertheless refrain from waiving hi to us when Crazy Cat lady and her boyfriend / cronies are around.

Even the local law enforcement side with them.... (on several occasions, I believe, related to the schizophrenia. When they realize we have relocated a dozen or more cat's, our lives and our children are threatened ( "you will pay for this") and while some other (scared) neighbor calls the sheriff which come in the matter of minutes = between 6-8 officers ) ...... and they told us that "it makes no difference that you received 2009 Outstanding young Californian as well as several distinguished U.S. patents for your work with disabled children and with UCD MC -Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation " www.tridynamic.com ...."you are no better than anyone" i.e. crazy cat lady, her feces and the drug addicts.(criminal justice system) That is to say their bread and butter.

Please do not get me wrong I have three cat's and all of them are spayed. They even take turns sleeping on the fence to fight off the invading colonies that escape the Crazy cat lady's clutches for awhile, at least until till feeding/ breeding time.

I fear that there should be many more after so much moaning over the past three years or more.

My greatest (speculation) fear is that they are being consumed.
http://www.care2.com/greenliving/man-arrested-for-eating-cats.html
S.T.C. like S.O.S. Save The Cat's Please call me if you can help 916-961-6325 tridynamic.com@gmail.com

I have been trapping as many as I can over the years without remedy because I can't get cooperation from the cat lady, to fix the cat's she has.I believe she want's the great number of cat's to do what she has been (hoarding) with them ???

I just caught a large (moaning) Feral so the moaning by my bedroom window will cease for a while but I regret he has already done his duty. We are overrun by(abandoned/kicked out by the Cat Lady ) feral's. They then battle over the Cat Ladies lovelies and(dwelling) territory alike. I should be expecting a few more dozen in about a month or so.....around and around we go....where it stops.......??? ( We were also told by law enforcement to "move out")
0 0
REPLY
djf
Author thumbnail
February 1, 2012 | 5:28 AM
Hi Heather
can you get it in some other way or later? this is too good of a story to let go. Was this for the BEE ?
the more public aweness on TNR and the repurcussions of people NOT doing the right thing is essentil to get out to readers. Good Job. darlene
2 0
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 8:44 AM
This type of thing is getting way out of hand. What next fired for feeding a hungry child? Humans are responsible for the cat problem and when a kind human trys to help out they get fired!!! No more 7-up products for my family or household!!! EVER!!! - thanks Hollygirl
4 3
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 5:53 AM
I agree !
2 1
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 5:55 PM
Hi Five Holly! I'm with you! A great article by Heather....Social Awareness!
2 2
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 9:01 AM
Is this the seven up on Land Ave? Picket in front, this should make the local news. How disgusting. And you know why there are Cats right? The spokesperson left out one important element: Rats and mice are attracted to sugar. But you are not gona hear about rats and mice coming out of his mouth in relation to his product, he'll just talk about cats. I know, because I worked across the street for about 10 years. We always had to put out those huge rat motels and they would get filled up all the time. I think there might be more to this and the company needs to take responsibility for attracting the cats regardless of mice or rats.
5 2
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 10:20 AM
I do my best to represent a situation as accurately as possible which in this case had been compromised by stupid last minute mistakes, one of sentence structure and one more blaring which I must correct. Cornell University is not in Hartord, Ct., but in Harford, N.Y..
1 0
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 11:26 AM
We have made a correction to your article. We encourage all contributors to use our free copy editing by sending a draft to journalism@sacramentopress.com. Email support@sacramentopress.com if you have any questions about this process.

Thanks for posting!
2 0
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 10:53 AM
Is there someone people can contact to voice their disgust/boycott, of the company?
Also, does the story end here? Will the cats continue to be fed or trapped and either relocated or humanely euthanized.
We are working with a large company (equivalent to 7up Bottling company. They were told by the FDA they needed to get all of their feral cats they have been feeding for the last 10 years out of there.
Anyway, they contacted us and agreed to pay to have the cats sent to us (the responsible thing to do) instead of turning their back and letting the cats starve. Have you sent this article to all the newspapers, PETA or other animal advocates that can do something about this?
2 2
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 11:11 AM
I appreciate that there are compassionate and caring people out there who are touched by the plight of this family. If this story helps the Ottoviani family in some way it will have served a purpose. In fairness to the representatives of the 7UP Bottling Company they truly do have obligations imposed upon them by the FDA and had done what they felt was necessary to uphold those obligations. What I hope to achieve through this story is not to vilify any person or entity, but rather, to use what happened as a means of sharing various perspectives and another approach to what unfortunately is a very common problem.
1 0
REPLY
February 3, 2012 | 9:59 AM
Like someone mentioned before & what should be looked at by 7UP & the FDA, without those cats, what kind of mouse & rat problem would they have. These cats are unpaid employees for 7up keeping the area clear of filthier, disease ridden rodents. The sad part is what everyone is led to believe about how filthy ferral cats are, the truth is they are cleaner & neater than some of the people that work at the plants.
3 1
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 4:55 PM
Sure the company did what it needed to stay with in federal guidelines. But how about showing some concern for it's community and it's employees. How about finding a way to work with the local humane groups to raise some money to help control the cat situation. I'll bet other employees would have liked to give a little time to the effort. Sure would have been some great PR. Instead of just doing what regulations require you to do, go above and beyond and do the compassionate thing.
1 0
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 11:32 AM
In answer to some of the questions that readers may still have about the plight of the cats, there are some concerned people in the community that will be following up with this matter. What I think is greatly needed by all is a better understanding of the problem regarding feral cats and to work together on humane approaches to the solution. Everyone who likes this article is not only welcome to share a link to this article with others, but is encouraged to do so. My challenge to anyone interested in social change is to look at this situation, and others like it, and find positive ways to bring forth change. For instance Alley Cat Allies is well known for developing and promoting the concept of TNR. (Trap/Neuter/Return) When we start thinking about it, perhaps we can find even more humane solutions to this problem. Let's talk about that. Ideas, anyone?
2 0
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 3:35 PM
I want to extend my sincere gratitude to the Sacramento Press Staff for accepting my entry. It means the world to me.
2 0
REPLY
edited on  February 27, 2012 | 5:50 PM
Hi Heather, I understand that you may have tried to contact me. Please contact me at tridynamic.com@gmail.com if you would like to discuss anything I have written in response to your story. Local man fired for feeding cat's- In which I also understand news 10 or others have expounded further on. Maybe shedding a bit more light here.

