STORYLINE Politics

This storyline has only one article

Viewing thru of

Close timeline

Task force takes on disabled parking placard fraud

by Melissa Corker, published on November 9, 2011 at 6:42 PM

Storyline: Politics RSS Feed

1 of 4
close

No high resolution image exists...

Progress bar

1 of 4
Loading images
Slideshow image Slideshow image Slideshow image Slideshow image

Abuse of disabled parking placards is no small problem in Sacramento, where a special task force is charged with tracking down offenders.

To help reduce the misuse of disabled placards, the Sacramento Task Force On Placard Abuse was formed in 1996.

According to Linda Tucker, spokeswoman for the Department of Transportation, the task force consists of specially trained parking enforcement officers who investigate complaints on disabled placard abuse and issue misdemeanor citations when necessary.

The city employs 50 parking enforcement officers, and two of those are full-time officers who go undercover to investigate the use of disabled parking placards in the city.

Tucker said the task force checks about 1,300 placards per year. So far this year, officers ended up confiscating 130 placards – about 10 or 11 per month.

There were 115 misdemeanor tickets issued during that same timeframe, Tucker said.

Being charged with a misdemeanor requires a court appearance, and the fine can be up to $3,500 or six months in jail, Tucker said.

“We take our enforcement of DP placard use seriously,” Tucker said. “There is a finite number of metered spaced and a lot more placards floating out there.”

According to the California Vehicle Code, getting a placard requires a signed statement by a doctor “substantiating the disability, unless the applicant’s disability is readily observable and uncontested.”

If a placard is lost or stolen, the owner can apply for a substitute placard without recertification of eligibility, according to the California Vehicle Code.

“We have people who steal our placards all the time,” Diana Derodeff, executive director of Inalliance said Wednesday. “People sell them, even.”

Derodeff said that, despite disabled placard abuses, it doesn’t seem to have an impact on the issuance of more placards.

“I’ve never heard of anyone not getting a placard because there’s too much abuse of the system,” Derodess said.

Some people intent on abusing the system find interesting ways to accomplish their goal, according to Officer Hatch, a parking enforcement officer for the city.

In a recent article for The Sacramento Press, writer Casey Kirk said Hatch “recalled one violator cutting the entire bottom portion off of a disabled placard, claiming it was issued to him that way.”

“Another instance that stood out (to Officer Hatch) was the placard-holder who extended his own permit, punching a hole in the current year and taping the punched out circle into the expired year,” Kirk wrote.

Derodeff said Inalliance transports many people with disabilities and when people abuse the disabled parking privilege, there isn’t room for those who need it.

Derodeff said that the biggest problem the Inalliance drivers face is people who park their cars either in handicapped spaces or in the spaces directly adjacent to the handicapped spaces.

Having disabled parking spaces more clearly marked – including all of the loading space needed – would be helpful, Derodeff said.

Derodeff said she thinks people who abuse disabled parking placards should be charged and fined.

City code states that anyone who illegally parks in a blue zone, puts a placard on a car to which it isn’t assigned, uses it without needing it or buys, sells or exchanges a permit is in violation of the law.

The state code has charges for additional violations, including unlawful use of permits or placards, parking unlawfully in a blue zone or blocking access to a disabled space.

“We are unique in that we are one of the few cities in California that charges violators with a misdemeanor for misusing a DP placard,” Tucker said.

Barbara Duncan, the director of communication for Disability Rights California, said reports of placard abuse are disturbing to hear because there are many people with legitimate need for the placards.

Duncan said that people tend to believe there is more fraud than actually exists because the majority of people who use disabled parking placards do not appear at first glance to need them.

“Many of them have invisible disabilities – back problems, heart problems and so forth. It’s not always obvious who is and who isn’t disabled.”

“People with disabilities worked very hard to get this benefit,” Duncan said. “We would like to see an effort to make sure that people who have legitimate needs for these placards can get them.”

According to the DMV, a disabled person with a parking placard is allowed to park for extended periods in on-street metered parking spaces, areas that require resident permits and on-street locations with posted timelimits as well as the regularly designated handicapped parking spots.

There are limitations to parking with a disabled parking placard or license plate, though.

Vehicles with disabled parking placards or plates may not park in the crosshatched pattern located next to a space displaying the wheelchair symbol, or next to red curbs (no stopping, standing or parking), or next to yellow curbs (commercial loading/unloading), or next to white curbs (passenger loading/unloading).

Privileges for free parking with disabled parking placards and license plates only apply to on-street parking, so a driver with a disabled parking placard parking in a public garage has to pay the garage’s set parking rate.

In residential areas, vehicles with disabled parking placards also have to abide by street cleaning restrictions.

Although the parking timeframe is extended for disabled parking, it does have a city-mandated final limit of 72 hours.

“The task force is a full program and a concentrated effort to reduce the abuse,” Tucker said.

Anyone can refer a tip about disabled parking abuse to parking enforcement officers, Tucker said.

“When people want to report something – anything at all, 24 hours a day – they only need to email 311@cityofsacramento.org,” Tucker said, “or, if they are within the city limits, just call 3-1-1. The complaint will make its way to parking and they will followup.”

Melissa Corker is a Staff Reporter for The Sacramento Press. Follow her on Twitter @MelissaCorker.

