STORYLINE Weekly Reflections From Philosophy Night

This storyline has only one article

Viewing thru of

Close timeline

Gossip

by Stuart Campbell, published on April 2, 2009 at 11:03 AM

No high resolution image exists...

Progress bar

Loading images

The easiest thing in the world is to have an opinion about how someone else should live his or her life. There is a kind of stimulation one gets from sharing such outlooks, which is most likely the reason for the popularity of reality TV. We all come built with the apparatus to evaluate, label, and judge other people according to the set of values we have established in our minds. But the question is; why do we love doing it so much?

Is it because we enjoy the mental exercise of comparing and contrasting different life styles? Is it because we genuinely want to help other people get on track? Or is it quite simply because it makes us feel superior to other people? My guess is that for the most part it is the later. The reason is that on some level, of course, we all want to feel worthwhile. We don’t want to feel insignificant, irrelevant, or unimportant. It just so happens, however, that one of the easiest ways to establish a feeling of self-worth is by comparison. For example, if I believe I am more intelligent, powerful, attractive or whatever than someone else, then my intelligence and power is obviously worth at least something. It has value, therefore so must I.

But when we look into the experience of gossiping, for example, not just catching friends up on what has been happening, but really laying our opinions on people thick and heavy, is it not true that there is often a conflict in our feelings? On one level there may be the emotional stimulation that comes from feeling “right” or superior, but on another level -- underneath all of that -- there is often a feeling of tension, disharmony and even guilt. Therefore to hold ourselves above other people is often to immediately create discord within our own experience, and the reason for this is obvious.

There is always a part of us that sees the truth behind our actions, a second perspective, which sees that in a sense we are hooked on the stimulation that arises from judging other people. Just as it is with any sort of addictive behavior, however, the problem is that we begin to loose self-respect when we realize we’re giving in to a “drug”. This is because to give in is to ignore our inner voice in the process, to act against our own personal truth.

Ironically, therefore, in a hidden effort to generate a feeling of self-worth – by comparing ourselves to “lesser” individuals – we often erode that very feeling by acting against our better judgment, judging other people, giving into bottom-shelf stimulation. As a result, once the "high" has past, our self-image takes a dive, and we no longer experience those crucial feelings of dignity, self-worth and most importantly self-love. Perhaps this is why they say, “to judge another is to judge oneself”.

Liked this article? Share it with your friends:

Conversation Express your views, debate, and be heard with those in your area closest to the issue.RSS Feed

April 2, 2009 | 3:04 PM
I also think that people are quick to judge because they want to categorize people, they want to simplify things in their brain by assuming that someone is a certain way and writing them off as always being that way even if they do something that contradicts the judgment. This was a thought-provoking read. I admit that I feel guilty and almost self-loathing sometimes after gossiping with a friend.
0 0
REPLY
April 2, 2009 | 4:53 PM
Thanks Colleen :)
1 0
REPLY
April 2, 2009 | 5:31 PM
Most of what people condemn or disdain in others is projection of what they cannot or do not accept in themselves. I refuse to gossip or speak negatively about others which makes it hard to have a "chat" with others in this society, unfortunately, but is the right way for me to live for myself.
1 0
REPLY
edited on  April 3, 2009 | 8:42 AM
For me, it's not the "lesser individuals" who bother me. When I am certain that someone stands below me in the social hierarchy, it is usually quite easy for me to be kind to them. My animus is concentrated on my superiors.

When I can clearly understand why a person is more esteemed than I (he is more sexually attractive; she is smarter; he is more virtuous; she has more money), I usually have no problem coming to terms with it. The universe is unfair; get over it. But when I see that a person stands above me for no other reason than mere happenstance, then it is my duty -- or, at least, my pleasure -- to knock him down.

Gossiping, as you say, is usually counterproductive. It worked for Iago, but Iago was a villain. The problem with gossiping is that people see it as a skulking, dishonest and illicit behavior. It bestows no honor.

I want to add, however, that gratuitous gossiping has some value as sheer fun. Is there anyone who doesn't occasionally enjoy making a snide comment about someone's foolishness or vanity? A late-night talk show host is basically a person who spreads gossip in a public forum.

If you wish to demean someone, it is better to humiliate him in front of mutual peers. Like prison violence, this has to be done swiftly and without mercy. You probably will not get a second chance at it. Of course, social violence, like any other kind, should be done conscientiously and with an understanding of how it will affect others.

Happily, though, if you feel that someone needs to be taken down a notch, others probably do, too, and your actions will be appreciated, maybe even applauded.
1 0
REPLY
April 3, 2009 | 5:45 PM
Gossip isn't all negative in content - I talk about friends with other friends all the time, it's how we keep up to date within the larger circle. And we have a culture of celebrity worship in this country not just because some of us like to see celebrities fall from grace, but because a great many people idolize them and follow their every move. Whether or not you think that's healthy, it isn't based on a sense of superiority or negativity, and the gossip associated with it is based on accomplishment and desirability, not failure and condemnation.
0 0
REPLY
April 5, 2009 | 11:22 AM
That's a good point. There do seem to be healthy kinds of gossip. But do you really think those are the most prevalent? Perhaps they are, I don't know. But in any case, there do seem to be very harsh manifestations of gossip, and it is the psychology of those I am interested in here. Thanks for the response though.
0 0
REPLY
April 8, 2009 | 8:44 AM
I agree wholeheartedly. Thanks for sharing.
0 0
REPLY
Leave a Comment
User icon
Type your comment in the box below Edit your comment in the box below

Type tags into the box below. Use commas to separate your tags.

Please Log in or Sign up

Existing Members

Sign In Progress bar Forgot Password?

New Users Create an Account Here
Progress bar
Verification email has been sent. To validate your account open the link provided in the message.
There was a problem sending your verification email. Please contact support@sacramentopress.com
Progress bar Login background Tag cloud top Tag cloud background Tag cloud bottom Login manager background