Thank you



Jaysen
0 0
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 5:00 PM
With regard to Billy's comments above. The rat & mice situation would probably be many times worse without the cats living there. It is unfortunate there are not more humans like Larry who take kind responsibility for the creatures under our care here on this earth.
3 3
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 5:54 PM
The health department inspects food facilities yearly, and the presence of animals, even cats, could get the business closed until they brought them under control. If this guy had any sense, he would have fed them far, far away from this facility to help keep his employer in compliance with the code, and to help keep the public safe from contaminated food.
4 0
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 12:46 PM
As I was researching this article, I visited the area to see for myself where Mr. Ottoviani had been feeding cats. The 7 UP Bottling Company is a large complex made of several buildings in an area where several industrial type businesses back up to a nearby residential neighborhood.

The feeding areas I saw were well off of the company premises. I did not see any on company premises or near to where any bottling activity would occur.
4 1
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 6:03 PM
Davi...Did you really read the article?? Mr. Ottoviani DID feed the cats well away from the 7-up facility....Geez!
1 1
REPLY
dsl
Author thumbnail
February 4, 2012 | 1:03 PM
Kaseyshere that's what he is saying....this article is very one sided.
0 1
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 5:56 PM
I should also point out that some poisons are used to control rats and mice that might end up poisoning the cats when they eat them, so attracting more cats by feeding them is not necessarily doing them any favors
2 1
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 6:01 PM
You mean rats and mice full of High Fructose Corn Syrup?
1 0
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 6:04 PM
I still the think the company is fully responsible when their product attracts animals and to use this as as a scapegoat and to through a 7 year employee under the table is very sad.
4 3
REPLY
dsl
Author thumbnail
February 4, 2012 | 1:07 PM
I am guessing the cat food was attraching the cats not the product. I don't see too many soda trucks being followed by cats.
0 2
REPLY
February 11, 2012 | 1:33 PM
That's 'THROW' not 'through'. Where did you go to school?
0 0
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 6:58 PM
Good job Heather!!
1 0
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 6:59 PM
I would like to write a letter to the company directly to the person who fired him and need his name and contact info. also I feel this story should be told to the news media on tv and also try to get donations to help Larry and his family during this time.

I do agree that PETA should become involved if at all possible as I feel his rights are being violated and he was only trying to feed the starving cats, which the shelters have no room for.
2 2
REPLY
February 3, 2012 | 10:16 AM
Don't bother contacting PETA. PETA is completely against feral cats and feels they should all be euthanized.
Those involved should continue to work with Alley Cat Allies, as they work specifically with feral cat situations such as these.
1 0
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 7:40 PM
Larry needs the rescue community to stand Behind him and help him get on his feet. Just posted on my FB page
3 1
REPLY
February 1, 2012 | 10:16 PM
Good article - sad situation. I shared your story on Facebook where I thought others would see it to pressure &-Up.
3 2
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 6:04 AM
I think this is awful. Cats keep the rodent population down on the property ! I could understand if he were feeding cats inside the building but outside? Come on 7-Up !!!! I am a huge supporter of TNR program. I have helped 4 cats in my apartment complex get fixed and everyone is very thankful. No more homeless kitties, no more cats crying in the middle of hte night and no more fighting. I give them clean water and food daily in the back of my apt and even the manager is fine with it. I also have a disabled 14 year old son. My health is good and so is his brothers. No one underatands the stress and pressures of being responsible for a disabled child unless they have one in their family.
I do know this much, their son should be on SSI which automatically gives you Medicaid. There are state and government programs to help disabled minors. I would hope they have these programs inplace for their son. They need a well informed social worker help them find the support they need.
3 1
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 6:17 PM
God Bless You SLF.
2 0
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 7:30 AM
I am sorry for his situation, but are you all saying that the desires of a business to comply with rules about food safety should take a back seat to someone's love of cats?
3 2
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 6:18 PM
No, we're trying to say they could've handled it differently.
2 0
REPLY
dsl
Author thumbnail
February 4, 2012 | 12:20 PM
I agree with you estebanpajaro rules are rules. Why should this guy get away with not following them?
1 1
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 1:55 PM
Feral cats live outside, and being that they are human shy, they stay away from humans, they don't want to go into the building. Are they making 7Up in the parking lots, or behind their business? I hope not. If food from outside is getting into their product, then I think they have bigger problems than some cats around their property. With all these concerns, I can assume no one inside the 7Up building eats, or goes to the bathroom, thus possibly contaminating a possibly carcinogenic beverage. OMG, I live with 4 cats (and 2 dogs), there goes my health. Where is my FDA??? Far away, I hope.
1 0
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 7:39 AM
In the only scientific study I am aware of, it was shown that the presence of cats (but more crucially - cat food) resulted in more nonnative mice and rats. I know the conventional wisdom is that cats keep rodent populations in check but the reality is that they do not. Cat food left out to feed whatever comes along is never a good thing and public health concerns are real.

He should have obeyed the wishes of the land owner, and moved the colony to his own house or the property of a willing landowner. Moving cat colonies has been done when the owners tear down an abandoned building with cats or when land owners decide having a colony cats isn't such a great idea.

TNR does not work. The studies conducted by practitioners themselves show that the decreases are mainly due to the REMOVAL of kittens and adoptable adults. It's a biological fact that if you provide resources (ie cat food) cats will be healthier and breed in greater numbers. Because TNR groups can never capture and neuter the 70% of the cats needed to provide population reduction, it is a waste of time and money. If you love cats, build an outdoor enclosure on YOUR property and trap and remove them from areas where they are not wanted. Put your love and compassion to good use and house cats on your OWN PROPERTY. These are domestic animals that deserve homes....not just a handful of food every day. Cats get diseases and parasites, get run over by cars and eaten by coyotes. How is it HUMANE to re-abandon them after capture and neutering?
1 3
REPLY
February 5, 2012 | 2:55 PM
Which part of TNR do you not understand? Neuter/spay and stopping breeding is involved. It does work and has worked nationwide for well over 15 years. Food is put out in daytime, not nighttime. It is gone before wildlife predators are attracted. If this company allows their garbage to overflow, well skunk, posseum and racoons will visit. Rodents are in fact controlled by cats via predator play and delicious snack. I spent 4 1/2 years TNRing my own neighborhood. No babies for 7 years. Death through attrition has reduced my colony from 18 to 5 and they are fed and I DO NOT have roof rats, or rodents of anykind, nor do my neighbors. The cats, not poisions, have naturally controlled the rodent problem. Poison can be ingested by the many children on the streets in this neighborhood, pet animals can ingest and die. That's a lawsuit waitng to happen for every poison site and is not natural.