Editorial Note: Corrections have been made to this story after it was published. The spelling of Diana Derodeff's name was corrected.

Liked this article? Share it with your friends:

Conversation Express your views, debate, and be heard with those in your area closest to the issue.RSS Feed

November 10, 2011 | 11:00 AM
I think that if the DMV did a better job of verifying doctor's signatures on the forms, this wouldn't be such a problem.
1 0
REPLY
November 10, 2011 | 12:34 PM
Casey, do you remember this comment of yours from a 2010 UDA 4th Wednesday presentation?

http://www.sacramentopress.com/headline/22629/Urban_Design_Alliance_Hosts_Parking_Dialogue

"The thing that most stood out to me to the most was when Chan said there were around 100,000 handicap placards currently issued out in Sacramento and less than half the amount of parking spaces total. "

And state wide there are over 2,000,000 of these issued. Where I truly feel the legislature failed us in that they allowed these placards to be issued free of charge and provided free parking along with them.

The average commuter will easily spend over a $100 Dollars a month on parking...worse if they get a ticket. Other states charge for the issuance and/or provide a reduced rate for parking.

Something needs to occur at the state level to help balance out the impact of this parking giveaway. It's out of control!
3 0
REPLY
November 10, 2011 | 1:46 PM
I certainly do remember that and am still in disbelief at the number of placards issued.

I think that there should definitely be an issuance fee. Like you said, we need to find some sort of solution because it's not fair to those who legitimately need the placards!
1 0
REPLY
November 10, 2011 | 4:41 PM
Doesn't the permit application have to have real info like the doctor's license number?
1 0
REPLY
November 11, 2011 | 11:51 AM
Providing a front row, easily accessible parking space for handicapped is the right thing for society to do.

But we should question why we also provide free parking as part of this package. Unless your situation means you physically cannot reach the parking meter / ticket dispenser, this does not make sense.

If for instance there are 1000 handicap spaces in the city of Sacramento that are in metered locations, this is easily a $1M plus a year of missed revenue....equal to maybe 5 or 7 full time police officers.

Decreasing the incentive for placard fraud (ie free parking) is best local way that we can decrease the fraud.
1 0
REPLY
November 10, 2011 | 11:58 AM
I think a task force is a waste of time and will lead to unnecessary harassment of truly disabled who don't look disabled. I can't tell you how many times I've heard people say "but you don't look disabled" to my husband. My husband is only 40 and "looks" great. Looks can be decieving because he needs a kidney AND pancreas transplant and he does dialysis 7 days a week.

My stepdad is in a wheelchair but he will probably outlive my healthy looking husband (if he doesn't get a transplant). So who is more disabled and deserving of the placard Plus my stepdad doesn't have to explain himself to everyone who sees him park and wants to catch someone "abusing" the system.

They find only 10-11 parking placard abusers per month. How many healthy looking disabled people did they harass to get that. This seems like a huge waste of tax payer money.
0 1
REPLY
November 10, 2011 | 4:40 PM
Sounds like you haven't encoutered problems getting disabled parking space due to cheats. I'm gladto hear that. One of the big problems of cheats can be that people that really need the spaces don't get them.
0 0
REPLY
November 10, 2011 | 6:50 PM
There is a real animosity downtown to those who use DP placards. Not everyone with a mobility related disability uses a wheelchair or walker, yet if you are legitimately using your placard and are able to get out of your car under your own power people grimace and stare at you in iniquitous disdain as if you just ran over their puppy. People judging others based on appearance (of any kind) is wrong. When you are issued a placard there is an accompanying piece of DMV paper work with your name and information on it stating that you are the true and correct owner of said placard. I have no problem showing this to any parking or police official at any time (actually by law you must show this paper when asked) and placard abuse should be handled swiftly, but by law enforcement officials. So I must add; those of you on the street, please don’t glare menacingly at me because I don’t fit your stereotype of a disabled person. Thanks.
1 0
REPLY
November 10, 2011 | 10:59 PM
I agree, I get the same thing. IMy vision is so bad I can barely see past the hood ornament on my Plymouth when I pull into my disabled parking spot at the Old Spaghetti Factory.

But when I get "that look" from bystanders who expect that I should be on crutches or something, I just wack them in the ankles with my white cane. Problem solved.
1 0
REPLY
November 14, 2011 | 9:29 AM
Error Correction: The Executive Director of INALLIANCE is Diana DeRodeff
0 0
REPLY
November 15, 2011 | 9:08 AM
I know somebody here at work that has a doctor friend that gave him the approval for a placard. Has no problem walking in or walking up stairs, he just doesn't want to pay parking so his buddy gave him the approval. Sad. But this happens all the time.
2 0
REPLY
Leave a Comment
User icon
Type your comment in the box below Edit your comment in the box below

Type tags into the box below. Use commas to separate your tags.

Please Log in or Sign up

Existing Members

Sign In Progress bar Forgot Password?

New Users Create an Account Here
Progress bar
Verification email has been sent. To validate your account open the link provided in the message.
There was a problem sending your verification email. Please contact support@sacramentopress.com
Progress bar Login background Tag cloud top Tag cloud background Tag cloud bottom Login manager background