Man has destroyed the way of nature and those of us to try to reestablish the plan of Mother Nature get your foolish complaints. Get off your stick Mr. Do you even know your neighbors, do you even care about them? Or do you just live inside your walls and make up your own mind based on the internet? Try doing the work and see for yourself. TNR is the only thing that works. Otherwise get off your computer and go kill animals yourself. You take the responsibility and you threaten Mother Nature. See what comes back. Because she is an angry woman when you pull her strings.

Rodents carry disease, not cats. But you may carry disease also and it's called ignorance.
1 2
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 12:21 PM
estebanpaja, Thank you for your comment which had motivated me to seek out available scientific material on the subject matter.

From a study that had been published in "The Journal of Animal Ecology", researchers had tested a theory by introducing feral cats, as well as rats, to controlled study areas on small islands around New Zealand, in order to study the effect of these on nesting birds.

What they determined was that "the elimination of feral cat populations from such ecosystems could lead to a more severe negative impact on the endemic species, as a result of expansion of rodent populations once their predators are removed. Attempted reduction of the cat population of Amsterdam Island is alleged to have caused a compensating rise in the number of rats and mice." http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1046/j.1365-2656.1999.00285.x/full

As one reader commented, rats and mice are attracted to ingredients that go into manufactured food products.

While rodents tend to invade indoor areas where food ingredients are present, unlike rodents, feral cats tend to avoid humans and generally limit their activities to peripheral areas away from most human activity. This would suggest that contamination of food products is highly likely to occur as the result of rodents coming into contact with food ingredients and unlikely to occur as the result of contact with feral cats ( which provide the added benefit of keeping the rodent population down.)

When Mr. Ottoviani started feeding cats they were already present; he did not bring them there.

Consider also that he and others prevented countless litters from being born through the practice of TNR which ends the reproductive abilities of the cats. 71 cats were sterilized in just over one year. Mr. Ottoviani did state that he did remove many of the cats. However, he is bound by laws which limit how many animals are allowed per residence within city limits.

Relocating feral cats only creates a problem in the area to which they are relocated, especially if they had not been sterilized. Feral cats turned over to animal shelters are destroyed since they aren't adoptable as pets at the cost of the taxpayers.

TNR does appear to be a humane solution and the scientific evidence does support that feral cats do control rats and mice, which pose a more serious threat to food production facilities than TNR maintained feral cats do.





6 0
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 6:26 PM
Heather, I AGAIN appreciate your article. Not ONLY did you do your research, but followed it up by answering the aftermath questions that your readers had. I'm not stroking your ego, I just think it's commendable for you to also do follow up with your readers. There should be more reporters like you! Bravo!
3 0
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 1:45 PM
As previously pointed out, keeping cats (feral or otherwise) fed, healthy, and neutered on a commercial property dealing with any type of food is the best and cheapest insurance against rats and other vermin. It is utterly unfathomable that this gentleman could be fired from his position JUST for feeding cats. Instead of firing him, this idiot company manager should provide extra break time for him to help in the task of feeding these cats. Since THIS is his way of relieving stress I must say that what he's going through with his family it's a wonder he has not lost his sense of compassion. And to fire him on top of his family medical troubles? APPALLING!!! Clearly an unconscionable act!!
5 1
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 3:13 PM
Its heartless for a company to fire a person for the kindness he shows for animals. It wasnt costing the company money, he was feeding the cats in his offtime anyway. This goes beyond greed of a corporation, this corp like many is repugnant.
5 1
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 4:04 PM
Great job, Heather! And your research on feral cat studies was so right on target! I understand the dilemma this business has with the FDA and compliance but every "issue" has a variety of solutions, some of which are "out of the box" compromises. "Shifting" the cats to an area away from the buildings (which apparently Larry has done) and assuing the cats are altered and any tame cats or kittens removed should provide a "win win" for both the cats and the company. Also, something that often comes up in regards to animals being in the proximity of humans is the "disease" assumption. As you know, most diseases do not cross the species barrier so being overly concerned about some poor cat transmitting some dreaded disease to a human is almost entirely baseless. A human bite is more disease ridden and dangerous to other humans than what most animals would transmit. In any case, I hope that someone can work with 7 Up Bottling Company to find an equitable solution. As we all know, that cats can't be relocated and once again, they will suffer the consequences of people's inability to be responsible (spay and neuter) owners.
5 0
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 5:51 PM
Thanks for the well written article and for calling attention to this situation.
3 0
REPLY
February 2, 2012 | 8:23 PM
It is apparent that many readers sympathize with Mr. Ottoviani and would like to know what they can do to help him and his family.

I too am touched by what they must be going through.

It's got to be difficult for caring people who want to do something to help to not know what the best means of getting together to do something would be. Since this is an online news publication I'm not sure how readers wanting to do something could become involved via a public forum without disclosing personal contact information. Perhaps that is something that could be addressed by the editorial staff if it is even fair to put them in that position. I'm not sure what the rules are on that.


3 0
REPLY
February 3, 2012 | 9:02 AM
Great article, Heather. What a battle we constantly face in order to take care of those innocent creatures that have been forgotten and left to fend for themselves. Instead of 7-up taking a positive approach and commending those that have helped to clean up the area and control the feral cat population, they respond to this behavior by punishing this former employee and all those that helped this situation. I, too have heard people say they will not be buying 7-up or Snapple. Good job in responding.
3 1
REPLY
dsl
Author thumbnail
February 4, 2012 | 12:16 PM
How does anyone know what action Seven Up Bottling took before firing this guy? I think they did the right thing they have to protect their buisness and clearly this was a health hazard.
2 2
REPLY
February 3, 2012 | 11:09 AM
i am fuming mad. and i'm boycotting, signing petitions and sharing on facebook. i've been to facilities without cats. guess what they have... rats.
2 1
REPLY
February 3, 2012 | 11:16 AM
care2 just picked up this story. if anyone starts a chipin, i'll send it to every care2 friend i have. this man needs help fast. i wish coke or pepsi would offer him a job. wouldn't that make a great follow-up story. and i'll add that many of these facilities are too barren to support alot of birds, so you really only see either rats or cats.
3 1
REPLY
February 3, 2012 | 4:07 PM
It warms my heart to see how many people still care, despite all the heartlessness in this world.
3 1
REPLY
FV5
Author thumbnail
February 3, 2012 | 3:56 PM
And another reason to hate 7UP and all their products. Thank goodness I do not spend a dollar with their company. I uinderstand they want to keep the area clean...but now they are going to have a problem with other vermin because cats are needed to help control other disease carring rodents. I hope this man sues 7UP and wins. How much more can this man and his family endure? But I guess if he was a meth head employee they would find a way to "help his disease" and get him treatment!!! Guess what people taking meth by choice is not a disease it becomes an addiction then it's a disease!!! This man is suffering from major depression and is probably one step away from something bad...let's hope 7UP has not put that man in that place...and I think 7UP knows exactly what I am inferring to that is suicide!! I will make sure my household will not purchase anything made by your company. I will look up everything you make and it's it's something I purchase I will not purchase it from you again. Done!!!!
2 2
REPLY
February 3, 2012 | 4:12 PM
My heart grieves for this man and his family too. Therefore, I want to share with everyone that I did not simply write the story and then drop the ball on this needy family. I spoke with Larry this morning and though the family is now officially homeless I know of someone who is going to put them up in a hotel for a week. A copy of this article, as well as all of your comments has done much to lift his heart and give him hope. I can tell you all that he is truly grateful that so many have shown that they care.
3 0
REPLY
February 3, 2012 | 4:28 PM
This makes me sick! A company that would fire someone for feeding cats??? C'mon! That is a caring, compassionate human being! The kind of person you WANT working for your company!! You are losers!1 I too am boycotting your company and products!!
2 2
REPLY
February 3, 2012 | 4:36 PM
catherine, i would love to see a chipin. a lot of companies fire people who are costing too much for health insurance, and i suspect that is at least part of what is going on here, as disgraceful as that is.
i heard about this article on facebook, and i dont have much time now, but i will be sure to share this in the rescue world, and even if 7-up does the wrong thing, i think if we could get the word out people would donate a few dollars to help him w/ his COBRA. which would make the company look even worse. btw, i thought 7-up was owned by pepsico, but i could be wrong esp since sierra mist came out, maybe they sold it?
1 1
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 5:49 AM
Here is the website for 7-UP http://www.drpeppersnapplegroup.com/brands/7up/ which is part of the Dr. Pepper Snapple Group trading publicly as DPS. Maybe cat lovers en masse should boycott ALL Pepsico products as they own DPS.
2 1
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 7:25 AM
Maybe us cat lovers who also follow the TNR program should all start feeding the cats around the company, off their property anyway. What are these cats supposed to do now, starve? 7-Up will probably call in someone to remove the cats, and I bet it won't be by trapping...

I do TNR and set up feeding stations and maintain these colonies of feral cats. I have a few hard to catch adult females but now that I bought a drop trap, boom 3-4 cats at one time, move them into transfer cages, alter and then release. I received a ton a grief from local businesses, complaining about the cat poop, the cats you know what ever they could complain about they would. But after about a year now, all of these businesses well except for one, have seen a large reduction in feral roaming cats. They are colonized to about 5-7 cats per area, they are healthy and generally not a bother anymore. No one believed me, but now they are seeing a difference. Wish they would donate a bag of food now and then that would be nice but oh well.
2 1
REPLY
edited on  February 4, 2012 | 8:38 PM
What I believe would really help to prevent these types of "misunderstandings" between corporate entities and people doing TNR is a much broader and more aggressive educational campaign.

If people from the 7UP Bottling Company (DrPepper/Snapple Group) fully understood tthat it is not the FEEDING of cats that is the cause of the problem but rather the BREEDING of cats that is the problem, perhaps this may not have happened.

The only way to stop reproduction of animals is to sterilize them, which Mr. Ottoviani and SSPCA volunteers had been doing.

Before the 2008 TNR campaign began there were 71 cats. According to Mr. Ottoviani, by the time he lost his job there were less than two dozen cats left on the surrounding premises.

If corporate America had a better understanding of TNR, (Trap/Neuter/Return) I think there would be more cooperation with people involved in TNR efforts and people like Mr. Ottoviani wouldn't lose their jobs. Perhaps instead, they would be rewarded.

2 0
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 1:49 PM
dlmccraw, bless you for what you do, it is a thankless task. My mother sounds just like you, has spent 30+ years and thousands upon thousands of dollars trapping, spaying, neutering and feeding ferals. People call her to trap cats and fix their problem and barely even say thanks. In one neighborhood she trapped 10 cats, they gave her a candle, wow. How big of them. I know you spend lots of YOUR money on gas, food and vet bills, and you do it because you care. Thank you again for what you do dlmccraw. My mom currently lives on 5 acres with 50+ cats, she ends up with the ones that were shot, hit by cars, blinded, thrown out and left to die. All have vet care. But this is besides the point. This man did an amazing thing and he gets fired and thrown out on the street. The FDA rule sounds a bit stringent. Are there feral cats running around inside the building? I think not. Are there flies, roaches and rats and mice inside? Probably. And dsl, you obviously don't give a crap about animals, so why don't you go find somewhere else to play?
1 0
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 7:27 AM
Great article Heather! There are so many aspects to this story to invote great discussions on multiple, timely topics; homelessnes, "corporate America", TNR, compassion for animals, unemployment, etc. Keep up the great discussions and best of luck in getting this article to go "viral"!
1 1
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 11:43 AM
Thanks for your comment! As an update, it's already gone viral! Someone has also started a petition which has over 3,000 signatures so far.... People do care.
3 1
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 12:17 PM
Yesterday, a public response to an ad by McDonalds, in which they offended many dog lovers, caused McDonalds to pull the ad and issue an apology. That strategy could be of help in this instance, too.

Go to their facebook page and *calmly* and *respectfully* request that they reconsider the termination. (if we are brash and insulting, not only will they ignore us, it will make *us* look like the losers).

Some things to check out before writing--this company's webpage features the notion that they celebrate giving back to the community; something that Larry and the other feral cat volunteers were doing. Are they walking the walk when they talk this talk? LARRY should be celebrated not only for his contribution to the community, but also to the unimaginable strength he puts forth in the care of his family. If he's embezzled money or punched a co-worker, then firing might make more sense. But firing a 7 year employee because Larry had showed kindness to animals doesn't ad up. Here is the link to their community program: http://www.drpeppersnapplegroup.com/values/philanthropy/

I also just looked at their 2011 annual report, and found a statement that they are integrating the notion of company volunteerism to help their communities. It seems to me that if they really believe in empowering their employees to give back to the community, they have the CHOICE to consider Larry's activities to be part of this campaign...otherwise it seems very hypocritical.

"BY 2015, DPS WILL:
• Contribute a total of 100,000 volunteer hours and attain an annual giving level of $10 million in charitable cash donations, with the majority of support focused on fit and active lifestyles, environmental sustainability, emergency relief and community celebrations. In August 2010, Dr Pepper Snapple Group announced the launch of ACTION Nation, our unified approach to corporate philanthropy. The mission of ACTION Nation is to foster physically active, engaged and sustainable communities where our employees, customers and consumers live and work. ACTION Nation focuses on four key areas: fit and active lifestyles, environmental initiatives."

--this is from page 10 of the annual report: http://www.drpeppersnapplegroup.com/files/2011_Corporate_Social_Responsibility_Report.pdf

I hope that Alley Cat Allies and/or Best Friends can get involved to advocate for the man who advocated for homeless cats. They will all benefit by educating this company on the value of Larry's actions...and maybe get a little media attention to create more pressure on 7-Up to do the right thing. It's important to stand up for those who stand up for the animals, and also to help others. We never know when *WE* might need a helping hand.
3 0
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 12:42 PM
Here is the link to the facebook page for 7-UP

https://www.facebook.com/7UP?sk=wall
2 0
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 10:03 PM
That was excellent Animal Lover! I too saw that on their website and had been thinking how much this company could do if they were to take a positive approach to the problem.

Volunteers donated their own money to reduce the cat population around the 7-Up Bottling Plant; it cost over $1000 to sterilize 71 cats that would have continued to drop litters on and around company property.

There is a mistaken public perception that simply "starving" an animal keeps them from breeding. Mammals, including humans, breed and reproduce even during conditions in which there are extreme food shortages. Without the help of a human, cats continue to survive and breed if rodents and other vermin are present. What they can't do without human help, is to sterilize themselves, hence people like Mr. Ottoviani.

I do wish people would finally come to understand this process and would work together instead of against each other towards solutions that have been proven rather than on misconceptions.

The Dr. Pepper/Snapple Group has an opportunity here. If they would simply be willing to take a step back and to look at this situation objectively, I think they would be able to see how what Mr. Ottoviani and SSPCA volunteers did by sterilizing 71 cats was of benefit to the company; that what these people had done actually helped the company achieve their objectives of maintaining standards of cleanliness.

If they could see this, and admit this, then they could take a large leap and do something truly redeeming in the eyes of the people, they could stand by their creed!
2 0
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 1:18 PM
Here is the link to the petition. Please sign and share:

http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/reinstate-larry-ottoviani/
1 0
REPLY
February 14, 2012 | 3:01 AM
I mistakenly flagged this comment as 'offensive'. SO sorry, I didn't mean to do this.
0 0
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 2:30 PM
I thought this was an excellent write up. Thank you Heather. I manage a large group of cats at the local dump and another one at an upscale golf course. Cats are everywhere. Trap/neuter/return works. We need to support the people out there getting it done. This story needs to be told. Of course the rats are what attracted the cats ! Garbage and rats usually are what a colony forms around so if 7 up wants everyone to know they struggle with rats they are doing the right thing by going after the feral cat caretaker and calling a lot of attention to themselves !
1 0
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 2:56 PM
Animal Lover, I was trying to see if I could link from your comment and hit the spam button. not sure how to undo that. Thanks for the good info !
0 0
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 3:31 PM
This is a letter I emailed to the sacramento press.. >^..^<

To all concerned,
I hope you keep us informed, and keep this in the news about this terrible incident. I cant believe that 7-up would do such a thing as to fire someone for feeding a needy animal. I dont even want to buy any of their products anymore unless they give that man his job back!

These are hard times and this mans humanity towards animals should be commended not punnished. I am outraged to say the least.

Its obvious to me that 7-up has no heart!
I am boycotting them as of this minute..
I will email 7-up to tell them off too...
1 1
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 3:49 PM
7-UP "hides" any wall posts as soon as they're posted. But if tons of people keep posting they wont' be able to keep up with it!
2 1
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 9:17 PM
just copy your comments somewhere else and go back and keep reposting. :)
0 0
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 5:17 PM
News 10 saw this story here and followed up with an interview with Larry. The word is that the story will most likely run tonight at 6PM. If not at six then perhaps at 11PM, or maybe even both!
1 0
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 5:41 PM
Thanks for continuing to update us Heather! I think it's great you have been following this after your initial posting and hope you will continue to do so.

We have received several emails commending The Sacramento Press for breaking this story. However, we'd like to clarify that the author of this story is one of our many talented community contributors who voluntarily posted this article as an entry to our journalism contest last month.

That being said, we are lucky she chose to use our platform to bring awareness to this situation! At 7,000 views right now, you are doing a great job of spreading the word about this article. Thanks again for posting, Heather!
1 0
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 5:50 PM
You did a good thing by bringing this story to everyone's attention. We need more reporters like you !
2 0
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 9:26 PM
As I mentioned in a previous post, News 10, a local news station, jumped on this story which aired on their 6PM news report. The story that aired is why I stopped trusting some so-called news reporters long ago. To say that this report was skewed in favor of the 7-Up Bottling Co. is an understatement, which I think most people will be able to see.

News 10 needs to get their facts straight. Epilepsy does not confine a person to a wheelchair. Mr. Ottoviani's son has cerebral palsy, not epilepsy, as was stated. Factual errors are one thing however, omission of facts are another.

Notice the one cat that News 10 caught on camera near a feeding area? That's not exactly what I'd call a huge cat colony! The numbers of cats at 7-UP are WAY down and that's purely as a result of Mr. Ottoviani's hard work and those of the volunteers that helped him.

By failing to report on the accomplishments of Mr. Ottoviani and Sacramento SPCA volunteers after they had sterilized 71 cats, this omission, deliberate or not, gave the appearance that Mr. Ottoviani had worsened or even created the problem. How unfair!

As I had ALREADY reported and News 10 SIMPLY REPEATED, Mr. Ottoviani has never denied feeding the cats despite warnings not to. What News 10 should have mentioned is that after the warnings he MOVED the cats OFF of company property.

Mr. Ottoviani trusted News 10 when they unexpectedly showed up in front of the home that he is still in the process of moving out of. He lost his home after 22 years of living there and the family is now homeless.

Nothing like kicking a guy for having a big heart just after he has hit rock bottom. Thanks New 10! I think that's what many of us will now remember your station for. I know that I will.
2 0
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 5:28 PM
You should send this to Bret Michaels....he has a contract with Snapple and he's an animal lover. Maybe he would have some pull with the company. Another good person would be Ellen Degeneres, she would probably jump all over this!!
2 1
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 5:46 PM
Esteban - people could catch 70 percent of a cat colony in their sleep ! Someone should do a study but the colonies I have and those I see are more like close to 100 percent fixed. That's why TNR works. Because we care about the cats and help each other out. 7 up screwed up here. And the FDA should have no worry if the cats are outside the plant. Seriously, everyone always wants to blame the caretakers when they are the very ones fixing the problem. Give us a break already !
0 1
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 6:12 PM
Not to take sides but I am one to look at both sides and try and see the whole picture. All I see here are people bashing 7-up on 1 persons statements. Ok that is all fine and well. Who all knows this person and has a 100% guarantee he is not lieing to save his job? Who has seen 7-ups case against him? A last chance agreement is a final step not he beginning. So he was warned, warned and written up, he was warned, written up and given an Ultimatum. So this was not 7-up out of the blue doing this. I am not saying they were right or wrong, all I am saying is who here has the full story or all the facts to both sides?
Granted if 7-up has no proof he was not feeding them on the job yes they were wrong, but in a plant the size of 7-up how many cameras do you thing can prove otherwise if in fact he was lieing to try and save his job?
Please do not bash me and do not say I do not have a heart. All I am saying is reading the story I feal real bad for the guy but all in all was 7-up 100% wrong? I do not think so. Do I think they could have done things differently? Possibly yes but I have yet to see the story up to the last chance and what proof they have he was feeding them on the clock to decide if they handled it proper or not..
3 0
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 9:16 PM
If there are mitigating circumstances, the company should issue a statement by now saying so, especially given all the public comments all over the internet today. As yet, I am not aware of any comment whatsoever.

On Friday, McDonalds was taken to task by dog lovers across the country when an offensive commercial aired. The public responded and, within hours, the ad had been pulled and an apology had been issued. Perhaps it's just taking longer for *this* company to get it's legal ducks in a row before making a public statement. We'll see what happens tomorrow, but it's hard to give corporations the benefit of the doubt anymore. If there is more to the story, I'll be sure to correct my comments. Until then..........pressure for a statement.
1 1
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 8:37 PM
I read this story 2 hours ago and it has deeply moved me to respond.
This man with the weight of the world on his shoulders and the challenge of "HIS" everyday life.
He has locked himself in to do the right thing at any cost v/s his own wants and desires for "HIS" life.
He has values beyond compare, where others are weak, he is strong.
YES, I whole heartily support the decision to give him back his job and reconsider what an asset he is to your company.
Now There Would Be A Super Bowl Commercial to beat the pants off of Coca Cola $$$
When people are down, aren't you suppose to do the right thing and find ways to show compassion.
No one knows what life has in store....
Think about being in "HIS" shoes tonight when you go to bed, and your deepest thoughts before you go to sleep........pretty scary isn't it ?
I am 60 years old, a retired GM factory worker, in Kokomo, Indiana.
I worked in a 'Clean Room' where you absolutely could have no food, no drinks & wore all the safety garb. My husband while mowing ran over a rabbits nest killing the mother. Without hesitation, I got bottles & formula & took them to work in a coleman lunch cooler. On breaks, outside on the picnic tables, everyone fed a rabbit. I was later called into the general foremen office, and to one of my most memorable events, he was laughing & pleased & wanted to see the bright addition to our department. Laughter was plenty in our department & a new sign was put up No Food, No Drinks, No Silly Wabbits*
IF I've learned anything its that we are put on this earth to be the guardians of God's creations.
To Love and Care for our planet, and everything alive!!!
People In Power should of, would of, could of make a difference....
Please reconsider for God's sake to handle this situation with class...
I am now facebooking this on to my friends - > their friends -> their friends...ETC...etc..etc.etc)))
Sincerely Hoping You Change "HIS" Status to EMPLOYED, Denise Floyd






5 1
REPLY
February 4, 2012 | 10:57 PM
Destiny2sunshine - that is the sweetest story ever ! Thank you for sharing it ! I needed that :). The local news station missed the whole point of the story ! it was painful to watch ! Heather did such a good job that I just came back to re-read her piece. It is not about the FDA - it is about punishing a human being - who us already suffering - for his compassion and action to make a bad situation better for stray cats. But that wabbit story just made my night :)
1 0
REPLY
February 5, 2012 | 12:30 AM
Such a sad story. I'll pray for him and his family. I seriously hope 7-up goes bankrupt for their evilness. And the jerk that fired him, I hope he loses his job and home too.
1 1
REPLY
February 5, 2012 | 9:09 AM
Hi, Heather-- I am the owner of the "Boycott 7UP" Facebook page and was wondering if you have a way to contact Larry Ottoviani. I have tried various methods to find a contact number or email and have not had any luck. Anything you could share with me would be greatly appreciated. You may email me at boycott7up (at) gmail (dot) com. Thank you!
0 1
REPLY
February 6, 2012 | 10:02 AM
I have emails pending from people in regards to this and I want everyone to know that I am working as quickly as possible to reply to each one individually. Please be patient.
0 0
REPLY
February 5, 2012 | 12:14 PM
If Mr. Ottoviani can show that the feeding station where he is feeding is indeed off of 7-UP property, and that he was not feeding on company time after being told not to (that is harder to prove, granted), then he was indeed wrongfully terminated. There are FDA rules, as well as local health department standards, than any business dealing with products for human consumption must follow. 7-UP is completely within their rights to not allow feeding on company property. They are also well within their rights to prohibit any employee from conducting non-work-related activities while on the clock. The problem arises if he was truly fired for activities off their property, done on his own time. This smacks of a company using this tactic to keep their insurance costs down - having an employee whose family uses the health benefits to that extent raises the cost of insurance for everyone on the plan.
1 0
REPLY
February 5, 2012 | 1:55 PM
This is a disgrace for all humanity. Shame on the people who did this.
0 1
REPLY
February 5, 2012 | 1:56 PM
This is a disgrace for all humanity. Shame on those who did this.
0 1
REPLY
February 6, 2012 | 3:38 AM
Punished for being compassionate caring and kind! This company should take a leaf out this amazing person and promote it in themselves!!
0 1
REPLY
February 6, 2012 | 5:10 AM
Texas being Texas there may be employment laws in place which prohibit appeal, but, logically there would be an appeal process in place. Larry's plight may be eased if he were receiving unemployment insurance benefits. The conversation indicates some research independent of either the company or Larry has taken place. It might be that that research could be brought to light in a hearing, and it might persuade the authorities to release his insurance benefits. I can not say more, except that Larry placed himeself in jeopardy by ignoring the demands his immediate supervisors placed on him. Insensitive and uncaring they obviously were to Larry, but, were they? Larry obviously worked well within the system there at 7Up, so he must have friends there. 7Up was not about to permit the feeding of feral cats on their grounds or on their time. Larry easily could have adjusted his schedule so to feed them after his shift. As for on or off premises - what benefit do cats, feral or other, provide? The eat rodents and large insects, including snakes. Remove the cat population and there is a whole new problem for 7Up of how to adequately assure rodent feces and body parts stay out of the production of beverages!
0 0
REPLY
February 6, 2012 | 10:19 AM
I would like to reiterate that Mr. Ottoviani has "denied doing so on company time and company premises." A claim is just a claim unless proven.
1 0
REPLY
February 6, 2012 | 9:03 AM
Ok this may be a very unpopular opinion but..While I do feel for this guy and his family issues Im not sure we have the full story. 7-up stated he had been warned in the past for this very issue, so he KNEW what the consequences would be. Also 7-UP HAS to obey and follow certain FDA policies and with the law suit happy society we live in had ANY of these cats caused any kind of contamination 7-up would be held lible for not doing something about the cats on the property. I dont understand why if the guy wanted to feed the cats ON HIS OWN TIME he couldnt place the food OFF the property. I work with animals professionally and while I do love animals I also know the diseases they can carry and the danger if someone is biten or scratched. Sterilizing cats doesnt prevent diseases such as saminela or rabies. Ferel cats also fight and this can cause cats to get infection and even maggots when not treated. There are feral cats near my home and there have been SERVERAL times that I have found sick and injured cats near death on my property. One that was covered in maggots and was extremelly aggressive. Again I do feel for this man and his family but I also understand the company trying to protect not only the public but themseves and other employees.
2 0
REPLY
edited on  February 6, 2012 | 12:11 PM
Justme, I appreciate your comments, as all comments add to the discussion.

Clearly the problem of unsterilized cats is common throughout the U.S, and the world. However, your comments illustrate exactly what can happen without an aggressive and humane approach addressing this.

Most people don't want these situations to occur in their backyard or on business property. When these situations do occur, it helps to understand that ignoring the problem will NOT make it go away.

The problem at the 7-up plant existed at the time Mr. Ottoviani began his employment. This indicates that there was a food source for the cats. It has been suggested, most likely quite accurately, that the cats were surviving on rodents because cats are resiliant animals and though they may suffer, they can survive on very little.

The answer to these types of situations is NOT to ignore the cats thinking that the problem will just go away; it WON'T, as indicated by the situation you have described.

Trapping cats and taking them to an animal shelter to be killed is an option, but one that is distasteful to many people and costs the taxpayers money. Other methods are illegal and/or inhumane.

TNR (Trap/Neuter/Release) does appear to be one solution that is humane and effective even though it may not have the approval of all people. That may be simply because many people do not understand fully how it works.

The method of TNR only returns healthy cats, not unhealthy cats, back to where they were AFTER sterilizing and vaccinating them. When the cycle of reproduction ends so does the birth of new litters, which inevitably leads to a reduction of cats. Un-neutered male cats compete for females in heat, and that's where most of the fighting behavior comes from.

If you want the situation to improve, the only way it will improve is if you or someone takes action. ,

After Mr. Ottaviani and several volunteers launched an aggressive TNR program they effectively reduced the number of cats at the bottling facility, removing the unhealthy ones in the process.
It's a shame that company management didn't see this, unless, as some readers had suggested, they had other reasons for wanting to terminate Mr. O's employment.
2 0
REPLY
February 6, 2012 | 6:50 PM
justme....you wonder why he didn't feed the cats on his own time and off 7-up property? He states that he *DID* feed the cats on his OWN time and OFF of 7-up Property!! It's right there in the article (see below).

Ottoviani had been warned several times by his supervisor not to feed the cats. The official termination notice dated Jan. 4, 2012, stated that Ottoviani violated his “last chance agreement not to feed the cats on company time and/or company property.”

While Ottoviani does not deny feeding cats, he denied doing so during company time and on company property.
0 0
REPLY
February 6, 2012 | 8:38 PM
Heather did an excellent job in reporting her story, too bad channel 10 botched it up so badly. His son I understand has cerbral palsey, he fed the cats not on company time, I believe it was during his dinner hour, and the cats were there already 7 years ago when he started his job. He apparantly tried to do the right thing with enlisting the help of organizations assisting with TNR with no help from 7UP. I believe they wanted to get rid of Larry maybe because of health care costs to the company along with vacation pay, 401K, etc., he has adisabled son since birth, a sickly wife, and Larry had a kidney removed about 1 year ago. Isn't 7UP union? Where are they in all of this ? Shame on all of them. No more 7Up or Snapple products for this household.
1 1
REPLY
dsl
Author thumbnail
February 7, 2012 | 5:04 PM
News 10 got the facts...You ask where is the Union? The Union can only protect employees in the right. This guy may have done the right thing by feeding cats but when it came to following rules he failed.
2 0
REPLY
February 7, 2012 | 9:44 AM
Sipping on the "Un-Cola" right now....I support 7-Up and their decision....
3 1
REPLY
CJW
Author thumbnail
February 7, 2012 | 11:18 AM
I can understand that 7-Up has a concern about health; however, the cats have been there for as long as the facility was there and there hasn't been any problem to date. In fact, cats keep down rodents which would cause a lot more health problems. And TNR programs are so effective in controling overpopulation of feral cats that they would have been advised to support this type of program and be happy that someone was so willing to take care of the cats while controlling the population.
0 1
REPLY
February 7, 2012 | 12:55 PM
ARE YOU KITTEN ME RIGHT MEOW!?!?! not okay. sooOOooOoOooOOoo boycotting!!
1 1
REPLY
dsl
Author thumbnail
February 7, 2012 | 5:27 PM
After reading the News 10 artical I am even more baffled. Doesn't it seem odd that Larry continues to travel from Rocklin to Sacramento to feed the cats? He has no money, his wife and child are ill it sounds like his priorities are a bit off. He needs to let seven Up do what they need to do to clean up the mess he created.
2 0
REPLY
February 7, 2012 | 7:00 PM
This article is very one sided and seems like everyone is rooting for Mr. Ottaviani but no company with a union fires a person who has the union backing him. He can sue the company but will not win because for the company to fire him and the union not to say anything they must have lots of proof he is in the wrong.

Just a side note: I hate cats.
1 0
REPLY
February 8, 2012 | 9:18 AM
Unfortunately, I don't have the time to read all the comments in detail, so I apologize if these issues have been addressed. First, Mr. Ottaviani will probably be eligible for Unemployment Compensation. He may have to go through an appeal, but should make out ok. The other thing is that as of early last year, there was a way to get COBRA payments partially subsidized. Hopefully he will look into both of these things.
2 1
REPLY
February 8, 2012 | 11:50 AM
Thank you all very much for your input. I will pass this information on to Mr. Ottoviani and see that he looks into it!
0 0
REPLY
February 8, 2012 | 10:16 AM
EXCELLENT story/EXCELLENT reporting! You went extra mile and showed how Mr. Ottaviani's action's (feeding the cats) had wider reprocussions (sp) (positive), while imparting information about the trap/spay/return program as well. I'm wondering if an attorney might see this and take on his case...Even if Larry receives unemployment benefits, it's unlikely that it will be enough to cover his COBRA premiums, plus living expenses. / Again -- nice job, Heather. -- Amy Yannello
1 1
REPLY
February 9, 2012 | 12:19 AM
Thank you Amy! And thank you to everyone who has commented. No matter what side of the argument readers have taken in response to this issue, you have all added to the content of the original article making things that much more interesting. Hats off to all of you!
0 0
REPLY
February 10, 2012 | 12:03 AM
Just FYI, there has been a ChipIn started for Larry Ottaviani. For those who who like to participate, here is the link:
http://helplarryottaviani.chipin.com/larry-ottaviani
0 0
REPLY
February 14, 2012 | 5:41 AM
Thanks for the chipin addy. I find it sad that the moment you published it, the comments seemed to stop cold. Maybe the piece has just run its course, but I hope some people came back, saw the chipin addy and went to help. I've signed the petition, and of course, no more 7 Up or PepsiCo products for our family until such a time that they make it right for Mr. Ottaviani...INCLUDING giving him money for a new residence, etc. Such a sad story.
0 0
REPLY
February 14, 2012 | 11:48 AM
CarolinaD, I think it's possible that when readers saw the Chip-in link they might have gone directly there without leaving a comment. The Chip-in was started by a gal in Kentucky after she had read the story. I personally had nothing to do with the creation of this event, though, like many others, am happy to see this kind of support for the Ottoviani family.
0 0
REPLY
February 20, 2012 | 9:47 AM
I have copy pasted the article to facebook asking for anybody who knows a social worker or someone from corporate 7-up to help this family. I am not able to chip in, unfortunately, due to our own financial problems, but, I must do something to help this family-this story has hit the core of what is happening to many Americans (loss of job with family members who are disabled). What an amazing thing the girl from Kentucky has done to set up a chip in for Larry and his family and that will be good for a couple of days. The Ottavani family needs some big help, SSI, Medi-cal, disability, medicare, habitat for humanity taking notice, a letter to the President-It will be up to the people to save this family since 7-up apparently isn't taking notice to do the right thing. Heather, thank you for putting this article, that started out about feeding cats and has now been given to us-the humans-a gift, to do our best to help this family AND the cats. I wish there were more I could do. Heather, you might consider going in to public service? You are doing a great work.
0 0
REPLY
February 26, 2012 | 9:17 AM
Melmax, myself and others are helping Larry and his family....
0 0
REPLY
edited on  February 20, 2012 | 10:38 AM
COMMENT REMOVED BY USER
February 20, 2012 | 10:37 AM
Apparently TNR and relocation of the cats to a new community was all lies on the part of 7-Up. I am amazed at the deception 7-Up is capable of. "Linda Animal Reserve" doesn't exist!!
0 0
REPLY
Leave a Comment
User icon
Type your comment in the box below Edit your comment in the box below

Type tags into the box below. Use commas to separate your tags.

Please Log in or Sign up

Existing Members

Sign In Progress bar Forgot Password?

New Users Create an Account Here
Progress bar
Verification email has been sent. To validate your account open the link provided in the message.
There was a problem sending your verification email. Please contact support@sacramentopress.com
Progress bar Login background Tag cloud top Tag cloud background Tag cloud bottom Login manager background